2 ms·
It's possible to fail "palatable, well meaning, everyone agrees to it", without also meeting or even approaching the nonpareil standard of general worthlessness
by throwanem 9y ago
It's possible to fail "palatable, well meaning, everyone agrees to it", without also meeting or even approaching the nonpareil standard of general worthlessness to which Anglin seems at such pains to hold himself.
The matter is in any case also, I think primarily, one of pragmatism. Even the most hard-line free speech absolutist can't defend Anglin without being made radioactive by mere association; thus, by his actions, he forces everyone around him to choose between principle and livelihood. It seems to me little wonder that everyone of import chooses the latter.
- angersock 9y ago> It seems to me little wonder that everyone of import chooses the latter. "First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out--because I was not a Socialist" and so forth. And no, the irony is not lost on me. Systems-minded people not blinded by ideology have natural sympathies to those causes, because the same mechanisms used to justify punching Nazis and kicking fascists off the internet can just as easily be turned against things that we care about.
- confounded 9y agoWhat does your systems-mind propose? Nationalizing all companies providing web infrastructure, so that they can be complelled to host curb stompings and child pornography?
- throwanem 9y agoAbsolutism has the virtue of simplicity, to be sure. The human world, in my experience, has not.
- stcredzero 9y agoAbsolutism has the virtue of simplicity, to be sure. The human world, in my experience, has not. The judicial system is pragmatically absolutist in its operation. It's quite complicated, it's not perfect, but it does work. The system of rights it's constructed on is necessary to prevent tyranny. Look up and read the history around the Magna Carta and the founding of the United States.
- zlynx 9y ago"Even the most hard-line free speech absolutist can't defend Anglin without being made radioactive by mere association" If only our education system would manage to teach logic. Instead we have generations of people who can't understand how anyone can argue in defense of one part without being part of the whole thing. It's as if "evil people drink water and you drink water, so you're evil" is an actual argument these days and no one sees why that is fallacious and stupid.