7 ms·
Reporter: Google successfully pressured me to take down critical story
- loteck 9y agoStory says Forbes and Google had signed an NDA prior to meeting with Google, unbeknownst to reporter. Reporter published confidential details and Forbes unpublished reporter's story, which reporter is unhappy about. Reporter appears to be deeply naive about the ramifications of Forbes violating an NDA. Reporter also thinks their axe to grind is against Google, when in fact it is against Forbes if anyone, for being a "news" org that signs NDAs.
- snarfy 9y agoYou need to read the whole article. The information was released outside of the meeting or the NDA. > Google's e-mail doesn't mention a key part of Hill's story: that she confirmed the information with Google's press shop. If I'd been in Hill's shoes, I would have taken that as a signal that I was free to report the information.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> If I'd been in Hill's shoes, I would have taken that as a signal that I was free to report the information And you would have been wrong. Unless the NDA was nontradirioanlly drafted, this is still an agent of Google's telling an agent of Forbes confidential information. (This is why it is important to consult with lawyers when such contracts are involved.) I agree, however, that much of the blame rests with Forbes' lack of internal controls.
- ubernostrum 9y agoI've worked for companies in the journalism space. Calling up legal to see if we had an NDA with a company before reporting on them was not exactly a part of the routine for the reporters. If this reporter had no reason to suspect NDA -- and the way in which press inquiries were responded to certainly wouldn't give that impression -- then it's not on the reporter.
- stickfigure 9y agoIt's "on the reporter" to keep their employer out of legal trouble, even if it means fixing things after the employer screws up. Or they can just do whatever they want and get fired.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> If this reporter had no reason to suspect NDA -- and the way in which press inquiries were responded to certainly wouldn't give that impression -- then it's not on the reporter She still violated an agreement her employer signed. If Google decided to pursue this, it would probably result in censure for Forbes. They, in turn, would seek to exploit the reporter's employment contract. Given the number of unknowns, it is difficult to speculate. She acted reasonably, given what she knew, though her reaction with full information betrays naïveté. TL; DR Forbes asking her to take down the article was perfectly reasonable. Her continuing to discuss it now that she knows it contained confidential information is not. Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal advice.
- DannyBee 9y agoWhether on the reporter or not, it would still be an nda violation, and that's a IMHO reasonable reason to pull a story. I'd also be wildly shocked if the presentation/information given was not stamped "Google Confidential and Proprietary". I have never seen one that isn't in this situation. That is explicitly done to signal that it's a thing covered under an NDA. If your company signs NDA's, and isn't telling people who may receive the information that "getting stuff marked confidential means it's under that NDA", you are eventually in for a world of hurt and contractual damages.
- wavefunction 9y agoShe identified herself as a journalist and no-one asked that the discussion be kept off the record. It's also impossible to violate an NDA you're unaware of in my layman's understanding. If Forbes had an agreement with Google it seems like Forbes should have pulled the article themselves. I assume they pressured the author because they don't want to own the responsibility they should.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y ago"It's also impossible to violate an NDA you're unaware of in my layman's understanding" You are wrong.
- michaelmrose 9y agoIt's impossible to be bound by an agreement others are party to. Its impossible to agree to such without being aware of it. You are wrong.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoIf your company is party to an agreement, you are party to that agreement. "Its impossible to agree to such without being aware of it." Same goes for laws. You do not need to aware of an law to be subjected to it. Especially tricky in foreign countries.
- michaelmrose 9y agoYou do need to be aware of a CONTRACT.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoSo not reading my corporate mails absolves me of all wrong doing? Splendid!
- slededit 9y ago
- rdtsc 9y ago> Google never challenged the accuracy of the reporting. Instead, a Google spokesperson told me that I needed to unpublish the story because the meeting had been confidential, and the information discussed there had been subject to a non-disclosure agreement between Google and Forbes. So Google is releasing news to news outlets and asks for NDAs? Then they threaten to sue for NDA violations. I read it as Google is using NDAs to control and force only positive "news" articles. If article is painting them in a positive light, let it slide, if it is not, threaten to sue. Did I misunderstand it? Cause that sounds pretty sneaky. > But an entity as powerful as Google doesn’t have to issue ultimatums. It can just nudge organizations and get them to act as it wants." Very true. These systems of incentives and constraints is what Chomsky and Herman's book Manufacturing Consent is about. Highly recommended reading. Though in this case (if I read it correctly) it is not really that subtle but more of a clearcut Politburo-style "news" control.
- delroth 9y ago> Did I misunderstand it? Yes. You seem to assume this was some kind of press release. It was not: Google was previewing a new unreleased feature to one of their big clients, and that feature preview was under NDA. It just happens that this big client was Forbes, a news website. Forbes then failed to uphold the NDA internally and ended up publishing an article about this, breaking the agreement. Google PR noticed and reminded them of the NDA, and the editor in charge of the article at Forbes agreed and took down the article. So evil.
- x0x0 9y agoNo one has disputed the evil bit, which is that google is leveraging their search monopoly to force publishers to use Google Plus. It serves Google very well to turn this into a debate about whether this reporter was or wasn't under nda. Regardless, the reporter's claim about plus is very newsworthy.
- awesomepantsm 9y agoThings that happened 6 years ago aren't really considered news...
- dannyw 9y agoIs no one taking about the actual content of the critical story? Allegedly, Google was penalising sites that did not feature the +1 button?
- pgodzin 9y agoWell the point of the story is building off the narrative that Google is using its power to suppress negative stories/think tank reports about Google. The article doesn't really give context on what information the story that got pulled had, and just that headline of "penalising" sites that didn't add the feature is hard to judge properly without knowing exactly what was said. I can certainly imagine Google trying to sell how big Google+ was going to be, and how adding the +1 button would drive users to Forbes for engagement and conversations. In such a theoretical argument, missing out on this engagement would set Forbes lower on the search results, effectively penalizing them. To me, this would be very different than an explicit punishing of sites that did not adopt the feature, which is obviously an abuse of power.
- koonsolo 9y agoWow, after reading the comments here, it strikes me how Google can do no evil in a lot of people's minds.
- Pica_soO 9y agoHN would cheer Hitler on as a come-from-nothing entrepreneur as long as Penemünde would launch new rockets and gadgets, and there was a good PR-Team selling it. The best way to avoid evil is not to look on manufactured news, but on actual power, and strife towards distributed powercenters, struggling with one another. Always, without ifs and buts.
- briandear 9y ago“It would be a shame if anything bad were to happen to your website traffic. By the way, if you say anything about this conversation we’ll sue you.” — Godfather Google when promoting their +1 WHY the hell is this not a bigger deal? This is extortion.
- michaelmrose 9y agoUsing search rankings as a cudgel to force others to promote their social network and to silence discussion of this is sufficient for me to want them broken up. Its easy to see that this could be misused to much worse effect. Personally I intend to migrate my domain, my email away from google.
- federicoponzi 9y agoIt's funny how this, at the moment, is behind the news “Google: it is time to return to not being evil” by 4 positions.
- adwhit 9y agoThe comments on this article make me absolutely certain that Google has a large PR team patrolling HN. HN may be fairly right-wing but there is an implausible amount of apologetics for one of the world's largest and most powerful companies engaging in plainly coercive behaviour.
- dang 9y agoThis violates the HN guideline which asks you to refrain from insinuations about astroturfing or shillage: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. On the internet, people are far too quick do this because they can't imagine that views which seem (to them) so wrong and dumb could possibly be coming from others in good faith. But the truth is that the opinion diversity of the community wildly exceeds intuitive estimates. The null hypothesis, therefore, when it feels like astroturfing simply must be going on, is that you're underestimating the good faith of others. It's super tempting to reach for the stick (PR! astroturf! shill! how much are they paying you!) but we know from experience that this degrades discussion quickly, and therefore the temptation needs resisting—hence that guideline. Real astroturfing exists, of course, but it's a quite different species than this common astroturfy warbler. If you're worried about it, we can investigate, but you need to email us rather than post comments about it. In this case Occam is even more active than usual because there's a particularly obvious explanation for what you're seeing: the tendency of the community to respond with objections to whatever gets posted. If the article were slanted the opposite way, so would the comments be, not because different 'astroturfers' would show up but because the people most motivated to comment are the ones who see something to pick holes in. Then others show up to pick holes in the way the first round of holes was picked—invariably leading with "I can't believe this community is so X", not realizing that they're motivated by just the same thing as their predecessors. This dynamic is a problem in its own right but for different reasons. Btw your assessment of HN as 'right wing' has the same cognitive bias—underestimating the diversity of the community—embedded in it. It's clear (painfully clear, at least to me!) that the opposite wing sees HN just the opposite way and has just as ready a supply of examples to point to. An anarcho-anti-capitalist story has spent the last several hours on the front page, etc.
- 9y ago
- r721 9y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15145176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15145176