3 ms·
Whenever I see this "We're inside a black hole" idea, two things always come to mind: 1. Wouldn't this invalidate the laws of thermodynamics, with energy pouri
by chc 16y ago
Whenever I see this "We're inside a black hole" idea, two things always come to mind:
1. Wouldn't this invalidate the laws of thermodynamics, with energy pouring into the universe out of "nowhere"?
2. Conversely, shouldn't the universe be evaporating?
- hugh3 16y agoIt's the creation of the universe. It's pretty much going to violate conservation of energy no matter how you slice it.
- chc 16y agoBut I mean, shouldn't conservation of energy be invalid right now, as more matter and energy fall into our universe from the outside-place? It sounds like he's not just saying black holes spawn universes, but that universes exist inside black holes. Thus universes should grow in mass beyond what they started with, and should eventually lose all their mass to Hawking radiation.
- Rhapso 16y agoWell, if we assume a big-crunch outcome of the universe, then it could be said that all matter would end up inside 1 big black hole. And then it might follow that the universe is re-spawned inside of the black hole. This solves your 2 issues, all escaping material would be re-absorbed, and there would only be a background oscillation of energy in and out of the universe that would net to a constant. This example kinda kills the whole romantic-fantasy element of universes in black holes, since you would only get 1 child universe per parent universe, and it would not really be noticeable from our point of view. (what happens to those poor universes when 2 of the black holes combine??)