4 ms·
Rust doesn't have any more runtime than C, and also doesn't have a GC. Servo has bindings into SpiderMonkey's GC so that the JavaScript stuff works properly, bu
by steveklabnik 9y ago
Rust doesn't have any more runtime than C, and also doesn't have a GC. Servo has bindings into SpiderMonkey's GC so that the JavaScript stuff works properly, but that's only that part.
That said, I don't think there are any direct blog posts about it; Firefox's other code just sees Rust as C code, as far as I know. (I don't work on Firefox though so I could be wrong about some details.)
- smegel 9y agoI swear I had read Rust had optional GC at one point. And similarly Rust wanting to own main(). Maybe not then.
- burntsushi 9y agoI don't know the precise history, but at one point, it did have a "gc" type, which I believe was demarcated by the `@` sigil. So, for example, `@T` was a garbage collected pointer to `T`. IIRC, the actual garbage collector was simplistic, and was mostly just reference counting under the hood. At some point (in 2014, I think), the GC type went away. Since then, there has never been any serious talk of adding an optional GC to Rust proper, although many folks have worked/written about writing their own.
- steveklabnik 9y agoThis is pretty accurate; however, a very long time ago there was a tracing GC!
- iopq 9y agoAre you sure? I thought @ was reference counted in 0.6 and then removed after. Was it before that?
- steveklabnik 9y agoI don't have any citation beyond "Graydon told me one time". It was like, very very long ago, possibly before @T even existed.
- Rusky 9y agoIIRC it was a mark and sweep GC in the OCaml implementation.
- steveklabnik 9y agoThat sounds about right.
- jacobush 9y agoWow, I can't believe I have been reading up lately on official Rust documentation and still I was under the impression that Rust had optional GC. Thanks for sorting me out...
- kbenson 9y agoWell, I think is sort of does when you use the Rc types, right? It's just much more explicit than a type modifier, it's a type wrapper that requires requires some level of additional code ornamentation in some instances when using later as well. It's just not really any different than using a library in C++ that offers the same, except that in Rust's case the library is part of the stdlib.
- steveklabnik 9y agoRust had almost everything at some point :) Rust binaries do define a "main", and setting that up is the runtime's job, like C. But you can also make a library that needs no main at all.
- oscargrouch 9y ago> That said, I don't think there are any direct blog posts about it; Firefox's other code just sees Rust as C code, as far as I know. So it means the compiled binary ends up in a simple compatible C ABI? thats pretty nice, if thats the case. But giving the project is using LLVM, even C++ ABI would be achievable without too much effort (i guess).
- burntsushi 9y agoTo clarify, Rust has its own ABI, just like C++ has its own ABI. And just like C++, you can expose a C ABI if you want by defining special functions. In C++, it's an `extern "C" { ... }` block, and in Rust, it's a `extern "C" fn foo() ...` function declaration. You can see an example here: https://github.com/rust-lang/regex/tree/master/regex-capi https://github.com/rust-lang/regex/tree/master/regex-capi Adding C++ ABI support is a significant effort.
- oscargrouch 9y ago> To clarify, Rust has its own ABI, just like C++ has its own ABI. And just like C++, you can expose a C ABI if you want by defining special functions. In C++, it's an `extern "C" { ... }` block, and in Rust, it's a `extern "C" fn foo() ...` function declaration. Ohh, Now i got it. But its pretty good thing to have anyway. C ABI is the lingua franca anyway to communicate to any language, even C++. > Adding C++ ABI support is a significant effort. Ok. So if has its own ABI, im sure it would be a pretty hard undertaking to be compatible with C++. I was guessing if maybe Rust had managed to squeeze and reuse the C++ ABI.. but sure, giving Rust is not that much alike C++ this would probably be a bad decision for small gains. Thanks for clarifying.
- Manishearth 9y agobindgen actually has the option to generate wrappers for C++ methods and other stuff for Rust to call. We don't use this, but we do use its ability to generate templates and stuff. The other way around -- getting Rust to use the C++ abi -- needs compiler changes and also has questionable benefits.