8 ms·
In an interesting (to me at least) move intel instead of competing on price when AMD put out a competitive offering they decided to keep prices the same more or
by gigatexal 9y ago
In an interesting (to me at least) move intel instead of competing on price when AMD put out a competitive offering they decided to keep prices the same more or less or increase them by adding value. Faster AVX units, more cores, more SKUs (not sure about that last one). And while intel has margins to maintain AMD has put features into their chips for years. For example AES has been shipping in most every desktop and server CPU while only some intel ones get it. Most AMD chips can do VT-D etc while the same feature is relegated to higher end chips generally on intel.
- simias 9y agoI could be wrong but I assume that there's enough inertia in the high-end business-to-business side of things (the part that matters for high-end server processors) that they probably can keep milking that cow for a few years more. People who have only been buying Intel CPU in the last decade won't jump ship immediately. Nobody gets fired for buying Intel CPUs, at least until very recently. You know you won't have compatibility issues etc... Of course within the next few years Intel will have to react somehow, either by outperforming AMD significantly to justify the premium or by slashing prices.
- gigatexal 9y agoI know I hope AMD can keep up the pressure and keep iterating.
- douglasfshearer 9y ago> Nobody ever got fired for buying IBM. Replace IBM with Intel for the 2010s version.
- tengbretson 9y agoAnd yet there are still people out there buying IBM and somehow not getting fired for it.
- abakker 9y agoDo you frequently see people getting fired for purchasing decisions?
- dijit 9y agoSystems Engineer here; Absolutely. Good example is that we bought 1,000 servers, 256G memory, dual socket Xeon E5-2687w v4 etc; The things didn't come with a TPM module and it was a business requirement to run: A) Windows B) Full Disk Encryption TPM modules were not available to us in such quantities.
- gigatexal 9y agoSo, um, ... what happened to those now "useless" servers. Wondering for a friend ;-)
- yourapostasy 9y agoAvailable software constraints choices in many of those cases. Put two choices in front of an application team exec: rewrite and port an application from POWER/AIX, POWER/System i, POWER/System z for $X million, with all the attending risks that entails. Or spend same $X million on new IBM hardware, and get more capacity, performance, etc., while the system administrators/system programmers update the underlying OS, with lower magnitude of risks and impacts, and if the sysadmins screw up, that's another department, not yours, anyways. Even if porting is a one-time charge, and saves Y * $X million in N years (where N usually <5). The choice to avoid risk is easy. This is why, by the way, selling to C-suite, or above middle management, as much as it is hated in technical circles, is used. The higher you go in management, the more risk is able to be shouldered. If Intel hypes up any AMD compatibility issues Intel can find, then that urge to avoid risk will play to Intel's advantage.
- sigzero 9y agoPort away from? We moved everything TO POWER/AIX.
- jsolson 9y agoI suspect anyone ordering top-bin CPU skus by the pallet-load has an ongoing program for evaluating performance-normalized TCO of at least a few candidate platforms based around a few candidate processors.
- gsnedders 9y agoHeck, why has Google been investing heavily in OpenPOWER? I bet it's as much as keeping the option there and making it as attractive as possible: gives them a far stronger negotiating position with Intel.
- wlesieutre 9y agoI saw mentioned in another thread that all AMD processors support ECC RAM, provided you pick a motherboard that does it.
- fish_fan 9y agoThis alone could save you thousands.
- frozenport 9y agoNot really. Low-end Xeons with ECC cost >$300.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wlesieutre 9y agoSure, but with a $300 budget on Intel you're choosing between an i7-7700K or a Xeon E3-1245v6, which are all but identical. The Xeon has a slightly higher base clock, slightly lower turbo (all clocks are changed by 0.1 GHz), ECC, and a locked clock multiplier. It appears to benchmark consistently a couple of percent below the i7. What's even the point of that product segmentation existing? To annoy their customers? I'd rather just buy a $300 processor that checks all the feature boxes instead of all but one. http://www.cpu-monkey.com/en/compare_cpu-intel_xeon_e3_1245_v6-718-vs-intel_core_i7_7700-665 http://www.cpu-monkey.com/en/compare_cpu-intel_xeon_e3_1245_...
- magila 9y agoI suspect Intel is not too worried about AMD because they've seen this script before. When AMD's Opteron server CPUs came out they offered vastly superior performance and scaleability compared to contemporary Xeons. Even with a clear technical advantage, AMD never came close to matching Intel's volume in the server market. Today, AMD's Eypc CPUs are a much closer match to their Xeon competitors than Opteron was. So if history is anything to go by, Intel has little to fear from AMD's latest efforts.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoAMD wasn't able to match Intel's volume because Intel engaged in outright bribery of PC and server vendors on a impressively massive scale (they literally paid out hundreds of millions per year — and that's just to one vendor — as an incentive not to buy AMD). Other factors obviously didn't help, but this was clearly a huge one. Given they've been slapped down for this, I wonder if they'll try it again. If they don't, AMD could have an easier go this time round.
- temac 9y agoI don't completely understand the "need" for bribery. Could they just not lower their prices? (which could have resulted in the same balance in the end)
- dboreham 9y agoI think you're confused about "couldn't match their volume". Parent means (I think) that AMD couldn't _sell_ enough units. Not that they couldn't _make_ enough units (which is I think your interpretation). They couldn't sell enough because someone was paying their customers not to buy their (superior) product.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoI think temac was suggesting Intel could sell cheaper chips. Why would Intel need to bribe the competition?