3 ms·
I have enough faith in the American people that we would never permit the end of freedom of movement. For one thing, it would take a Constitutional amendment to
by closeparen 9y ago
I have enough faith in the American people that we would never permit the end of freedom of movement. For one thing, it would take a Constitutional amendment to legalize internal border controls. For another, geographical mobility has been core to American identity since the earliest days of the country. You're talking about locking the Okies in the Dust Bowl. Locking the autoworkers in Detroit even after the auto industry dried up. Preventing the Great Migration of Southern blacks to the more hospitable Northern states. Deepening inequality by locking in the regional disparities that perpetuate it.
This is insane, dystopic (literally, geographically-based caste systems feature in dystopian fiction with some regularity, for example the Hunger Games and Elysium), un-Constitutional, and un-American.
If internal border controls ever became law, I'd be the first to sign up for the resistance in the resultant civil war.
- EGreg 9y agoWhoa whoa, who's talking about ending freedom of movement? To be clear we are talking about being eligible to receive free money from whichever local area agrees to issue it to you.
- paganel 9y ago> we are talking about being eligible to receive free money from whichever local area agrees to issue it to you. This looks pretty similar to the English Poor Laws, which in the end proved to be quite despotic. It started like this, at the end of the 15h century: > In 1495, Parliament passed the Vagabonds and Beggars Act ordering that "vagabonds, idle and suspected persons shall be set in the stocks for three days and three nights and have none other sustenance but bread and water and then shall be put out of Town. Every beggar suitable to work shall resort to the Hundred where he last dwelled, is best known, or was born and there remain upon the pain aforesaid." (taken from the wiki page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_Poor_Laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_Poor_Laws) but it turned out that that made people dependent on their "original" parishes and that the other parishes/towns would not want any of them on their streets, thus impeding the free movement of people across England. There were other major ills caused by this law (this subject also has its own wiki page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opposition_to_the_English_Poor_Laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opposition_to_the_English_Poor...), I for myself first learned of its bad effects (and of the bad effects that similar laws can cause) by reading some Bentham.
- EGreg 9y agoOnce again, this is NOT about forcing anyone to do anything. This is about ELIGIBILITY FOR UNCONDITIONAL BASIC INCOME. You can move anywhere you want -- but you are not guaranteed benefits. Should be obvious! If you don't allow communities to limit who can join, what is to prevent 50,000 people from various parts of California moving to Beverly Hills the next day and demanding enough UBI to live in a mansion and having private doctors?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paganel 9y ago> You can move anywhere you want -- but you are not guaranteed benefits. Should be obvious! You're not explicitly forbidding them to stay, you're doing that implicitly, by correlating their getting financial assistance with them remaining in a specific place. It's the same thing with saying "you're free to leave your job anytime you want!" when you're full of financial responsibilities (rent/mortgage, kids, older relatives you have to take of) which means that you are not in fact "free" to leave that job. > If you don't allow communities to limit who can join, what is to prevent 50,000 people from various parts of California moving to Beverly Hills the next day and demanding enough UBI to live in a mansion and having private doctors? The way I understand UBI (I may be wrong) is that whenever and especially if it would be implemented then exclusive places like Beverly Hills will have to go, i.e. the society would have to become more equal.
- EGreg 9y agoNo, inequality will always persist. You can't have 10,000 people come live in a place where water is expensive and then demand that society bring water to them. You speak of freedom - freedom brings inequality as different communities make different choices. Back to your point - you are free to leave your job if another company will hire you. You are free to leave your community if another community will pay for your UBI. Or if you saved up enough to move, or if you actually make enough money now etc. You do realize the UBI is on top of what you'd be making anyway, just to help you save up? Perhaps the community will pay UBI only to those who move there and work there (contributing to the society), or prove inability to work. But then it wouldn't be unconditional anymore - and who gets to say that the "poet" who muses for 10 hours a day isn't doing some productive work? Communities would then be tying UBI to certain kinds of work. But just giving unconditionally UBI to everyone is unsustainable because it just completely overlooks the cost of living in a certain area. If millionaires can afford super duper doctors and other gentrified stuff in that area, how would you figure out how much UBI to give to the people moving there? If you give the same amount to everyone everywhere, they STILL couldn't afford doctors in Beverly hills. Now you are talking about price controls forcing an ace surgeon in Beverly Hills to take the same as someone who barely graduated medical school and never got better, who works in SomewhereCheap Kansas. That's unrealistic. And you're forcing a water company that supplies water to a desert place to charge the same for that necessary good as a water company that delivers 100 feet from a local aquifer. Think it through and tell me how your proposed UBI system without immigration quotas would even workz