3 ms·
There was never extraordinary peace. Quite the opposite. Tens of millions died in conflict post-WWII. The only thing that changed was conflicts no longer result
by wahern 9y ago
There was never extraordinary peace. Quite the opposite. Tens of millions died in conflict post-WWII. The only thing that changed was conflicts no longer resulted in territorial acquisition as a general matter, and that split can be traced back to 1928, not to post-WWII.
The notion of the U.S. as a global policeman has some credibility, but only going back to the 1990s. Before then the U.S.'s reach ended where the Soviet Union's began, and there were plenty of proxy conflicts.
- acover 9y agoSource? This analysis seems to suggest we are in a period of relative peace. [0] [0] - https://ourworldindata.org/war-and-peace/ https://ourworldindata.org/war-and-peace/
- wahern 9y agoArguably we are, but conflict has hardly ended. Even according to that chart, only in the past few decades do we even seem to fall appreciably below the average, especially if you exclude outliers like WWI and WWII. My point is merely that there's little reason to chalk up the very recent changes to the U.S. being a global policeman. The more complex truth is all of these things: atomic weapons making World War too risky, increase in global economic ties, increasingly democratic governance, the role of hegemonic powers (including but not exclusively the U.S.), and of course the U.S. as the pre-eminent hegemonic power. This re-analysis of the effect of the Kellogg–Briand Pact is quite persuasive, but only in the context of the above. Also, see my post else thread regarding the complex cause+effect relationship. A treaty is a culmination of historic events; a culmination with consequences, but not magical in itself.
- pmiller2 9y agoThe US has been in a state of armed conflict for all but 21 years of its existence: http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2015/02/america-war-93-time-222-239-years-since-1776.html http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2015/02/america-war-93-time-2...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rictic 9y agoThere has been an extraordinary peace since WW2 in terms of number of deaths. Things improved further post-cold war, but the international climate changed significantly after WW2. It is damning with faint praise to say that the tremendous loss of life to war in that time is extraordinarily peaceful, but compared to the rest of human history it's absolutely the case. In pre-modern times war was the default posture between states.
- jrs95 9y agoSeems like we've just substituted political control for literal territorial acquisition.
- antisthenes 9y agoConquering land is no longer necessary since capital has global mobility and is usually no longer tied to any particular location. Even before there is a slight chance of a territory becoming unstable, there will be capital fright and thus all incentive for waging war in the first place will have been snuffed out. Modern capital (on industrial scale) is extremely risk averse, hence seeing so little foreign investment into unstable countries and territories and capital following the path of least resistance - from least stable to most stable. It's why Saudi and Russia are investing hundreds billions into foreign markets and not the other way around.