5 ms·
Shouldn't the market take care of this? Apparently there are colleges willing to "dumb-down" their curriculum to maintain graduation rates, but those colleges w
by taylodl 9y ago
Shouldn't the market take care of this? Apparently there are colleges willing to "dumb-down" their curriculum to maintain graduation rates, but those colleges will become a black mark on one's CV and so the good students would choose not to attend those colleges, right?
- sbenj 9y agoActually, I think the market has created this. To me it looks like universities have moved from things like subjects that represent the apex of current human knowledge (hard sciences, philosophy, literature...) to a far more vocationally focused curriculum (business, marketing, game design, hospitality...). To me this looks like a loss of idealism and a move towards a market idea of what sorts of things make up valuable knowledge. It also seems like a real loss of something important.
- spoiledtechie 9y agoShouldn't the market take care of this? Only if students can pick their HS, rather than be placed in one by their zip code. Bad schools, make bad students, but students can't leave bad schools, due to their zipcodes... Education reform on zipcodes is a MUST.
- ZoeZoeBee 9y agoSchool of choice has been the law of the land in most states for a while now. http://ecs.force.com/mbdata/mbquestRT?rep=OE1601 http://ecs.force.com/mbdata/mbquestRT?rep=OE1601
- brewdad 9y agoIt really depends though. In my state, schools will allow inter-district transfers but only if there are students wishing to leave the "good" school to attend the "bad" one. In practice, this means that there might be a dozen openings for 10,000 students who might apply to transfer. If you aren't a future Rhodes Scholar or Div 1 football superstar, there are no transfer options.
- FLUX-YOU 9y ago>but those colleges will become a black mark on one's CV and so the good students would choose not to attend those colleges, right? How many colleges can you name off-the-cuff that you'd never hire from? Do you actively follow every college to figure out if/when they water down their requirements? There is no information exchange other than the press and word of mouth for what you're wanting the market to fix. The other metrics, graduation rates and job placement rates, supposedly wouldn't be reliable statistics in your view.
- kenhwang 9y agoEasy, only hire from colleges that you know doesn't water down requirements.
- qq66 9y agoThis is happening, but unfortunately information is not perfect (a random hiring manager doesn't know that Cal State is loosening requirements but Oregon State is not) so actually the brand value of all state and community colleges is decreasing, which will have the opposite to desired effect on social mobility. CUNY has probably graduated as many Nobel Laureates as MIT undergrad, but it will be tarred with the same brush of "the average college graduate isn't what he or she used to be." A similar effect is happening in the US political arena where people are being called "-ist" for a wider range of transgressions than previously. Rather than increasing the political penalty for these offenses, the expansion of the terminology has actually weakened the associated opprobrium, because people think of being "-ist" as a less bad offense since so many more people seem to be doing it these days.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>weakened the associated opprobrium, because people think of being "-ist" as a less bad offense since so many more people seem to be doing it these days. This applies to all rules that govern what we consider normal behavior. When (basically) everyone is ignoring the insanely low posted speed limit the result is (basically) everyone driving the speed they feel appropriate for the conditions. When everyone knows a few gay people nobody sees the point to criminalizing being gay. A lot of people were STFUing because they were afraid of not being PC. Now that people are seeing people say even more extreme things than they wanted to say without being seriously punished they're saying those things too. Something good will probably come of all this but change is never easy or fun. It's unlikely that we'll return to a culture that accepts outright racism. Hopefully we won't continue to perpetuate a culture in which any attempt at having a frank discussion involving a touchy subject is not chilled by a fear of being name called as a BoogymanOfTheDay (e.g. racist, communist, etc).
- jseliger 9y agoShouldn't the market take care of this In some ways I think it already has. I wouldn't look at a degree as a sign of fundamental competence and I don't think most other people would either. Maybe that's overly optimistic.
- technofire 9y agoAgreed. Certainly nobody should be hiring based principally on a candidate's alma mater. A candidate should be interviewed to find out that they know what they need to know and have the skills required. Really, college education is mostly irrelevant in practice.