7 ms·
Canada's 'Great Trail' Is Finally Connected
- mikeash 9y agoPresented without comment: "(In case you were wondering, it would take a roller-grill hot dog 76 years and 256 days to travel the entire trail network.)"
- whois 9y agoThank you
- twoodfin 9y agoLooking forward to the HN post on the first person to thru-hike/paddle it.
- notatoad 9y ago>It’s almost four times as long as the Grand Italian trail, which covers all of Italy. It’s also over five times as long as the West Coast’s famed Pacific Crest Trail, and over six times as long as the Appalachian. the difference being that the pacific crest trail, the appalachian trail, and the grand italian trail are all actually trails rather than just lines on a map. The trans canada trail isn't a real thing, it's just some marketing people looking at maps, saying "this probably counts as a trail, right" and then calling the job done. the trans-canada "trail" includes creeks, four-lane highways, and unmaintained deer tracks.
- ghaff 9y agoI'm not that cynical. A lot of work went into getting it to this point and they're not just calling in "done." That said, there appears to be an awful lot of road walking compared to most other official long distance trails, even if those do sometimes have sections of road here and there.
- QAPereo 9y agoI just can't see many experienced through hikers falling for this, so what's the point? Pure bureaucracy?
- maxerickson 9y agoIt can create demand and a some sort of nexus for planning. The North Country Trail in the US was established in 1980 and still isn't really close to done yet. An aside, the annual opportunity to actually hike the Lake Michigan crossing is coming up on Monday, the Labor Day walk over the Mackinac Bridge.
- jonknee 9y agoIt’s not exactly a through hiking type of trail, but something you would do sections of. I see no problem that it includes water passages and what not, choose the recreation type you want and go get it.
- notatoad 9y agothe problem with it including waterways is that words have meaning, and "trail" and "waterway" are words that mean different things. it's cool that they include waterways in their map. my problem is that they don't call it the "canada-wide recreation areas network", they call it a trail. and it isn't.
- ghaff 9y agoBetter tell the Northern Forest Canoe Trail https://www.northernforestcanoetrail.org/ https://www.northernforestcanoetrail.org/ "Trail" tends to imply hiking trail but there's no reason it needs to.
- njarboe 9y agoEspecially if it is called a "Canoe Trail" one would assume there is not a lot of hiking.
- uoaei 9y agoStretches of the Pacific Crest Trail are also unsegregated shoulders of Highway 1.
- notatoad 9y agoWhat do you mean by "stretches"? 1km? 10km? looking around the map near me for an example, there's a section of trans canada "trail" from olds to airdrie that is just highway 2A travelling in a dead straight line for about 100km.
- nether 9y agoNot even close. The PCH follows the coast and the PCT follows mountain crests: http://www.bigbearhostel.com/uploads/6/9/6/1/6961020/9626729.jpg?477 http://www.bigbearhostel.com/uploads/6/9/6/1/6961020/9626729...
- seattle_spring 9y agoThis is definitely not true. Are you thinking of the California Coastal Trail? Highway 1 runs directly on the coast. The PCT runs along the crest of the Sierra Nevada and Cascade mountain ranges-- more than 100+ miles to the east of Highway 1.
- problems 9y agoAdditionally, much of the actual "trail" in it is rail-to-trail conversions, flat stretches with private farm land on both sides. Not exactly an exciting hike.
- 51Cards 9y agoNo trails that go these kinds of distances are "exciting" all the time. Fairly hard to hike across Canada without going through the prairies for example. :)
- kdbg 9y agoAnother thing is that it is quite stupidly routed in some areas with real trails. As a reasonably experienced long distance hiker, and being from Canada when I heard about the trail nearing completion my first though was, can I through hike this. I looked into the logistics of doing this in about a year of hiking . Crux would be getting out of the North and mountains and into SK for winter. Anyway, my first thought was damn there is a lot of road walking up north. Then I decided to see what it looked like when it ran through the town I grew up in, take a look: http://se.ri0.us/2017-09-02-134045614-af037.png http://se.ri0.us/2017-09-02-134045614-af037.png Notice how part of the 'trail' isn't even connected to the rest, how it does a lollipop in the southeast And if thats bad, a little west of there it has a huge lollipop into another town: http://se.ri0.us/2017-09-02-134257918-22a76.png http://se.ri0.us/2017-09-02-134257918-22a76.png And the Toronto area, just goes out to Detroit and then nothing: http://se.ri0.us/2017-09-02-134402430-7fd8a.png http://se.ri0.us/2017-09-02-134402430-7fd8a.png I get that its a connection of recreational trails and some of the weird routing is because the town's local trails are not meant to be trails 'to' somewhere but really, this is just bad design. As the trail does lollipops and has dead-ends I really don't think its fair to compare its length to more proper trails that one could reasonable follow end to end without needing to hike segments multiple times (there and back). I really wish The Great Trail was an awesome, trans-Canada hike, I really do, buts its just a great disappointment to me. I think funding/support this trail had would have been better spent on some of the amazing trails Canada has like the Great Divide Trail.
- kentt 9y agoI ran about 15 miles of this today (goes through my hometown). Some notable points: - about 500m on a two lablne road with no shoulder and 80km speed limit - 3 miles on the most beautiful abandoned road that looks like a Josh Keyes painting. I've done 100 runs down here and never seen anyone on it - 10 miles on a dyke. I bit close to the highway at points but a well loved and travelled trail. - the rest through suburbia. If there wasn't signs (and there often isn't you wouldn't know it was part of a "trail" since it's a normal sidewalk).
- deanCommie 9y ago> A quarter of this length is water—wetland and river routes where hikers will have to trade boots for boats. This is another problem. If you think you could do this entirely by human power, you're wrong. Zoom in on Vancouver, and the trail crossing the water across the Burrard Inlet in a zone where non-motor-powered boats are ILLEGAL (between the two bridges is the port, cruise ship terminals, and a busy float plane airport. No kayaks or paddle boards or sailing allowed. You'd think they'd plot a path in the 3rd largest city in Canada that is navigatable by kayak.
- njarboe 9y agoThe first thing most people who would be interested in this topic want to see is a map. None in this article. For an interactive map see: https://thegreattrail.ca/explore-the-map/ https://thegreattrail.ca/explore-the-map/
- goodcanadian 9y agoThat map is linked in the article . . .
- njarboe 9y agoTrue. Wanted to see the map right away so googled for it before reading all the way through. Ended up spending time on the map and forgot about the article till later. I guess that is why the author put the map link at the very end of the article. A map image at the start of the article might have kept people reading.
- jayvanguard 9y agoWhy did they change the name from the Trans Canada Trail? I liked it better.
- philipov 9y agoMaybe they wanted to make hiking Great again.
- ghaff 9y agoFYI, this is apparently what used to be referred to as the Trans-Canada Trail. I have a poster I picked up ages ago; it was probably around the time that the trail was first being promoted. Note that "connected" is somewhat euphemistic (and controversial). [1] A lot of the trail is unsegregated shoulders of highways. [1] http://www.cbc.ca/radio/the180/the-not-so-great-trans-canada-trail-it-s-ok-to-be-grumpy-at-work-policing-free-speech-on-campus-1.4078755/it-s-dangerous-to-call-the-trans-canada-trail-complete-says-cyclist-1.4078859 http://www.cbc.ca/radio/the180/the-not-so-great-trans-canada...
- kurthr 9y agoWow, at least the P.E.I. government has revised their Trans Canada Trail guide, which said you would never need to leave the trail... We got to Prince Edward Island which was supposed to be the safest place in Canada to cycle, and the afternoon we arrived we were riding on the Trans Canada Trail, the trail guide took us off the trail, we did 2.9 kilometres on a highway, and she was struck by a drunk driver and killed.
- justinator 9y agoYeah, and water!
- sandworm101 9y agoTrail has been in place for years. What this is is the end of a decades-long debate about trail use. Parts of the trail were once open to motor vehicles (quads, logging roads etc) and some people dont think that should count. Note the very specific language about use, that snow machines are allowed in winter and horses in summer. Some trails are also on private land, where limitation on use gets complicated. This the end of a long debate between specific parties not the physical completion of any great work.
- Alex3917 9y agoI recently spent some time trying to figure out the furthest north you can drive in Canada by car (or at least without a float plane), and what there is to do up there. It's actually pretty interesting. Apparently you can get up to James Bay via the James Bay Road and the Trans Taiga Highway, but there isn't any way to actually get up to Hudson Bay without a boat or a float plane. It's crazy how much of the country is basically unexplored. Apparently over 90% of the lakes don't even have names, so you can name a lake if you want to be the first person to visit it.
- ghaff 9y agoI think the furthest north you can drive is probably Whitehorse in Yukon [EDIT: not BC] on the Pan-American Highway. But presumably you were looking at the eastern end of Canada. [ADDED: As someone else noted, you can keep going north of Whitehorse with the Pan-American Highway eventually crossing the border with Alaska or the Dempsey Highway.]
- notatoad 9y agoWhitehorse is in the Yukon, not BC. And you can keep going up past Whitehorse on the Alaska highway
- emilyfm 9y agoYou can drive a further 1200km+ road distance north of Whitehorse, Yukon on the Dempster Highway to Inuvik in the Northwest Territories. End of the road appears to be just north of town: https://goo.gl/maps/shD9UoxTtK42 https://goo.gl/maps/shD9UoxTtK42 Western Canada is big. If you drive from Inuvik to San Diego over 60% of the entire road distance is within Canada.
- abruzzi 9y agoThey're actually building a road north out of Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk, which will take you to the Arctic Ocean: http://www.cbc.ca/news/multimedia/driving-to-the-top-of-the-world-exploring-canada-s-new-arctic-highway-1.4073615 http://www.cbc.ca/news/multimedia/driving-to-the-top-of-the-...
- nbanks 9y agoA few years ago I road the section from Magog to Montréal, QC which is part of Quebec's "Route Verte". This stretch was completed separate from highways and only occasionally crossed roads. What I noticed most was that it was nowhere near the fastest way to travel because it often went in a round about route instead of following a straight line. The section near Mont Orford was likely the slowest bike path I've been on, followed by a section near Waterloo, Quebec which was a converted rail line which was likely the fastest. The lack of straight lines may be part of the reason why there's 21,000km of trail when you can bike from St. John's to Victoria in just 7,000km.
- microcolonel 9y agoMan, I'm going to traverse this thing if I can. I wonder how long it would take to walk it (and boat somehow, don't think you could swim it). Probably not practical on foot, about two years of ten-hour days maybe, and that's in good weather. Added: Looks like somebody has already done the whole east-west leg.
- jbeales 9y agoThere's a guy[1] who has been working on hiking it all for a couple of years. I think he just has a bit of the journey from somewhere in the Yukon to the Arctic Ocean left. [1]https://www.facebook.com/thegreathike/ https://www.facebook.com/thegreathike/
- pavement 9y agoarticle includes no map Seriously? EDIT: https://thegreattrail.ca https://thegreattrail.ca https://cangeo-media-library.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/images/web_articles/article_images/4519/transcanada_trail_final_04.jpg https://cangeo-media-library.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/im...