30 ms·
They always have to find a new name for everything. It's not fasting, it's biohacking. It's not a tip, it's a life hack. It's not custom, it's bespoke. Edit
by SilasX 9y ago
They always have to find a new name for everything.
It's not fasting, it's biohacking.
It's not a tip, it's a life hack.
It's not custom, it's bespoke.
Edit: Aritcle title is "The Silicon Valley execs who don't eat for days: 'It's not dieting, it's biohacking'"
- lisa_henderson 9y agoYour first 2 examples are good, but "bespoke" is older and often more specific than "custom".
- freehunter 9y agoI agree biohacking is a stupid name, but there's a difference between fasting and dieting. Dieting is specially related to food you eat, while fasting is food you didn't eat.
- dpark 9y agoThis isn't a meaningful difference and it's also not really true. A "water fast" is a fast involving consumption of only water. Similarly a "juice fast". So a fast isn't just about "food you didn't eat". Fasting is also absolutely a diet in the sense of a diet as a state of caloric restriction.
- freehunter 9y agoA juice fast isn't a fast, it's another stupid name like biohacking. The literal dictionary definition of "diet" is "the kind of food an animal eats" or maybe "the types of food someone is limited to for weight loss or medical reasons". A "juice fast" is a diet, not a fast. A water fast is just a normal fast, since water does not have any calories and is not a food. A diet is not a state of caloric reduction, it's a description of the foods you're able to eat. A fast is not a description of the foods you're able to eat, it's a description of the act of eating zero foods and zero calories. If you're dieting, you're eating food. If you're fasting, you're not. There is an infinite amount of difference between zero and anything-but-zero.
- dpark 9y ago> A diet is not a state of caloric reduction I'm pretty sure you know this is untrue. Your own definition references weight loss, which implies caloric restriction. In common use, "caloric restriction" is the most common intent of a diet. Outside select groups (e.g. bodybuilders), "dieting" is exclusively a weight loss exercise. > A fast is not a description of the foods you're able to eat, it's a description of the act of eating zero foods and zero calories. If you're going to refer to the dictionary to support your claims, you should do so consistently: "abstain from all or some kinds of food or drink, especially as a religious observance." Keyword there is "some kinds". A fast needn't be total to be a "fast".
- freehunter 9y ago>I'm pretty sure you know this is untrue. I do not. You're the one claiming that "fast" and "diet" mean the same thing according to your own definition not backed up by anyone else's definition. A diet is the food you're allowed to eat. Literally everyone agrees with this definition. A fast is abstaining from food. Literally everyone agrees with this definition. There is a big difference between the two. A weight loss diet defines the food you're allowing yourself to eat in order to lose weight. If someone tells you they are fasting, they mean they're eating nothing. If someone tells you they are dieting, it means they are restricting the foods they're allowed to eat, but are still eating food. At this point I'm pretty sure you're just trolling me. There is nothing incompatible with our definitions except you claim a fast is the same as a diet and a diet is the same as a fast, which I'm pretty sure you know this is untrue. There is a big difference.
- coldpizza 9y ago> They always have to find a new name for everything. Advertising is not always about selling products. It can be about selling a concept. They find these new names to sell these concepts to the people who want to be "trendy" and "hip", and subsequently garner more following.