3 ms·
That is funny :) Maybe ~20% of Americans are well-enough off that they feel wealthy. But they have no clue what real wealth is. And indeed, in day-to-day life,
by mirimir 9y ago
That is funny :)
Maybe ~20% of Americans are well-enough off that they feel wealthy. But they have no clue what real wealth is. And indeed, in day-to-day life, it's pretty much invisible.
Edit: Gotta quote this:
> All of this adds up to a terrain incredibly inhospitable to class-based politics. Every few years a group of millionaire Democratic presidential aspirants pretends to be the people's warriors against the overclass. They look inauthentic, combative rather than unifying. Worst of all, their basic message is not optimistic.
> They haven't learned what Franklin and Teddy Roosevelt and even Bill Clinton knew: that you can run against rich people, but only those who have betrayed the ideal of fair competition. You have to be more hopeful and growth-oriented than your opponent, and you cannot imply that we are a nation tragically and permanently divided by income. In the gospel of America, there are no permanent conflicts.
- yorwba 9y ago> But they have no clue what real wealth is. I think measuring "real wealth" by some relative metric like "top 1%" is misguided. To me, being wealthy means being able to live a comfortable life without worrying about your next paycheck. I'm from Germany, but studying in China on a scholarship. The 1000 euros per month I get wouldn't put me among the German 1%, but in a country with a lower cost of living, I spend only half of what I get. When the scholarship runs out next month, I have a year of runway at my current spending level. That's wealthy enough for me.
- closeparen 9y ago> To me, being wealthy means being able to live a comfortable life without worrying about your next paycheck Americans generally use middle-class to refer to this state. Things are good, you have a paycheck or two of slack, you can make a healthy retirement contribution and save a little each month, own (via debt) a decent house and car, go out to eat a few times a month, not pinch pennies at the grocery store, etc. Major changes like moving, getting a new car, putting a kid through college, etc. require some planning, maybe some financing, but are doable. Real wealth would be owning a grand house and luxury car, not needing to work to sustain the same lifestyle (before retirement age; after retirement age this is baseline for not being poor), ability to self-fund a capital intensive business, casually owning multiple residences, frequent international travel, etc. Luxury cars are toys and putting a kid through college is painless. That kind of stuff.
- arca_vorago 9y agoReal wealth is not having debt.
- devonkim 9y agoI have no debt, some liquid assets, but still rent. I know I'm better off than a lot of the country but being in the top n% of income in the wealthiest country in the world but enjoying little of the amenities besides basic infrastructure seems difficult for me to think of myself in any way as "wealthy." Unencumbered is ahead of many but I think I'd far rather have $400k income (and, more importantly, the social status and connections that kind of occupation or niche implies) with $1MM in debt than some low six figure income with much more in common socially with the homeless and nonfunctional mentally ill.
- fuzzfactor 9y agoWith the increasing number of the middle class including full-time workers becoming homeless (especially now in Houston) some homeful people would be best to become less rejecting of the homeless and/or mentally affected who lost traction before them. Especially in such a case where it's so obvious that there but for the grace of god they go. Regardless of natural disaster or not, the prevailing cutoff line is coming after your low six-figure income, since there's not much foundation remaining below that level. If you are providing shelter or a more extensive domestic environment those are not functionally very much like six significant figures anyway, but you knew that.
- clairity 9y agothat's not right. real wealth is having a low cost of capital. the wealthy tend to carry debt because it's plentiful and cheap for them. access to cheap money gives them access to better returns than the average bear. if you are not wealthy, debt is expensive and not nearly as rewarding. but having debt, of course, doesn't imply you are wealthy.
- closeparen 9y agoNah. Someone with $25k assets and $20k debt is substantially wealthier (i.e. can use their money to accomplish more purposes) than someone with only $5k. Having a major asset (like a house) owned outright might be closer to "real wealth" territory.
- mirimir 9y agoI agree that there's far more to life satisfaction than money. But that's a different conversation. The point here is that people support policies that favor the top 1% because they foolishly believe that they're part of that top 1%. Or because they believe that they will be. Or because they believe that said 1% drives the economy.
- IncRnd 9y ago> The point here is that people support policies that favor the top 1% because they foolishly believe that they're part of that top 1%. Or because they do not believe in taking from others in order to themselves have something. You literally ascribe people's actions and beliefs to foolishness, when a little introspection will show that others are not necessarily being foolish.
- nunez 9y agoAs far as I'm concerned, real wealth is the point at which you no longer have to work because your money is working for you AND that money is producing enough for you to be in the top 1% of earners in your country. (I believe that is $250k/year in the US, though I'd be fine with $100-150k) Why is this important? Because at that point, you can do, say or believe WHATEVER YOU WANT without fear of losing your job and you have the capital and network to influence others. To me, that's about $20M ($10M in my case) invested in a boring old three headed portfolio (50% index, 25% bonds, 25% international index). Earning $20M for the sole purpose of saving it is not easy. The only ways i know of acquiring that wealth is through an inheritance, a significant liquidity event or by stealing it.
- tonyedgecombe 9y ago>>Maybe ~20% of Americans are well-enough off that they feel wealthy. But they have no clue what real wealth is. And indeed, in day-to-day life, it's pretty much invisible. I suppose you could be in the 1% in your community and not nationally.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]