6 ms·
> The central issue in American politics is the economic security of the middle class and their sense of opportunity for their children. Maybe for Mr. Summers,
by mirimir 9y ago
> The central issue in American politics is the economic security of the middle class and their sense of opportunity for their children.
Maybe for Mr. Summers, it is. And maybe as well, for liberals generally.
But there are at least a couple problems. First, many Americans are apparently convinced that some other issue is central in American politics. Maybe it's threats from foreigners. Or from Satan, or some proxy of his. Or perhaps, it's losing their guns. Or whatever.
Second, even among those who agree that the economic security of the middle class is the central issue in American politics, many have been convinced that rewarding wealthy capitalists is the best strategy.
So it goes.
Edit: Indeed, many middle-class Americans think that they're wealthy, and so don't care so much about the middle class.
- ryandrake 9y agoThe article is from a while ago, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were still true: 19% of Americans think they are in the top 1% and 20% more expect to be one day [1]. So a full 39% of Americans either suck at math or actually believe that by rewarding wealthy capitalists they are actually rewarding themselves! 1: http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hope-over-self-interest.html http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hop...
- mirimir 9y agoThat is funny :) Maybe ~20% of Americans are well-enough off that they feel wealthy. But they have no clue what real wealth is. And indeed, in day-to-day life, it's pretty much invisible. Edit: Gotta quote this: > All of this adds up to a terrain incredibly inhospitable to class-based politics. Every few years a group of millionaire Democratic presidential aspirants pretends to be the people's warriors against the overclass. They look inauthentic, combative rather than unifying. Worst of all, their basic message is not optimistic. > They haven't learned what Franklin and Teddy Roosevelt and even Bill Clinton knew: that you can run against rich people, but only those who have betrayed the ideal of fair competition. You have to be more hopeful and growth-oriented than your opponent, and you cannot imply that we are a nation tragically and permanently divided by income. In the gospel of America, there are no permanent conflicts.
- yorwba 9y ago> But they have no clue what real wealth is. I think measuring "real wealth" by some relative metric like "top 1%" is misguided. To me, being wealthy means being able to live a comfortable life without worrying about your next paycheck. I'm from Germany, but studying in China on a scholarship. The 1000 euros per month I get wouldn't put me among the German 1%, but in a country with a lower cost of living, I spend only half of what I get. When the scholarship runs out next month, I have a year of runway at my current spending level. That's wealthy enough for me.
- closeparen 9y ago> To me, being wealthy means being able to live a comfortable life without worrying about your next paycheck Americans generally use middle-class to refer to this state. Things are good, you have a paycheck or two of slack, you can make a healthy retirement contribution and save a little each month, own (via debt) a decent house and car, go out to eat a few times a month, not pinch pennies at the grocery store, etc. Major changes like moving, getting a new car, putting a kid through college, etc. require some planning, maybe some financing, but are doable. Real wealth would be owning a grand house and luxury car, not needing to work to sustain the same lifestyle (before retirement age; after retirement age this is baseline for not being poor), ability to self-fund a capital intensive business, casually owning multiple residences, frequent international travel, etc. Luxury cars are toys and putting a kid through college is painless. That kind of stuff.
- arca_vorago 9y agoReal wealth is not having debt.
- devonkim 9y agoI have no debt, some liquid assets, but still rent. I know I'm better off than a lot of the country but being in the top n% of income in the wealthiest country in the world but enjoying little of the amenities besides basic infrastructure seems difficult for me to think of myself in any way as "wealthy." Unencumbered is ahead of many but I think I'd far rather have $400k income (and, more importantly, the social status and connections that kind of occupation or niche implies) with $1MM in debt than some low six figure income with much more in common socially with the homeless and nonfunctional mentally ill.
- colanderman 9y agoWell, those 20% aren't so deluded. In fact 12% of all Americans do enter the top 1% at least for a year. [1] (Granted it's not clear from the above link whether the poll question was worded to clarify this ambiguity.) [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-to-riches-to-rags.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-...
- mirimir 9y agoYou don't "enter the top 1% at least for a year". To be part of the 1%, you at least have enough capital to live off interest indefinitely. Indeed, enough for your children to live off interest indefinitely.
- kilotaras 9y agoIt seems like you're talking about wealth and GP is talking about income.
- mirimir 9y agoYes, I've been talking about wealth. I mean, I've said "wealthy" a few times :)
- scythe 9y agoI think you mean "to be rich". To be in the top 1%, you, by definition, need only to have an income which is in the top 1% of the US income distribution. However, the lacuna between the income distribution and the power distribution is exactly what is misleading about the term "the 1%" when it is used to complain about the power of the wealthy in modern America.
- isostatic 9y agoSome people use top 1% to refer to income. Some use it to refer to wealth. For range majority of people income relies on a job, and by doing it harder/longer/smarter you get a higher income. Our tax system peanalisies hard work. The other option is to treat rich people as those with a lot of money, not those who are most productive. When I think of someone who is rich, I think of someone who is wealthy. That means having a lot of wealth, more than 99% of the country. To do that you need assets of over $8m (2013) {1} That amount of assets should be able, long term, to grow with inflation and still deliver over $100k a year to live on. Even if it didn't just withdrawing the cash at $100k a year will see you through for life. 1. https://dqydj.com/net-worth-in-the-united-states-zooming-in-on-the-top-centiles/ https://dqydj.com/net-worth-in-the-united-states-zooming-in-...
- jabl 9y agoI think these kinds of misconceptions people have about themselves are quite common, in fact. Like that the vast majority of people think they are above average drivers.
- kartan 9y agoThere was this year that my friend sold her apartment... It was a lot more money than she originally paid for it. She got an awesome income that year. For the article: > Using data from the Internal Revenue Service, Mr. Carroll showed that between 1999 and 2007, half of those who earned over $1 million a year did so just once during this period... Yep. I will recommend reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Lie_with_Statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Lie_with_Statistics
- icelancer 9y ago>>But there are at least a couple problems. First, many Americans are apparently convinced that some other issue is central in American politics. Maybe it's threats from foreigners. Or from Satan, or some proxy of his. Or perhaps, it's losing their guns. Or whatever. This is very much by design. The state and controlling money interests are happy if people are complaining about guns, weed, LGBT rights, neo-Nazi marches, and so forth as long as the complaining does not involve economic insecurity and/or civil liberties.
- intended 9y agoThe conversation in threads never goes beyond this point. Yes, this is by design - and crickets (usually). Even if it were by design, how can it be countered or worked around.
- mirimir 9y agoI'm not sure what else there is to say. Realizing what's going on doesn't accomplish much. I mean, what's going on has been obvious for decades.
- icelancer 9y ago>>Even if it were by design, how can it be countered or worked around. My post wasn't meant to invoke a solution. I am not sure that there is one. It's quite the solved game.
- closeparen 9y agoYou have also left out an interesting third group, who are interested in the welfare of the poor, and believe the middle class have gotten far too much airtime and are basically the same as the super-rich with respect to the poor's concerns. These folks don't come out much on a national level, but are prevalent in urban housing debates, defending the poor and rich alike against the (upper) middle class.
- mirimir 9y agoYes, I did. But they're an even smaller group.
- alphaalpha101 9y agoAlso it's just not really true. The middle class in America is perfectly well off. It's the working class that's in shit, and those that can't get a job at all that.
- bob_roboto 9y ago> So it goes. Always makes my day :)