6 ms·
> "The fact remains that the government has not brought charges," Donoghue said in a telephone interview. "Our client has now been in custody for almost 18 mont
by geofft 9y ago
> "The fact remains that the government has not brought charges," Donoghue said in a telephone interview. "Our client has now been in custody for almost 18 months based on his assertion of his Fifth Amendment right against compelled self-incrimination."
To be clear (and I am pretty sure the public defender knows this, but is just phrasing it like this for public perception), the prosecution's position is that the Fifth Amendment is irrelevant because they're compelling him to do an act under the All Writs Act and not to testify about anything (produce a password, produce files, etc.). The approach they're taking is that he's a person in a position to do something to let the government access evidence, and it doesn't matter that he's the person they want evidence against, instead of a third party (as with New York Telephone Co., or more recently Apple), and he's in prison for refusing compliance with the writ.
It's totally unclear that this legal strategy should work in a just/ideal society, but, at least for now, the courts are allowing it.
- cabaalis 9y agoSo much for that whole constitution thing anyway.. They can just create some "act" that overrides it! And nobody will complain because the person affected is the bad guy, until they come for them.
- stinkytaco 9y agoBut they are not asking him to testify, admit guilt, or anything like that. They aren't even asking him to tell them the password, just to enter the password to decrypt. This is more like expecting access to your house when a search warrant is provided. EDIT: To be clear, it's not that I feel he should necessarily be compelled, but rather that a fifth amendment defense is weak in this case, since it's not a testimony at all, but rather revealing already existing material (as opposed to compelling the defendant to write a confession).
- dopamean 9y agoThis may be a dumb question but I want to make sure I'm getting everything here... they have a warrant to search the hard drive?
- stinkytaco 9y agoYes, there is a court order compelling him to unlock the drives. The really questionable thing here is that they haven't charged him with any crimes, even contempt. That shows there may be a desire to establish some precedent in this case. EDIT: Scratch that, you can hold someone in jail as long as they are in contempt of court, apparently.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> They aren't even asking him to tell them the password, just to enter the password to decrypt. How are you distinguishing one from the other? What makes compelling someone to speak the password aloud different from compelling them to type it with a keyboard?
- stinkytaco 9y agoWell, the government has made a distinction for physical security [1]. So it's probably not too much of a jump to make. That case is probably the closest case law to this one we have, though the facts aren't quite the same (the police didn't have as much evidence for what might be on the phone in that case). [1]: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/01/court-rules-against-man-who-was-forced-to-fingerprint-unlock-his-phone/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/01/court-rules-agai... EDIT: Worth pointing out that line in that case is really "physical evidence" vs. "knowledge". The court argues that the fingerprint unlocking the smartphone is closer to a blood sample than a testimony. However, I could definitely see a court seeing this as "it's ok to make someone unlock" because they didn't just collect the physical evidence, but made him take the action of unlocking the phone.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThe obvious difference is that fingerprints aren't testimony. They aren't in your mind, they're on your hand.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoHow can they validate that he's provided an accurately decrypted hard drive, without the password?
- geofft 9y agoIt doesn't override the Constitution, though. He's not compelled to testify against himself. In a pre-computer society, we'd understand the Fifth Amendment as allowing you not to testify to your crimes, but not allowing you to refuse the police the right to search your house with a court-signed warrant, simply because you keep incriminating things in the house. It might exploit a loophole, though (and I also think there's a lot of room to argue over whether that analogy is actually the right one). The one thing that's different with computers is that usually the police can just break into your house (or a safe, or something like that) if you refuse to give them the key, and encrypted drives have no other alternate route in. So you wouldn't be kept in prison indefinitely for refusing to comply with a warrant; you'd just get your door knocked down.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> The one thing that's different with computers is that usually the police can just break into your house (or a safe, or something like that) if you refuse to give them the key, and encrypted drives have no other alternate route in. So you wouldn't be kept in prison indefinitely for refusing to comply with a warrant; you'd just get your door knocked down. This isn't really new with computers. People have been writing in code since time immemorial. What would have happened two hundred years ago if some defendant had been using a book cipher and the police don't know which page of which book is the key?
- goodcanadian 9y agoThis isn't really new with computers. People have been writing in code since time immemorial. What would have happened two hundred years ago if some defendant had been using a book cipher and the police don't know which page of which book is the key? I'm guessing that they would have brute-forced it. The complexity is much lower than the modern case as is the number of potential keys. I can imagine someone spending a fair bit of time in jail for contempt during this procedure, but it would not be indefinite. I can also just see the police calling in a code breaker and not bothering with the court order to tell them the key.
- lightedman 9y agoThe courts are trying to say that the Fifth Amendment only applies to witnesses. They're deliberately misleading the people in this case. The fifth amendment clearly states "No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation." Note the "nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself" telling him to decrypt that hard drive is still in effect forcing him to be a witness against himself. These judges saying the fifth amendment doesn't apply should be sued for constitutional violations.
- sjy 9y agoAre you denying that the Fifth Amendment only applies to witnesses (which seems clear from the text), or are you just disputing the court's decision that being compelled to decrypt a hard drive is not 'in effect' forcing someone 'to be a witness against himself' within the meaning of the Fifth Amendment?
- lightedman 9y ago"Are you denying that the Fifth Amendment only applies to witnesses" Yes, because of the first two words of the entire amendment - "No person" that 100% excludes any qualifying status and grants everyone immunity from testifying in any effect against themselves.
- rayiner 9y agoNot quite. The prosecution’s position is that the 5th Amendment doesn’t apply here, which makes all the All Writs stuff permissible: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2017/03/20/third-circuit-doesnt-resolve-standard-for-forced-decryption-under-the-fifth-amendment/?utm_term=.0729bb4e2db0 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201.... The Third Circuit punted in the legal question, stating that even if the 5th Amendment applied to being forced to hand over a decryption key, the guy couldn’t invoke his Fifth Amendment right here because of legal technicalities (see Kerr’s analysis in the link above).
- jo909 9y agoMy analogy would be that 1. There is an unbreakable safe 2. The judge believes he has the key to the unbreakable safe 3. They know there is evidence inside the safe 4. They ask him to unlock the safe 5. He refuses to do so, so they try to force him by jailing him They do not ask him to testify about the safes contents or even to hand over the key, just to "insert and turn the key". And their argument is that he can not refuse that by pleading the fifth. In a physical world they would be able to seize the key from him by force even if he gets hurt in the process (within some limits). In the end he will probably be able to argue that he does no longer have the key, and they will not be able to proof he still has. But _at the moment_ this is not whats being argued about. (Not saying I find anything about that right or just or moral, but I do not find it completely without reason)
- 1_2__4 9y agoThe fact that he possesses no physical key is the crux of the matter. Any metaphor that tries to use objects like keys is pointless - there would be no controversy if there was a physical key.
- jo909 9y agoWell there are plenty of safes without physical keys that use pin-pads. To to bring that analogy a little closer to reality then, they are trying to force him to enter the pin into the safe. And again the current argument is not about whether he knows the pin or not, just whether he can refuse to enter it by arguing that this would be "being witness against himself", i.e. protected by the fifth.
- eru 9y agoA physical key is equivalent to its shape. So if you have a picture of the key, or just memorise its shape, you can throw away the physical copy.
- Clubber 9y agoI think a more apt analogy is a cyphered letter. Instead of anything physical like turning a key, the judge is compelling him to decipher the letter.
- ada1981 9y agoHow does one prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that I haven't actually forgotten the password? If I've forgotten the password, wouldn't I no longer be in a position to aid in obtaining the evidence? Would the burden of proof be on the fed to prove that I have not forgotten the password? If I lost the physical keys to a vault, could in be held for not being able to open it? I think Child pornography / abuse is one of the worst offenses possible, but in this case, they need to find another way to convict him if he is guilty.
- johncolanduoni 9y ago> How does one prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that I haven't actually forgotten the password? It appears the disk wasn't fully encrypted (since they found hashes of individual files), so they likely know when the computer was last used and possibly when the data in question was last decrypted. I don't think the former being very recent should be enough to establish that he hasn't forgotten the password, but the latter sure seems like a good standard.