7 ms·
We seem to be in an interesting time where everyone is casting around looking for the next "big" idea, regardless of whether it works, and as a result the only
by nostrademons 9y ago
We seem to be in an interesting time where everyone is casting around looking for the next "big" idea, regardless of whether it works, and as a result the only way to do useful "small" ideas that work is to fund them yourself or get ordinary, non-import people to help fund them (i.e. crowdfunding or ICOs). All the attention is on flying cars, self-driving cars, killer robots, alternative currencies, artificial intelligence, 600 mph vacuum transportation, and missions to Mars.
The last time I can think of when the tech landscape looked like this was the early 90s, when everybody was hung up on artificial intelligence, pocket computing, handwriting recognition, voice recognition, WebTV, 3D graphics, and virtual reality. We ended up getting many of those, 15 years later, but the real huge story of the decade was the WWW, which was really unimpressive when it first came out (I remember comparing it unfavorably to Gopher in 1993; Gopher at least was semi-organized).
The WWW overshadowed everything else because the problem it was solving - which many people didn't know they had - was more universal than the problems solved by any other technologies that had just entered the market, and its solution was just barely viable enough to solve that problem. Meanwhile, the tech for many of the other much hotter problems of the time was 15-20 years out; they couldn't actually be solved by the processing power available in 1992. I wonder if there's a similar overlooked-but-universal problem that someone in a garage is working on now, that'll spark a new wave similar to the dot-com boom.
- Judgmentality 9y agoSo what do you think are the big problems being worked on today which people are overlooking because the technology isn't as sexy as self-driving cars? I agree with you that funding chases the flashy stuff, and real businesses are built on substance. I'm just curious what you think will end up breaking out from this era of funding. Obviously hindsight is 20/20, but I heard an interesting tidbit from a famous investor about the dot com bubble: you either invested in Google or you didn't. I wonder if things will turn out similar this time as I still haven't seen a good IPO from a tech company in years (would love for people to provide counter-examples as I don't track this very closely).
- jacquesm 9y ago> So what do you think are the big problems being worked on today which people are overlooking because the technology isn't as sexy as self-driving cars? Making computers disappear.
- germinalphrase 9y agoWhich would be ... ubiquitous AR? What is the end vision for this idea?
- abecedarius 9y agoSee Vinge's novel Rainbows End. It's a combo of the AR plus having sensors/effectors/networking embedded in all the stuff around you for computing to work with. The "internet of things" starts to go that way, but what I've heard of hasn't sounded that impressive. Seems like it needs to get way better at security and interoperability, though it's not my field.
- jacquesm 9y agoUbiquitous computing without proper security and interop is a non-starter. The present day internet of things to me looks mostly like companies that are in the 'goods' business that are desperately trying to get into the 'services' business because they would like themselves some slice of that recurring revenue.
- abecedarius 9y agoYes, I want to buy things that can talk only to my network, while apparently they want me to pay to host XYZcorp's botnet.
- danielharrison 9y agoMake someone rich, as is any idea.
- 9y ago
- fullshark 9y agoI'm not a huge crypto fan but among the hot tech fields, a reliable means to build savings / retain value over a multi year horizon is the most universal problem i.e. Bitcoin.
- kybernetikos 9y agoLike everything else, the value of bitcoin depends on its demand. There's absolutely no reason to have confidence that the demand for specifically bitcoin will be any more consistent over the long term than lots of other things. There are lots of things that could happen that could dramatically shift the demand levels. Speculative, new, volatile are not good characteristics of places to put your savings unless your appetite for risk is quite high. It's also not a good description of why people are getting into bitcoin as far as I can tell. Most of the people I know invested in bitcoin are invested speculatively because they want to make money as the price goes up, not retain the value they've acquired.
- chubot 9y agoThat's a good question to ponder. I like small ideas that turn big. But I have no idea what it could be. The web was public infrastructure that had commercial applications. Tim Berners-Lee and co. started it at CERN, Andreessen and others worked on it in universities, and Netscape commercialized it. What public infrastructure do we have now that could follow such a path? ----- And I wonder about the economics and business model. How will it fit within the dominant business models today: 1. Facebook/Google "content + clicks" advertising model 2. the Apple/Android/Amazon locked device + pay for content model I'd argue that those two business models sort of limit the universe of technological ideas that we consider (or fund if you are VC). For example, the only software you can really sell these days is SaaS (?) The web is big because it overturned Microsoft's model of selling software, although honestly it took 10+ years to do that. And Microsoft certainly played a big role in the first dot com boom with IE and hotmail. And you can argue that nobody made that much money in the first .com boom. Yahoo and EBay are probably the exceptions. Amazon really didn't until after the crash was over. But Intel, Sun, Cisco, etc. made a lot of money by selling shovels. Maybe the analog today is that AWS and Google will make a lot of money selling cloud services to the next big thing? Maybe the incumbents have to "buy into" the next thing -- otherwise it will get squashed. ----- Maybe it's useful to look back to a previous boom -- the PC boom of the 1980's. As far as I know, the killers apps then were word processing and spreadsheets (for small businesses). I'm reading "The Dream Machine" and it is pretty amazing how people wrote before word processors! I never experienced those days, but I remember my mom literally cutting and gluing snippets of paper to write her papers! But pretty soon she got a word processor. There is probably some "invisible drudgery" in our lives today along the lines of "creating documents" and "making phone calls and mailing brochures to disseminate information that should be on the web". But it's hard to think of what that is! I guess I will say that I have PLENTY of unmet needs. There is a lot left that computers "should" be able to do. "The Dream Machine" is reminding me of that -- the vision was augmenting humans, not replacing humans with magic AI that doesn't even work. But maybe I'm too old or too cynical, but it's hard for me to think of things left that are both technologically possible (in the near term) and economically incentivized. It seems like we have the best version of "The Dream Machine" (interactive computing + global networking) that can be supported by known business models. So I guess that's why people think the next big thing will require a huge technological innovation like AI, VR, driverless cars, block chain, etc. I'd love to hear a rebuttal though! ----- Another thing "The Dream Machine" is reminding me of is how all the ARPA funding on interactive computing stemmed from the military command + control use case. That was driven by the Russians getting the bomb in 1949 and Sputnik shortly after. So here's my best prediction: there will be some cataclysmic security event. There have been some obvious ones recently, but you can imagine it being even worse. The trend is going in the right direction. That will kick off a boom in funding/tech for offensive/defensive seucrity. I actually bought a computer security index fund a year or two -- it's NOT doing great. But maybe a public event will change this. "Security" definitely falls under the category of "invisible drudgery", to the point that we don't do it! Every system we build is pretty exploitable for a low number of dollars!
- codingdave 9y agoExcept that the WWW didn't come up out of the blue and take over just because there was a problem to solve. It was an evolution of markup languages that had been evolving for along time, melded with newer networking stacks. The timing was also good in that it hit at the same time as telecommunications started to enter the homes, not just schools and business. And it didn't take over in its initial days either -- it had a few updates before it went mainstream, not the least of which was Netscape creating a friendly UX. So you may be right that something else may be lurking in a garage right now, waiting for that same combination of pieces to fall into place. But it isn't as simple as just finding the problem. Timing and execution mattered for the WWW, and it will matter for everything else.
- breck 9y ago> I wonder if there's a similar overlooked-but-universal problem that someone in a garage is working on now, that'll spark a new wave similar to the dot-com boom. I've got one for you. I've found a simpler universal grammar for programming languages. All modern programming languages use BNF grammars for syntax, and these have been researched and developed for about 60 years. But sitting unexplored for 60 years, has been another type of grammar, that uses only geometry to notate structure (achieved in practice via whitespace). I believe this new branch of languages will prove far superior to BNF languages in time, once tooling catches up. I'm self-funding research on this. Like your description of the early web, it's really unimpressive now (http://ohayo.computer http://ohayo.computer, https://github.com/breck7/treeprogram https://github.com/breck7/treeprogram), but think it will catch on and be big. It seems so obvious to me when you improve something so low level that it will have big effects. But it's been hard to convince other research groups, and of course I could be wrong.
- halfteatree 9y agoSo... lisp with optional parentheses?
- breck 9y agoClose. Except absolutely no parentheses. The important thing is that your words are laid out according to geometric rules, not via character delimiters. This has big implications for static tools, as well as future hardware that can execute trees directly (right now prototypes with FPGAs).
- pron 9y agoThe problem with this is not so much that pretty much no one is able to make money off of programming languages, but what may be one of the causes of that effect: Few if any programming languages at least in the past 20 years have been able to make much of an impact at all (meaning, significantly reduce the cost of software development). Pretty much the last one has been garbage collection. So it's always possible we're one good idea away from a breakthrough, but I, for one, am skeptical, and if there were such a revolutionary idea, it would -- like any PL progress -- be slowly carried out and perfected over decades by many research groups.
- twelvechairs 9y agoThe WWW never got any industry hype because it wasnt designed as a money making product unlike the others on your list.
- kobeya 9y ago> I wonder if there's a similar overlooked-but-universal problem that someone in a garage is working on now, that'll spark a new wave similar to the dot-com boom. Bitcoin. Seriously, it exactly matches your requirements. Typically dismissed by everyone on their first encounter, it nevertheless solves universal problems related to something everyone uses -- money. And it's only just barely viable enough to solve that problem in limited cases right now, so I predict there will be a torrent of people responding to me with all the reasons why it can't be bitcoin because X, Y, Z. Just as any technical person would have said about the web in '96.
- Ironchefpython 9y ago> Typically dismissed by everyone Yes, there's no bitcoin hype at all. > it nevertheless solves universal problems related to something everyone uses -- money. You know what is a simpler, more energy efficient, universally accepted, easier to use, time-tested, fungible, stable, and better in almost every way form of money is? Money. All the tulip mania or dotcom stocks or Florida swampland or whatever bubble fueled by something valueless without any underlying guarantees will never supplant actual money.
- kobeya 9y agoI work on bitcoin, and am very involved in the community. Every single person I have interacted with, core developers included, dismissed bitcoin on first exposure, at least in the early days. And I suggest that you sometime look into how national currencies work and the systemic risks involved. Bitcoin solves a real problem of trust and institutional moral corruption.
- Ironchefpython 9y ago> Every single person I have interacted with, core developers included, dismissed bitcoin on first exposure, at least in the early days. I was exactly the opposite. I was entranced by how cleverly the blockchain solved the n-party Byzantine Generals problem. Then I realized the while bitcoin is a neat technical solution, it doesn't solve any real-world problems except committing crimes and fueling a bubble. > Bitcoin solves a real problem of trust. No, it doesn't. For the vast majority of people on the planet, a stable fiat currency is more trusted and stable than e-tulips. Rational people trust banks more than they trust Mt. Gox. Can you give me an example of a common situation where trust is lacking, where normal people would have been better off using bitcoin than say... VISA or Mastercard?
- sah2ed 9y ago> I wonder if there's a similar overlooked-but-universal problem that someone in a garage is working on now, that'll spark a new wave similar to the dot-com boom. AR? (Assuming the recent past of Pokémon GO and the upcoming general availability of Apple's ARKit is anything to go by.)
- flunhat 9y agoHardly overlooked, though
- sah2ed 9y agoYes, but AR is really just a means to an end. ARKit could lead to the discovery of a killer app or two, similar to how Uber/Lyft's ride-hailing app is the killer application for lots of people with GPS-equipped smart phones, even though phones have had GPS tracking for ages but use was limited to mapping apps.
- octaveguin 9y agoHere are two boring problems: Affordable housing and affordable health care. For each, the current system only wants to create more cost and not benefit the consumer. Somewhere the bottom will fall out. Maybe independent housing communities will start being a thing where the land is cheap? Maybe medical tourism is where its at? Probably neither of those solutions will really work out. They're big problems, though, with real money in solutions. Technology will likely help provide an innovative path forward.
- mceoin 9y agoMedical tourism is an idea worth going after if it's something you're passionate about. There are players in the space but it's still early days. - marketplace play - moral good - huge market
- rkunnamp 9y agoIn the place that I live in, Medical Tourism is growing . It is a place named Kerala, the southern most state of India, with high literacy rates, and relatively high human development Index compared to other parts of India. Most health tourists are from middle eastern countries, though. I wouldn't be surprised if a term like Keral'ed come up in health care sector, like Bangalored in IT.
- bryananderson 9y agoI'm not convinced that it always works like this. Flight, for example, was always one of the "big" ideas that people were quixotically chasing. It just needed the right technical solution. It involved a revolution in the theory and practice of aerodynamics and the ground-up engineering of a complex system unlike anything that existed before. But it worked and it changed the world.