2 ms·
> Incredibly, a primary such idea was censorship itself: those groups who partially defined themselves as absolutely opposed to banning socially intolerable ide
by throwanem 9y ago
> Incredibly, a primary such idea was censorship itself: those groups who partially defined themselves as absolutely opposed to banning socially intolerable ideas, are now the very same groups calling for vindictive suppression of socially intolerable ideas.
What's incredible about that? One tends to find that people advance the arguments which serve their turn, and arguments of value in obtaining power tend rarely to be also of value in retaining it. Complaining that there's something hypocritical in this may satisfy in some fashion I don't really understand, but it doesn't strike me as being an especially effective or worthwhile fashion in which to spend one's time.
(And is there really any hypocrisy here? I don't see it - as far as I can tell, the groups of which you speak defined themselves not as opposed to banning socially intolerable ideas period, but rather as opposed to banning those socially intolerable ideas to which they happened to adhere. Anglin's ideas, if we dignify them by that name, don't seem to fall within that range, and so I have a difficult time understanding how I'm meant to take this issue as one of failure to live up to one's claimed principles.)
- ctdonath 9y agoNo, those groups of which I speak did define themselves as opposed to banning socially intolerable ideas period. They were quite clear about all having the right of expression.