2 ms·
The battle over the question whether or not something exists in the mathematical sense has essentially been won by the formalists, who will allow any definition
by yorwba 9y ago
The battle over the question whether or not something exists in the mathematical sense has essentially been won by the formalists, who will allow any definition to claim the existence of something so long as it is consistent with the rest of mathematics.
Then, given that 0.99999... exists, what useful properties could it possibly have, if it is to be treated as a number.
0.99999... = 0.9999... * 1 = 0.99999... * 9/9 = 0.99999... * (10 - 1)/9 = (0.99999... * 10 - 0.99999... * 1)/9 = (9.99999... - 0.99999...)/9 = 9.00000.../9 = 9/9 = 1
So if 0.99999... exists and has the same arithmetic properties as decimal expansions of rational numbers, its value must be 1. Now whether you think it should have these properties is an entirely different question, but most mathematicians seem to like it this way.