6 ms·
> The author blatantly violated YouTube's developer policies Well duh, but those policies only exist because YT is trying to sell those features. > He's lucky
by Spivak 9y ago
> The author blatantly violated YouTube's developer policies
Well duh, but those policies only exist because YT is trying to sell those features.
> He's lucky they didn't choose to go down the lawsuit route instead.
Lucky? It's a toss-up whether policies like this are actually enforceable. Most likely all they'd be able to do is block the devs access.
I'll take this as my stance on this matter: a user or program should be allowed to do anything they choose with the bits they receive. They can alter, modify, ignore, strip, or save any part of it.
This app operates in the same area as ad blockers. Would you argue that uBlock should be taken down because YT wrote a policy demanding that browser software must not 'enable or encourage' the blocking of ads.
- jhanschoo 9y ago> a user or program should be allowed to do anything they choose with the bits they receive. They can alter, modify, ignore, strip, or save any part of it. Regardless of your position on whether the law is right or wrong, this is not true as a matter of law. Depending on the pertinent applicable law, your ability to transform these bits may be restricted based on IP law or contract law.
- comstock 9y agoMaybe, but we'll never find out if Apple just removes the software and it never goes to litigation...
- Veratyr 9y ago> Lucky? It's a toss-up whether policies like this are actually enforceable. Most likely all they'd be able to do is block the devs access. He consented to a contract, violated it and caused actual damages (loss of ad revenue, profiting from copyright infringement). Given that he displayed content in violation of the license he was given and made money from it, it could even be a criminal copyright infringement case. > This app operates in the same area as ad blockers. Would you argue that uBlock should be taken down because YT wrote a policy demanding that browser software must not 'enable or encourage' the blocking of ads. The uBlock developer doesn't profit and didn't agree to anything. > I'll take this as my stance on this matter: a user or program should be allowed to do anything they choose with the bits they receive. They can alter, modify, ignore, strip, or save any part of it. A stance like this is how you get DRM and ads baked into the video stream. Would you honestly prefer we get into an arms race with YouTube? With DRM the way it is today, I'm not sure that's a battle we can win. Head down this path and we'll have DRM and eye tracking to make _really_ sure we're watching ads before we play a video.
- thinkloop 9y agoEye tracking is surely coming regardless
- corobo 9y agoLets put paranoia aside for a moment, how would this even be feasible? Firstly the browser has to ask permission to use the camera Hey maybe you're the one in a million that uploads videos direct through webcam so they have that permission anyway - Would people really be ok with sitting there as their webcam light flickers on and off to make sure they're watching adverts? No, they would not. Literally any rival tube site could milk the heck out of that to start pulling people away from YouTube. I'd put money on seeing people vlogging on an adult tube site before we see eyeball tracking on YouTube. Besides all that you could just unplug your webcam..
- Nexxxeh 9y agoOh, you say that now... 460p unless you meet the hardware and software requirements. Eye tracking hardware and HDCP 4.0 display, and Windows 10 Securibility Update or MacOS Himalaya. iOS 10 or Android Sherbet. On MacOS and iOS that's Safari with iEye permissions granted for YouTube.com, or Chrome on MacOS with GoggleEye enabled. On Windows, it's Edge with Windows Accessibility and Optics (WAaO), or Chrome with GoggleEye. Android is Chrome with GoggleEye. Or the official iOS, Android or Win 10 apps. Coming 2019. Maybe.
- corobo 9y agoTrips up at the first hurdle - 460p unless you meet the hardware and software requirements That's a sinking ship. That's the sort of thing that allows Facebook into the world despite MySpace already existing. The sort of thing that allows Google to elbow its way into the #1 spot past the Altavistas, Hotbots and the Jeeves. A new site would come out of nowhere that doesn't have that restriction.
- 9y ago
- dakom 9y ago> a user or program should be allowed to do anything they choose with the bits they receive. They can alter, modify, ignore, strip, or save any part of it. If you sign a NDA with Coca-Cola, and they share their recipe with you via email, you're allowed to do "anything you choose" with it? If you sign a partnership contract with Google, and they share their algorithms with you, you're allowed to do "anything you choose" with it? Where's the line exactly of how far you can violate a contract simply because the property - intellectual and otherwise, can be represented as bits?
- Retra 9y agoObviously, when you're selling proprietary information. A service should have no right to enforce reinterpretation of the bits received any more than you have a right to enforce how people are to interpret the semantic content of your posts. (And in fact, I could easily go around selling my reinterpretation, and that only becomes a problem once you're arguing damages.)
- dakom 9y agoYes, financial damages is what happens when you "reinterpret" bits against contractual agreements.
- NTripleOne 9y ago> Well duh, but those policies only exist because YT is trying to sell those features. See, I could get behind this argument if I could actually buy those features - but because I'm not in the US, I can't. YouTube Red has looked like the same speck on the horizon as it has for the past 3 years in the UK now, and as far as I know, absolutely nothing has been said about when it'll arrive here. I would like nothing more than to pay for this functionality, after being given a trial of YouTube Music Key (back before it was called Red) well over 3 years ago at this point, I want reasonably priced access to Red original content, I want background and audio-only play on my phone. Hell, I might even use the download video feature, who knows? Well it's sure as hell not me, because I don't even have access to it.
- dbbk 9y ago> Well duh, but those policies only exist because YT is trying to sell those features. That's totally within their rights as a business, is it not?