4 ms·
In fact, my naive understanding of world history is that territorial conquest (distinct from cultural/political/economic conquest) was largely a modern European
by icebraining 9y ago
In fact, my naive understanding of world history is that territorial conquest (distinct from cultural/political/economic conquest) was largely a modern European thing
What about Alexander the Great, the Roman Empire, Genghis Khan? Not to mention the various empires of the Ancient world, from 2000 BC, which had plenty of conquering; the Achaemenid reached 5.5 million km².
- wahern 9y agoAFAIU, none of those were territorial acquisitions in the modern sense. Neither Alexander the Great nor Genghis Khan expanded the territory of the Greek or Mongolian nations, respectively. The modern notion of the nation-state doesn't really have an historical analog. It's a distinction that matters when critiquing this new paper, because its argument is fundamentally premised on (and constrained by) the notion of a modern nation-state. Indeed, without the concept of a modern nation-state we may not have seen European-style territorial acquisition, because it's only within a system of nation-states do you need territorial acquisition to legitimize complete political sovereignty. The "nation-state" is an historical novelty in the way that it makes absolute legal, economic, and social power co-extensive.