2 ms·
Fair enough. That's an _extremely_ important and obvious exception. But it's not unlike China. Few scholars would classify China as a nation interested in conqu
by wahern 9y ago
Fair enough. That's an _extremely_ important and obvious exception. But it's not unlike China. Few scholars would classify China as a nation interested in conquest (now or ever), even after considering Tibet and the slow, multimillennial political expansion of the Han people.
The U.S. relinquished the Philippines and other significant acquisitions after the Spanish War. The Monroe Doctrine shows that the U.S. was never much interested in territorial acquisition, per se.
If anything, I'd argue that our concept of territorial conquest is derived from the peculiar historical evolution of European powers. And it's decline is more a reflection of the world moving on from that peculiar history. The further you get from Western Europe--geographically and temporally--the more difficult it is to characterize and analyze conquest in terms of the nation-state--which was, as a distinct and categorical "thing", a European invention solidified by the Treaty of Westphalia.
Thus, I think it's fair to say that neither the U.S. nor China are conquesting nations, but only using the European definition of conquest. The European definition is usually what we use in discourse because it's well-defined and has very specific meanings. If we loosen the term then, yes, I think it's clear that the U.S. especially is a conquesting nation; and to a lesser extent (at least in modern times), China. But loose definitions makes for poor discourse. I think it's enough to recognize the limits of our definitions.