2 ms·
It doesn't override the Constitution, though. He's not compelled to testify against himself. In a pre-computer society, we'd understand the Fifth Amendment as a
by geofft 9y ago
It doesn't override the Constitution, though. He's not compelled to testify against himself. In a pre-computer society, we'd understand the Fifth Amendment as allowing you not to testify to your crimes, but not allowing you to refuse the police the right to search your house with a court-signed warrant, simply because you keep incriminating things in the house.
It might exploit a loophole, though (and I also think there's a lot of room to argue over whether that analogy is actually the right one).
The one thing that's different with computers is that usually the police can just break into your house (or a safe, or something like that) if you refuse to give them the key, and encrypted drives have no other alternate route in. So you wouldn't be kept in prison indefinitely for refusing to comply with a warrant; you'd just get your door knocked down.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> The one thing that's different with computers is that usually the police can just break into your house (or a safe, or something like that) if you refuse to give them the key, and encrypted drives have no other alternate route in. So you wouldn't be kept in prison indefinitely for refusing to comply with a warrant; you'd just get your door knocked down. This isn't really new with computers. People have been writing in code since time immemorial. What would have happened two hundred years ago if some defendant had been using a book cipher and the police don't know which page of which book is the key?
- goodcanadian 9y agoThis isn't really new with computers. People have been writing in code since time immemorial. What would have happened two hundred years ago if some defendant had been using a book cipher and the police don't know which page of which book is the key? I'm guessing that they would have brute-forced it. The complexity is much lower than the modern case as is the number of potential keys. I can imagine someone spending a fair bit of time in jail for contempt during this procedure, but it would not be indefinite. I can also just see the police calling in a code breaker and not bothering with the court order to tell them the key.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> I'm guessing that they would have brute-forced it. In an era before digital computers? That still isn't any different. Nothing stops the police from hiring someone to break the encryption. They may not be able to do it but that is no different than before. Many ciphers that are broken today were not broken decades or centuries ago -- good luck brute forcing even 56-bit DES in 1975. It's completely plausible that AES will be considered insecure some years in the future even if nobody can break it today.
- goodcanadian 9y ago200 years ago they did not have computers to do the encryption either; encryption schemes were comparatively simple. Also, the scenario suggested that the police had the code book, but simply did not know which page. Code breaking predates computers by millennia.
- derekp7 9y agoBut if the police found a document written in what looked like gibberish, they couldn't compel you to translate the document to English. In this case, they have executed the warrant, and found an electronic document filled with gibberish.
- ada1981 9y agoThis is the best analogy I've seen. Can you be compelled to labor to help the prosecution? What if I had a huge stone vault. To get to the inside of it would take the fed 7 years of digging. The crime they have a warrant for has a statute of limitations of 5 years. If I help them dig, they can get there in 4 years. Can they force me to dig with them?
- stinkytaco 9y agoInteresting question. In my opinion, no, they could not obligate you to help dig, because they could get someone else to help with that. If you had a key, however, it might be different?
- derekp7 9y agoFurthermore, what if you didn't have the key, but had a photographic memory and could draw out the shape of the key for them to make one? Could they then compel that?
- geofft 9y agoI think the All Writs Act as written would say yes. There's nothing in it about amount of work. The government does, I think, have to pay you. Now, in response to the use of the All Writs Act about iPhone decryption, a couple of people raised the argument that the 13th Amendment, which prohibits "involuntary servitude," might prevent the government from just telling you what your job is (even if you're paid for it). I don't know that any court has had an opinion on the validity of this argument. Also, I think the All Writs Act only applies to things that the Western legal system considers "writs," which is not clearly defined in statute anywhere. So you'd have to ask an actual lawyer who understands Western caselaw about whether "decrypt your hard drive," "write and sign firmware for an iPhone that doesn't lock you out on incorrect passcode attempts," and "dig stone for four years" count as writs. I have no idea.
- cabaalis 9y agoA password is information that you "know" not something you "have." I believe that giving a password is testifying information. This appears to be the sticking point. He is being locked up for refusing to say the equivalent of a word that would be information used against him. To me, that is being locked up for refusing to testify. Locking up for refusing is compelling. Therefore he is being compelled to testify.