7 ms·
Lots of coastline is plenty windy. Why isn't there more offshore wind generation in USA like there is in other nations? My impression is that rich people who ow
by jessaustin 9y ago
Lots of coastline is plenty windy. Why isn't there more offshore wind generation in USA like there is in other nations? My impression is that rich people who own land on the coast have no taste and think that offshore wind generation is an eyesore.
- strictnein 9y ago> "My impression is that rich people who own land on the coast..." Yep. An example: http://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/04/20/cape.cod.wind.farm/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/04/20/cape.cod.wind.farm/index....
- ccorda 9y agoAt least with respect to the west coast: > Unlike the Atlantic Ocean, where offshore wind farms can be bolted into the seabed in relatively shallow water, the West Coast's continental shelf plunges quickly and steeply. http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-offshore-wind-20160703-snap-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-offshore-wind-20160703...
- olau 9y agoThere are efforts underway to develop floating foundations, but I believe it's still in the test phase with only a few turbines deployed.
- nicktelford 9y agoThe first major floating wind farm is being deployed off the coast of Scotland right now!
- olau 9y agoYeah, I remembered it as 4 turbines, but it looks like it's 5. So as I said, it's a test farm. But yes, it's real, production-size turbines, not small scale models. I should have clarified that, sorry. I don't think anyone is going to build a major farm until this one has been running for a couple of years. And they've figured out how to cut costs. Happy to be proven wrong, of course. :) Statoil isn't the only company working on floating foundations, by the way, although I think they are by far farthest along when it comes to actually putting a big one into production. For instance, the former CTO of Siemens Wind Power is working on a design. He's going for standard components and as cheap as possible. I wouldn't be surprised to see that in a test production in a couple of years.
- iheartmemcache 9y agoedit: Full mea culpa. Parent is right. Keeping this post intact since it still contains green-relevant information and some historical information that may be of interest. Big ups to Scotland for pushing this forward. The Northerners[0] are doing some clever things too like running their own municipal fiber after having their pleas being ignored for ages. The Danes have been at it for almost the better part of a decade[1]. IIRC, their national transport is 100% green 24/7 and has been for a few years now. They've hit events where 100% of their entire country grid was wind-powered, and are so good at it China[2] brought in Danish consultants for assistance. Here's a real time chart of their energy infrastructure (including exports to Sweden/Norway/Germany)[3]. As a MA native, I remember people on the Cape would joke about the "bridge tax" (i.e., anything coming into the Cape is ~25% more). I know until recently[4] their internet connectivity was horrenduous. Energy there is fairly intermittent as well. Hopefully, they'll pick up a few Siemens units (you can pick up retired Siemens Vestas units on ebay for < 100k that are rated in the 10s of MW!) and deploy a unit or two[6], if only as a PR stunt to make themselves look 'progressive'. A win/win if they can increase employment and bring jobs to the locals in addition to that energy. -- [0] http://gizmodo.com/5984187/british-farmers-install-their-own-1gbps-fiber-network-in-the-middle-of-nowhere http://gizmodo.com/5984187/british-farmers-install-their-own... "B4RN" is awesome. It's great to see what a community can get done when they ((apologies in advance:) broad)band together. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_offshore_wind_farms_in_Denmark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_offshore_wind_farms_in... [2] http://www.reuters.com/article/us-denmark-windpower-china/china-to-call-on-denmark-to-help-build-offshore-wind-farm-idUSKCN1BF1DX http://www.reuters.com/article/us-denmark-windpower-china/ch... [3] https://en.energinet.dk/#energysystem https://en.energinet.dk/#energysystem - Real time chart! Porn for green energy nerds like me. [4] Thier municipality started to offer gigabit through a peering with the Boston/North Shore providers to position their community as a "business friendly, gigabit ready" region in order to attract more businesses, rather than relying on the traditional tourist-town economy. They brought in some contractors to lay cable from Boston (or likely just North of Boston[5]) which is active now with tons of businesses using it, though I'm not entirely sure if the general populace has FttH. [5] IIRC Andover or Quincy or somewheres around there (http://nationwidecolocation.com/massachusetts_colocation.htm http://nationwidecolocation.com/massachusetts_colocation.htm) was one of the major peering points where a significant amount of NE traffic ran through. Traditionally it has great connectivity first due to all of the DARPA peering that occured around universities (MIT still has the 18.x.x.x class A perma-leased from ARIN). This continued through the late 90s/2000s with Verizon using those DC's as their major peer-points (which is incidentally why FiOS was rolled out so early in the Boston suburbs). [6] You'd have to deploy them strategically in a region that isn't going to interfere with the yuppies boating experience as they go to the Vineyaahhhd on the 4th. NE has the same NIMBY problem that SF has in that regard.
- eloff 9y agoThere's a floating wind farm being deployed off Scotland, so this could be possible in the future: http://www.bbc.com/news/business-40699979 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-40699979
- dmix 9y agoThose "floating" wind turbines are still bolted to the seabed (so they don't float away) and are interconnected with wires. They showed how they work via infographics on their website that was on the HN frontpage recently. So the OP's comment about the sloping sea shelf is still relevant.
- jerven 9y agoNot as much as before, because the cost of cable to hold down the turbine is the only thing that gets more expensive with deeper water (the part connecting the floater to the "bolt"). These cables are relatively cheap. The other option's jackets or monopiles (95% of the market) require almost a 500 kg of steel extra per meter (very rough guideline). This means that at depths more than 25meter the monopile/jacket is more expensive than the wind turbine on top. With the hywind style floaters, this is not the case.
- throwaway613834 9y agoWhat's the reason for going offshore? Is the wind not as strong on land?
- sandworm101 9y agoFewer issues re land owners. Wind tends to be more steady at sea.
- philipkglass 9y agoOffshore you can install bigger turbines, because sea transportation of turbine components is not size-limited like rail/road transport. Taller turbines help to reach wind resources that are stronger and steadier. Also, even at the same height, offshore wind resources are often better than they are a few km inland. Finally, offshore wind can supply power to densely populated coastal areas when there isn't room to build turbines on land. The disadvantages are higher construction and maintenance costs; waves and salt water are much more challenging to materials than the ordinary conditions onshore turbine towers experience.
- throwaway613834 9y agoGreat, thank you!
- edejong 9y agoPerfect answer. Another reason, which kind of joins with the density of the population is the significant noise pollution of larger wind farms.
- greglindahl 9y agoMost cities are on the coast, so offshore offers generation near where it's needed. Doing offshore does not mean ignoring on-shore. In some cases offshore winds are strong enough that on-shore turbines are less cost effective. That's true for some of the east coast of the US.
- Tomte 9y agoNo people complaining about noise, moving shadows and bad aesthetics there.
- jxramos 9y agoThere was an interesting City Journal article about fishermen getting in the mix that caught me by surprise in an interested party that never occurred to me before. City Journal has good historical background and context that they gather up on subjects too... "The mounting opposition to the development of offshore wind in Long Island’s waters is the latest example of the growing conflict between renewable-energy promoters and rural residents. Cuomo and climate-change activists love the idea of wind energy, but they’re not the ones having 500-, 600-, or even 700-foot-high wind turbines built in their neighborhoods or on top of their prime fishing spots. The backlash against Big Wind is evident in the numbers: since 2015, about 160 government entities, from Maine to California, have rejected or restricted wind projects. One recent example: on May 2, voters in three Michigan counties went to the polls to vote on wind-related ballot initiatives. Big Wind lost on every initiative." https://www.city-journal.org/html/bonackers-vs-big-wind-15333.html https://www.city-journal.org/html/bonackers-vs-big-wind-1533...
- notatoad 9y ago"'Not even Superman standing on Montauk Point could see these wind farms,' he said. Maybe not; and maybe wealthy beachfront homeowners won’t be able to see the proposed turbines, but lots of fishermen will. And that has them spoiling for a fight." seriously? Why on earth does it matter if fishermen see wind farms? when did we invent the rule that all energy generation needs to be invisible?
- yuliyp 9y agoThe point is that they fear that fish will be scared away from the area by the presence of the turbines.
- notatoad 9y agoIs there any evidence to suggest that's the case though? A quick google suggests the opposite to be true. [1] This reminds me of the middle-america folks who were claiming the wind turbines near their houses caused all kinds of disease, including somebody who claimed the wind turbines were causing people to contract aids. Not sure if it's just an unfounded fear of new things, or if it's a concerted effort by the fossil fuel lobby, but people really like to hate wind power. [1] http://www.aqua.dtu.dk/english/News/2012/04/120410_Fish-thriving-around-wind-farms http://www.aqua.dtu.dk/english/News/2012/04/120410_Fish-thri...
- samcheng 9y agoOffshore wind is considerably more expensive to build, maintain, and interconnect. This article suggests that offshore wind is 3X as expensive as onshore wind: http://www.windpowermonthly.com/article/1380738/global-costs-analysis-year-offshore-wind-costs-fell http://www.windpowermonthly.com/article/1380738/global-costs... That puts offshore wind as more expensive than gas turbines, for example. And that's assuming an offshore wind project could get past NIMBY opposition. There's a lot more land in the Midwest than there is coastline.
- olau 9y agoWithout floating foundations, offshore depends a lot on the specifics of the oceanbed. But DONG Energy, which I think is the world biggest developer of offshore wind, recently gave a bid on a subsidy of zero for a farm near Germany. Final investment decision is still in a couple of years so they may pull out of the bid if things don't develop as expected, but not without paying a big fee. So offshore is expected to get cheaper. There's a comparison with nuclear down in the thread. I think one important thing to keep in mind here is that these cost reductions coming from industrialization and improved economies of scale are REAL. They happen year over year, has happened for decades, and they will surely lower the price even further in the future. Just like solar. And battery tech for that matter. It's incremental improvements.
- Theodores 9y agoBut what happens if you have a place like the North Sea surrounded by facilities for deploying oil rigs and associated infrastructure, for the oil to run out? There is considerable sunk cost in the infrastructure and with some subsidies to keep yards busy (as such things are needed for national security reasons) it all becomes a lot easier.
- nnfy 9y agoYeah, that'll convince them to our side! Let's insult of their taste! Never mind that taste is subjective, and you cannot deny that modern wind turbines don't exactly blend with the natural horizon, be it sky, mountain, or forest...
- freehunter 9y agoWell to be fair, skyscrapers don't blend with the horizon. Cell towers don't blend with the horizon. Cooling towers and smokestacks don't blend with the horizon. The nice thing with coal and nuclear power is that rich people can push it's production to poorer areas and forget that there are major externalities to allow them to flip a light switch. Rejecting wind power because it [insert reason here] is just saying "make the poor people deal with it". It is quite literally one of the most selfish decisions anyone can make, to force the world to stay on coal power because wind turbines "don't blend with the horizon".
- nnfy 9y agoNo. Don't make this a class warfare thing. The nice thing about nuclear/coal power plants is that you dont have to pepper the horizon with them. There is substantially less visual impact, and with nuclear, far less spatial footprint. And plenty of people, rich and poor, oppose skyscraper construction because of view loss. What is with this inane contemporary idea that we should not be able to use wealth to improve our quality of life? This is the ultimate form of empty virtue signaling. Why haven't you built a turbine on your property yet? I'd venture to guess that you're a well off developer, making you top 1% of the global population... But it's ok, so long as you have your own 1% to sneer at, right? It's their fault that we dont have turbines! Classism can be used for the same kind of scapegoating that racism and sexism are.
- freehunter 9y agoBecause here's the argument: I need power. Right now I get that power from coal plants. That's bad, right? I think that's bad. Let's not do that. Oh, you mean to get wind power you need to put the windmill somewhere windy? But my house is windy! Nah, let's keep the coal, at least I can't see it from my house. The inane contemporary argument is that you can use wealth to improve your quality of life. Like not burning coal to make electricity. Arguing that you'd rather stay on coal power than see a windmill isn't trying to improve your quality of life, it's actively destroying someone else's quality of life. But the lungs of a poor person are worth less than the view of a rich person, so that's what happens. At least coal doesn't "pepper the landscape?" Jesus christ, man. No one is asking you to put a turbine in your backyard, you're just throwing a fit about the hypothetical potential to maybe possibly one day cast a glance at one, and rejecting the idea on that basis. Did you know meat comes from dead animals too? Yeah, really pretty view from inside a bubble. Real nice horizon.
- KVFinn 9y ago>Lots of coastline is plenty windy. Why isn't there more offshore wind generation in USA like there is in other nations? My impression is that rich people who own land on the coast have no taste and think that offshore wind generation is an eyesore. Offshore has promise but it's significantly higher in cost and there isn't a lot of long term data on how well they hold up yet.
- will_hughes 9y ago> there isn't a lot of long term data on how well they hold up yet. Whats your definition of long term? 26 years[1] is definitely getting there for me. A part of the reason for that first farm being decomissioned is because new generation turbines are capable of generating more energy than the entire farm[2]. So maintenance costs per kWh are higher than the new gear. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vindeby_Offshore_Wind_Farm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vindeby_Offshore_Wind_Farm [2] http://www.4coffshore.com/windfarms/dong-to-dismantle-vindeby-nid3279.html http://www.4coffshore.com/windfarms/dong-to-dismantle-vindeb...
- TomK32 9y agoNow you are talking Florida home owners vs boat live-aboards.
- prbuckley 9y agoDoes anyone know what the status of using kite powered systems for off shore power generation is? I know makani has been working on that for over a decade now, it always seemed like a really promising approach to me but I haven't heard of any commercial applications of it. Here is a link to makani... https://x.company/makani/about/ https://x.company/makani/about/
- flogic 9y agoKite power is one of my pet hopes. I keep hoping it will gain some significant traction. Looks like there may be a a test power installation going up in Scotland https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/kite-power-station-scotland-wind-turbine-plant-electricity-a7348576.html https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/kite-power-station...
- kbart 9y agoWhat happens to these kite power stations when there's no wind to keep them flying?
- isostatic 9y agoWhen the jet stream dies we have bigger problems than a small drop in electrical production.
- eosophos 9y agolike what else?
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoThe Makani ones that Google were funding are basically wing shaped drone planes on a tether, usually the rotors on the front of the wing turn in the wind to generate power but they use their rotors running backwards under power provided by the tether to land vertically back at the base when there's no wind.
- specialist 9y agoI was shocked how windy Cleveland is. I'm told Chicago is more so. Windy city indeed. If its pratical to put wind farms in the North Sea off the coast of Scotland, I'm guessing using the Great Lakes would be too.
- cr1895 9y agoSome reasons: - (lack of) political will - abundance of cheap natural gas - lack of US expertise (compared to Europe, where offshore wind has existed for decades) - hurricanes