5 ms·
Looks fascinating. One thing that jumps out at me as a git user is the directory/rename tracking. Directory tracking seems like a great idea. Rename tracking
by dasil003 16y ago
Looks fascinating. One thing that jumps out at me as a git user is the directory/rename tracking.
Directory tracking seems like a great idea.
Rename tracking on the other hand seems like a fool's errand since there is no sane universal definition of what constitutes a rename; I think what git does with superficial heuristic hinting at the UI level is really the best thing there.
- gecko 16y agoI could come at that from the opposite direction: maybe getting perfect renaming is impossible, but the incredible slowness of asking Git for a file's history makes it utterly unusable in some contexts, where Mercurial/Subversion/Bazaar's rename tracking makes the same operation lightning quick. Maybe it's impossible to get it perfect, but if it can get good enough, the reward can be tangible.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoIt's possible I've seen rename tracking turn into a debacle. Personally I don't see the use for it. If you want to retain history then merge the file(s) to a different directory/name. More often than not that works more than well enough, whereas proper rename tracking can become a rabbit hole of edge cases, and if you miss even a few you can hose your users.