3 ms·
This type of argument about meritocracy and class, although important, is missing the point. It's not as if you eliminated all class contributions to elite sch
by daveolsim 9y ago
This type of argument about meritocracy and class, although important, is missing the point.
It's not as if you eliminated all class contributions to elite school attendance suddenly problems with meritocracy would disappear.
The problem is that we overvalue superficial indicators of ability or human capital as if they were perfect, and ignore more significant, directly relevant ones.
Not too long ago, there was a linked article about selection bias in education (https://fredrikdeboer.com/2017/03/29/why-selection-bias-is-the-most-powerful-force-in-education/ https://fredrikdeboer.com/2017/03/29/why-selection-bias-is-t...). Lurking in that insightful essay were even darker problems, though: if you look at Figure 1 of that piece, what you might notice was the huge spread in CLA scores as a function of SAT, revealing how imperfect SAT is. But it goes further than that, because each of those points is a mean, and behind each point is an even wider distribution. What we tend to do is take something like SAT, and treat it as if it were a perfect rank ordering of ability, when it's not. I'm not saying SAT is all it takes to get into an elite school; what I'm saying is that we overvalue things like SAT in evaluating outcomes, and ignore all the vicissitudes of life. It's not a class-based issue, it's much broader than that.
This extends much more broadly in my opinion than education, though, to licensing laws, regulatory capture, patent abuse, corporate management, etc. There's a kind of "winner takes all", or "the end justifies all rationalizations for the means", assumption with regard to credit in our society, and meritocracy is just one symptom of this.
It becomes mindless at times.