4 ms·
Spyware Dolls and Intel's VPro
- reacweb 9y agoIf an Intel employee go broke and sell privates cryptography keys and IME documentation to a hackers group, how many computer have to be replaced in the world ? Security by obscurity has never worked in long term.
- AstralStorm 9y agoTechnically, from what we know ME firmware is flashable and possible to update except baked in private keys to verify signature. Of course, it is still a single point of failure, would be much nicer if Intel provided documentation on chipset and CPU init as well as a way to replace those keys. (Say, hardware switch to enable write pin on some EEPROM.) The big trouble is the huge attack surface of the vPro not running in magic unsupported "trusted mode" while not being properly audited is trouble. Likewise blobs like SINIT used for TPM and SecureBoot initialization.
- oneweekwonder 9y ago> Technically, from what we know ME firmware is flashable and possible to update And it might be running Minix3[0] which is amazing for me. But man it sucks to think there is a *nix machine next to my machine I have no control over. Some might mention SSD fw, but does it have a known serial over LAN vulnerability[1]. Wikipedia also cite a elevation of privilege bug[2]. I'm so glad I'm not a IT manager. [0]: http://blog.ptsecurity.com/2017/04/intel-me-way-of-static-analysis.html http://blog.ptsecurity.com/2017/04/intel-me-way-of-static-an... [1]: https://www.scmagazineuk.com/platinum-hackers-exploit-intel-amt-sol-for-secure-cc-communications/article/667477/ https://www.scmagazineuk.com/platinum-hackers-exploit-intel-... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Active_Management_Technology#cite_note-intel1-12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Active_Management_Techno... ps. If anybody have some info of the minix in ME. Please drop me a message.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sebazzz 9y agoPretty sure the private is provided by a HSM, you can't steal that.
- jlgaddis 9y agoUntil a while ago we assumed the ME was safe too.
- madez 9y agoI hope for european authorities to force Intel and AMD to offer chips without ME and consorts and providing guaranteed complete documentation and control to the users. Food is regularly sampled and controlled. I think the same for electronics is necessary. EU, why do you sleep? 1. Is there a justification for it? Yes, Intel and AMD have together a monopoly for fundamental parts of consumer and business computers. They do not leave the choice to avoid ME and equivalents. The products are fundamental and the functionality can be provenly malicious. That allows anti-trust measures. 1.1 But aren't OpenPOWER, RISC-V, ARM, ..., alternatives? No, because the products either don't exist, are not suitable for the needs, or have similar issues with lack of documentation and guaranteed control for users. Please correct me if I'm wrong. I expect hardware level reverse engineering to check for backdoors. 2. Can authorities force them to change their offering? Not directly, but they can do it indirectly and effectively by forbidding selling their products without change. Or by charging them huge fees for every CPU sold while not offering an alternative. 2.1 Can the authorities check the hardware? Yes, but it is time-consuming and needs experts. Since it could be done for the whole of Europe, the load can be shared. Food controls also need experts, are time-intensive and don't work perfectly. Still, it is working generally good. 3. Is this likely to happen? The authority needs to be willing to face huge and important companies and be able to withstand political pressure. German authorities are hopelessly incompetent when it comes to digitalization and computers. Maybe EU's organisations wake up. They have shown to be willing to face huge corporations and speak clear and understandable words with them.
- jacquesm 9y ago> EU, why do you sleep? Lack of alternatives. Even though NL for instance supplies critical equipment to all fabs there is no way the EU could force Intel or AMD to do their bidding because they could not possibly check if what they agree on is what is actually being done. The EU still sees the USA as an ally (though it is clear the reverse is no longer the case) and this to some extent explains the lack of rigor here. China and Russia are in a better position to deal with this problem and they seem to have chosen to create their own chips rather than to attempt to make a deal with the giants. I'm sure France and/or Germany would love a EU processor if only for the prestige but I'm also quite sure that that processor if and when it saw the light of day could not be trusted any further than Intel or AMD now.
- acoye 9y agoI guess ARM is safe for now … Is it not?
- squarefoot 9y ago"For a number of years now there has been growing concern that the management technologies in recent Intel CPUs (ME, AMT and vPro) also conceal capabilities for spying, either due to design flaws (no software is perfect) or backdoors deliberately installed for US spy agencies, as revealed by Edward Snowden. In a 2014 interview, Intel's CEO offered to answer any question, except this one." https://www.infowars.com/intel-ceo-refuses-to-answer-questions-on-whether-nsa-can-access-processors/ https://www.infowars.com/intel-ceo-refuses-to-answer-questio... Lots of deleted posts on that Reddit chat though, so it's difficult to get a picture. I know about ME etc, but had no idea Intel's CEO was asked abut it directly and his response (or lack of).
- jamiek88 9y agoInfowars? Really? Do we have a more credible source than deleted comments on reddit interpreted by infowars?
- squarefoot 9y agoI don't know the infowars site and its reporting quality, the original article points to it. That's also why I was asking for more info.