5 ms·
Lawyers are expensive, and bank accounts have complicated T&Cs which basically say "We can do what we like, and fuck you." You'll spend a fortune paying someon
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
Lawyers are expensive, and bank accounts have complicated T&Cs which basically say "We can do what we like, and fuck you."
You'll spend a fortune paying someone to argue some or all of the agreement is unenforceable.
I would suggest trying to get in contact with other businesses in the same boat. The UK doesn't have a formal class action suit mechanism, but there's nothing to stop you pooling your resources in a joint suit and suing for an eye-watering sum of common consequential losses.
My guess is that if you do that, HSBC will settle out of court by restoring your accounts and offering a "no-fault goodwill payment" to everyone.
At that point you can collectively choose to refuse the payment and fight the case all the way through.
- jacquesm 9y ago> Lawyers are expensive Not nearly as expensive as folding your business. > and bank accounts have complicated T&Cs which basically say "We can do what we like, and fuck you." I've yet to see one that had T&C's that spelled that out directly or indirectly. In fact, banks being quite regulated chances are that even if their T&C had language like that in it it would likely be invalidated. > You'll spend a fortune paying someone to argue some or all of the agreement is unenforceable. If it goes to court, yes. But there is a very high chance that it will not and if you do not show that you are prepared to take it to a higher level then you're going to have to be content with being ignored. Trust me, a letter from a lawyer will not be ignored, especially not if it formally makes the bank liable for any and all direct and indirect damages arising from an action taken by the bank.
- woodylondon 9y agohow do you pay your lawyer if your account is blocked? :)
- jacquesm 9y agoLawyers typically invoice once per month, by then this should be long over. And if not they're not monsters either, and should given the fact that they know exactly what the state of affairs is be more than happy to wait for a bit. Another reason to cultivate a relationship with a legal office long before you actually need them.
- richardknop 9y ago>> by then this should be long over How do you know? This could drag on for months. And in the meantime, your money is frozen by the bank. Not a lot of lawyers will be happy to work for free in the hope you will get access to your money eventually to pay them. And forget about not having money to hire a lawyer. You don't have money to pay salaries (or a salary if you are a one person company), bills, rent, mortgage. You have survival things like paying your rent so you don't end up on the street as top priority while your bank account is frozen. I think you underestimate how expensive lawyers are and especially for small businesses they really can't afford them. Which is why there needs to be strong regulation / legislature to make sure banks cannot just freeze your money because their buggy anti fraud system flags your account for some bogus reason. At the very least they should be forced to allow you to withdraw some amount of money per month (2-3k) let's say while your account is in review, so you have money to pay your rent/gas/food and other basic cost of living expenses. Apparently they can just freeze your account and your money is gone perhaps for months. That's frightening.
- jacquesm 9y ago> How do you know? A couple of lawsuits. This is a matter of some urgency, a company that has its funds frozen can not trade and the knock-on effects are substantial (employees, taxes, invoices). So the courts should be easily convinced they need to move fast or the damage will be substantial. There are special procedures for such affairs and they tend to be heard within days. > And in the meantime, your money is frozen by the bank. That could be a very short time. But then again, I am not a lawyer, merely the frequent consumer of lawyers' time. > Not a lot of lawyers will be happy to work for free in the hope you will get access to your money eventually to pay them. Any lawyer unwilling to take your case is not worth doing business with anyway since they tell you effectively they won't be competent enough to see this through to a speedy conclusion. > And forget about not having money to hire a lawyer. Yes, I will happily forget about it since it is not an issue. > You don't have money to pay salaries (or a salary if you are a one person company), bills, rent, mortgage. This is exactly why you have a case and one with an urgent component. > You have survival things like paying your rent so you don't end up on the street as top priority while your bank account is frozen. Well, you will so that's why my suggestion to re-route any outstanding invoices to a new account pronto to avoid getting caught. > I think you underestimate how expensive lawyers are and especially for small businesses they really can't afford them. I think you underestimate how many times I've used lawyers in the past and how important it is to know your way around the legal system as an entrepreneur. Sooner or later you will either sue or be sued and if that's your time for learning you are too late. > Which is why there needs to be strong regulation / legislature to make sure banks cannot just freeze your money because their buggy anti fraud system flags your account for some bogus reason. Likely this is exactly why the account is frozen in the first place. And which is why you need to play this by the book and without delay. > At the very least they should be forced to allow you to withdraw some amount of money per month (2-3k) let's say while your account is in review, so you have money to pay your rent/gas/food and other basic cost of living expenses. I'm pretty sure that is exactly the kind of thing a ruling would aim for, but again, going by my experience the bank will avoid going to court at any cost and will long before that point give you a one time option to withdraw your money and move your business elsewhere. Now what happens after that is an annoying problem to have because it may very well be that the business or one of its partners - and not the account - was flagged. > Apparently they can just freeze your account and your money is gone perhaps for months. That's frightening. It never was any different, it's just that with the terror and the drugs laws these things happen more frequently. Also, some businesses are much more liable than others to be used for money laundering / financing of crime / evading embargoes and so on and you really need to think ahead about stuff like this to avoid getting bitten by it. Again, I'm not a lawyer but I have worked in banking - albeit long ago - and even in those days there were plenty of rules in place and I have used the legal system quite extensively and as far as I can see this case is not special or in any way lost before you've tried to fight. It will cost some time and some money, the latter you may be able to recover depending on how the judge sees things, the former you will certainly lose. I would be extremely surprised if the bank actually let the case go to court and if they do that's a strong sign there is more to this than the OP is letting on so for now my money is on the bank folding at the first sign of serious opposition.
- BeetleB 9y ago>Lawyers are expensive, and bank accounts have complicated T&Cs which basically say "We can do what we like, and fuck you." Dude - did you not notice that all it took was for him to post an online article? They didn't go to him with their T&Cs. Lawyers are expensive for a lot of things, but often all it takes is an official letter from a lawyer. I don't know how expensive that can be, but as someone else pointed out, it's likely pennies compared to losing your whole business. People often pay an affordable monthly rate to get limited legal services. They'll do basic stuff for free, but if it gets complicated you have to start paying. Something like this letter would have been covered. A tip for you - it's natural for techies to "plan for the worst". Learned the hard way that in real life being optimistic can work out. A friend once lived in an apartment building where his neighbor kept complaining about loud noise from his apartment (called the cops a few times). The cops always sided with my friend. However, when it came time to renew his lease, the landlord said "No" due to the large volume of complaints. But things got worse - no one would rent to him. Apparently his name got put in some database as a bad tenant. He kept talking to his previous landlord to get his name off the list, and they did nothing. He became essentially homeless while earning six figures. He sent his wife and kid to live with her parents, while he stayed with a friend for a few months. In the end, he went to the police, got the records of the incidents, all of which showed that the police found his neighbor to be unreasonable. He took those papers to the landlord and they finally fixed his record. When he told me this, I asked if he talked to a lawyer. "No man. Everyone told me they'd charge so much that it wouldn't be worth it." The guy did not even call a lawyer to ask what they would charge! Trust me - the legal business is not as "profitable" as it once was. There are many lawyers out there who need the money and don't have regular clients. They'll be happy to provide services like writing threatening letters for a fee. How much could they charge? Googling around I'm seeing $150 to $500.
- M2Ys4U 9y ago>The UK doesn't have a formal class action suit mechanism Actually, it does. The Consumer Rights Act 2015 created one. See Schedule 8[0] (which amends the The Competition Act 1998[1], but legislation.gov.uk hasn't updated that yet). However, there has only been one case, so far, [0] http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/15/schedule/8 http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/15/schedule/8 [1] http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/41/contents http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/41/contents