4 ms·
For the sake of completeness. Top capital gains rate is 20% + 3.8% medicare surcharge + state tax. In a high tax state like California, you're paying 37.1% on i
by cjlars 9y ago
For the sake of completeness. Top capital gains rate is 20% + 3.8% medicare surcharge + state tax. In a high tax state like California, you're paying 37.1% on investment income, not 15%. Also, top federal rate is 39.6%, not 35%, plus state income tax, you can pay as high as a statutory rate of 52.9% in CA, or around 47% after deductions.
And more to your point, we already have a defacto wealth tax in the US because inflation is not deductible. If you hold a bond paying 2% per year, and inflation is also 2% per year, you pay tax on those gains even though you've made a post-tax loss in purchasing power. At 2% long term inflation, the defacto wealth tax works out to be the 2% multiplied by your capital gains rate, or from 0.47% to 0.74% for high earners depending on what state they live in.
- gok 9y agoNit: That 52.9% number isn’t quite right because you get to deduct your CA income tax against your federal income tax. So in practice even if you made a billion dollars in California, you’d pay $133M to the state then get federally taxed 39.6% on the remaining $867M, giving you an effective tax rate of about 47%.
- cjlars 9y agoGood point, updated. It would be further impacted by AMT and the standard deduction thresh-hold, but that's a good estimate I think.
- humanrebar 9y ago> we already have a defacto wealth tax in the US We have actual wealth taxes, too, in the form of property taxes.