3 ms·
And yet, the way RIAA portrays it is as if every album has a set number of potential sales, and each instance of piracy takes away from those potential sales.
by baddox 16y ago
And yet, the way RIAA portrays it is as if every album has a set number of potential sales, and each instance of piracy takes away from those potential sales. The truth is, the piracy rate will usually be pretty constant across all albums, e.g. one album sale for every 20 free downloads.
- philwelch 16y agoThere's no contradiction there--it's entirely possible there will be one album sale for every 20 pirate downloads, but that doesn't rule out the possibility that each album is capable of selling 20 times more than it does. It's implausible, but not logically ruled out. More to the point, maybe for those 20 free downloads, 5-6 would have actually bought the album but didn't, and 5-6 (possibly overlapping set) will be convinced to see a show or buy a t-shirt, so the actual financial situation for the band isn't so much different as they think it is.
- blueben 16y agoThis isn't just about demand for an album; demand is tempered by the price attached to the product. This is about demand for an album at $15/copy. There is demand for the album; the downloads demonstrate that. There is almost no demand for that same album at $15/copy. That is the limit of what you can assume about this scenario.