5 ms·
Can you think of a war that has been beneficial for average Americans? Can you think of a politician who hasn't received "donations" from armaments manufacturer
by jessaustin 9y ago
Can you think of a war that has been beneficial for average Americans? Can you think of a politician who hasn't received "donations" from armaments manufacturers?
It takes a real commitment to the tabula rasa stance to pose the hypotheticals you've posed here.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoI think World War 2, the Korean War, the first Gulf War and possibly the NATO engagements in former Yugoslavia benefited Americans. Furthermore, I place value on the deterrence broadcast by such actions. Look at any poll--war is popular.
- jessaustin 9y agoWWII and the Korean War were not instigated by the military-industrial complex as such. (Although of course the Korean situation has been preserved and worsened by their constant input...) The 1st Gulf War resulted in USA troops occupying Saudi. That was the pretext for 9/11, a decade later, and all of the ensuing disasters. I'm not saying that Iraq couldn't have been ejected from Kuwait in a manner that was on balance beneficial, but that's not what happened. Even deterrence is constantly undercut by decisions that benefit the complex while harming USA citizens (as well as everyone else on earth). Libya was for a moment an argument for deterrence, until we said, "thanks for getting rid of all your weapons Muammar, now here's a bayonet up your ass!" DPRK love to talk about that episode... Wars are not popular, without massive media efforts to make them so. Fortunately, as we've seen in Syria, that button gets less effective every time the war pigs press it.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The 1st Gulf War resulted in USA troops occupying Saudi. No, it did not. There is a difference between troops being based on a country and troops occupying a country. The 2003 Iraq war ended with the US occupying Iraq. The 1991 Gulf war ended with US troops based in Saudi Arabia. The two things are radically different.
- jessaustin 9y agoWell that's not what Osama said. To him that was a distinction without a difference. He didn't want USA soldiers eating pork and drinking beer on the outskirts of Mecca and Medina. Maybe you distrust him, maybe he had some other reason for turning the world upside-down that he didn't admit, maybe you have a better model of his decision process than the rest of us have... maybe though, that's subconsciously motivated by an attachment to the idea that USA fights and wins justified wars? If you didn't believe that already, would you be more receptive to the idea that things could have been done differently, with less disastrous results?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Well that's not what Osama said Osama bin Laden was upset because he tried to leverage the Iraq crisis to get the Kingdom to bring him and his fighters in to protect against Iraq as a way to magnify his own influence, and the Kingdom choose the US instead. > Maybe you distrust him, maybe he had some other reason for turning the world upside-down that he didn't admit, maybe you have a better model of his decision process than the rest of us have... I dunno who “the ready of you” are; plenty of people are familiar with the basic history of al-Qaeda. This isn't one of the deep mysteries of the universe.
- jessaustin 9y agoLet me guess... you saw a report on CNN? Try harder, man.