3 ms·
> Ban players for PEDs .... Suspensions are not enough, because even if a player stops doing them, he may have made himself unnaturally big, strong and fast. T
by cratermoon 9y ago
> Ban players for PEDs .... Suspensions are not enough, because even if a player stops doing them, he may have made himself unnaturally big, strong and fast.
This is really insightful. I don't know much about HGH but I know steroid use is something that a guy can do for a while, gain muscle and size, and stop, and yes, some of that size will go away, but there's a base that will never go away. That's a fact a lot of folks don't know, that steroids have permanent effects. The sport may catch a guy cycling and suspend him for a few games or a season, but it doesn't matter. He's already gotten growth that he can then build on without PEDs, and gotten an advantage over guys who never use steroids.
- hkmurakami 9y agoThe problem is that you'll still be paid before getting banned. This is the problem cycling and other PED rampant sports face. You can take away the medals but you can't take away their money and you can't take away the fact that they've enjoyed their fame while it lasted
- Bartweiss 9y agoSure, but you can probably make the sport a bit safer. In cycling or tennis, the lasting effect of PED use (after stopping) is being more competitive. In football, the lasting effect is being more dangerous to other players on the field. That's a huge distinction.
- hkmurakami 9y agoBut even if you make the penalty a ban, players are still incentivizing to try to cheat the system because they'll get paid. You have to take away both the financial and glory rewards of PEDs
- differentView 9y agoThey lose money when they're banned.
- hkmurakami 9y agoMore often than not, they wouldn't be able to make the first batch of money without the aid of PEDs. This is pressure that even MLB minor league players face.
- Bartweiss 9y agoThis seems like an almost irreducible problem. For existing players, the risk of consequences is a deterrent. For prospective players, the risk is worthwhile for anyone who wouldn't be drafted without PEDs.
- Bartweiss 9y agoYeah, agreed. I wasn't interpreting that as an attempt to end PED use, just to mitigate damage once it's found.