2 ms·
> I understand that OpenJDK is GPLed with class path exception, but is that enough? GPL v2 does not say that it is irrevocable. Oracle could throw a huge monke
by tzs 9y ago
> I understand that OpenJDK is GPLed with class path exception, but is that enough?
GPL v2 does not say that it is irrevocable. Oracle could throw a huge monkey wrench into OpenJDK by announcing that they are revoking the current license on all of the code in OpenJKD that they own and either no longer licensing it or licensing it on terms incompatible with the current license, and start suing people who continue using it as if it is still under GPL.
This would put us into legally uncertain territory.
Generally, non-exclusive copyright licenses that do not specify a definite duration and do not say they are revocable are revocable at will. They may be irrevocable if supported by consideration.
The key question here would be whether defendants can find an argument that there was consideration (unlikely) or a substitute for consideration (much more likely).
Another approach Oracle could take is not to try to revoke the license, but rather simply announce that they are no longer issuing new licenses. People who have OpenJDK licenses now can keep on using it, but anyone who comes to Oracle for a new license is told no.
Unfortunately, GPL v2 explicitly says that you cannot sublicense and when a licensee distributes copies their recipients do not receive their licenses from the distributor but rather from the original licensor.
If Oracle succeeded with this approach the consequences would be murky. Existing licensees would probably be able to continue distributing copies and derivative works, and their recipients would be able to use them, but those recipients might not be able to further distribute copies.
For those drafting future open source licenses who want to keep these things from happening with software under your license: (1) explicitly say in the license that it is irrevocable, and (2) explicitly say that licensees can sublicense under the same terms.
Of the major free/open source licenses, the only one I know offhand that does this right is Apache.
- danarmak 9y agoThe GPL is not (easily) revocable. The license for any concrete version already published in OpenJDK under the GPL can only be revoked 35 years after that version was published. Even then, the owner must provide public notice 2 years before revoking the license. Source: https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/832/is-a-copyright-license-by-default-revocable-or-irrevocable https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/832/is-a-copyright-l...
- tzs 9y agoThat's specifically talking about 17 USC 203, which is a termination right that applies to all copyright licenses in the US, even those that explicitly say they are irrevocable and were backed with consideration. That a license is eventually revocable under 17 USC 203 does not preclude it being revocable under other circumstances. The case law holds that a non-exclusive copyright license without consideration that does not say it is irrevocable is revocable at will. That's why nearly every case you can find where someone tried to revoke a non-exclusive copyright license turns into a case about whether or not there was consideration. Google "non-exclusive copyright license revocation" and you'll find a few articles discussing some of these cases. See also Rosen's book on open source licensing, available free online [1]. [1] http://www.rosenlaw.com/oslbook.htm http://www.rosenlaw.com/oslbook.htm
- danarmak 9y agoThanks! This is an important problem I wasn't aware of. Googling shows a lot of different opinions and confusion about this; it'll take me time to get to the bottom of this. If one takes seriously the idea that all FOSS licensed under the GPLv2 and other licenses that don't explicitly say they're irrevocable (as GPLv3 does) is at risk of being un-licensed at will, the whole ecosystem is at risk.
- michaelmrose 9y agoCan you please provide a case in which a gpl licensed item was revoked "at will". Since I am pretty sure such has never happened you could alternatively provide another case in which a piece of software was revoked? I honestly don't believe that you can make such an offer allow man years of work to be built upon your offer, derive benefits for years based on providing such an offer and say sorry changed my mind. Even if an unproven legal theory existed that would Theoretically justify this, it would end in 7 years of litigation during which the ecosystem would have collapsed. They would own at best a billion dollar legal bill and 100% of nothing at worst a billion dollar legal bill and nothing to show for it. Its hard to imagine that this is a real issue.
- 9y ago