10 ms·
> And unionists, no matter how piss poor a job they do, can never be fired (in theory they can, but in practice it never happens). Do you mean union leaders or
by yorwba 9y ago
> And unionists, no matter how piss poor a job they do, can never be fired (in theory they can, but in practice it never happens).
Do you mean union leaders or regular members? Because if it's the latter, then you have a counterexample in every 100% unionized company that ever fired anyone.
- ekianjo 9y agoMore specifically union leaders, who have the whole weight of the union behind them.
- hoschicz 9y agoThat's the incentive to form unions.
- alkonaut 9y ago> Do you mean union leaders or regular members? Because if it's the latter, then you have a counterexample in every 100% unionized company that ever fired anyone This is an interesting point. In countries with well functioning high organization such as Sweden (but unlike France) the key to the situation is the peace agreement (yes it's literally called that) between unions and employers. Basically: unions promise to work during the whole contract period. So when strikes happen, it's when the contracts are renegotiated, which happens e.g. every two years. If the parts can't reach a new agreement, unions go on strike. Unions don't just strike willy nilly in the middle of the contract period. Employers actually quite like this: it gives them stability and a competitive edge over countries where production might be disrupted by a strike at any point. Strikes that happen in the middle of a contract period are called "wild strikes" and are usually not sanctioned by unions. These are very rare, compared to e.g. Denmark and France. The union's power is tremendous when it's actually allowed to use it. For example, it typically blockades everyone from working. Even if a non-union member would want to work, the employer usually doesn't dare letting them. And even if the employer would want to keep operating with other employers, the union usually gets help from all other unions to ensure the employer can't do anything (deliveries don't work, garbage collection doesn't happen etc).
- kalleboo 9y agoOne example of the power of Swedish unions is that Sweden has no minimum wage law. Sure an employer could pay less than the union rate by why wouldn't the worker go to a union shop instead?
- alkonaut 9y ago> Sure an employer could pay less than the union rate by why wouldn't the worker go to a union shop instead They couldn't. They would be blockaded. Unions demand that all shops pay union rate, regardless of whether employers of the other shop are happy to not be union. So unions decide rates for all employers and all employees.
- byroot 9y agoHe means "delegates", kinda like union leader but not exactly. But they can absolutely be fired, they are simply a protected class of workers, meaning they cannot be fired because of their delegate status, but can be because of anything else. It's very similar to the US protected classes of workers. A very simple Google search will show you they do get fired from time to time, e.g just 3 month ago: http://www.courrier-picard.fr/32021/article/2017-05-22/le-delegue-syndical-licencie-pour-une-pause-cafe-trop-longue-chez-mgi-coutier http://www.courrier-picard.fr/32021/article/2017-05-22/le-de... The guy got fired for cause after 26 years in the company, because of a coffee break that lasted too long. Due to his protected status, a court has to validate the firing, and in this case they did. @ekianjo is simply dwelling on the common French entrepreneurs narrative that the law is anti-business, etc.
- ekianjo 9y agoIts not because you find an exception it means the rule does not generally apply.