4 ms·
Well, yes and no. The philosophy behind freedom of speech is (to greatly simplify) "it's so much better for the advancement of ideas when people can say contro
by SilasX 9y ago
Well, yes and no.
The philosophy behind freedom of speech is (to greatly simplify) "it's so much better for the advancement of ideas when people can say controversial things without being afraid of material reprisals."
One way to promote the ideal is to not push legal penalties against those who say such things. That's the basis of the legal protection of speech, and specific countries' laws thereon (in the US, the First Amendment).
But you get the same disaster, and failure of the ideal, when non-governmental actors do it. If everyone fears going into poverty when they say something controversial, well, we're in the same crappy-ideas-that-no-one-criticizes dystopia.
Hence my frustration at those who give the lecture about "lol First Amendment is just for the government" and "lol why should they have to pay you when they don't like your ideas?" Yes, they're technically correct, but it's comically missing the point to "stand up for free speech" but also cheer on the technically-legal ways you can make someone suffer for disagreeing with you.
That doesn't mean we should force you to keep buying from those whose ideas you don't like. It does mean we shouldn't be sanguine about orgs using financial power over someone's livelihood to keep their (potentially) good ideas from being spoken.
- pfisch 9y agoThis is sort of ridiculous. You don't have to keep someone on your payroll who is actively speaking out about white supremacy. There should be social consequences for your speech, just not legal ones.
- AlgorithmicTime 9y agoSocial censorship of speech is nearly as dangerous as government censorship of speech. We need to have a robust norm of not trying to silence people for dissenting viewpoints
- pfisch 9y agoSo if my employee is advocating murdering me and my entire family that is cool? I have to fund someone who is actively trying to get political support to put me in a concentration camp?
- spacemanmatt 9y agoWe have a robust norm of socially distancing ourselves from disgusting viewpoints. It is absolutely nothing likely being imprisoned for your speech.
- pfisch 9y agoHow am I getting downvotes for not wanting to help fund white supremacy? Who are the readers of this site?
- SilasX 9y ago>This is sort of ridiculous. You don't have to keep someone on your payroll who is actively speaking out about white supremacy. I explicitly agreed with that. Did you see this part? >>That doesn't mean we should force you to keep buying from those whose ideas you don't like. (Note: "keeping someone on your payroll" = "keep buying from them".) >There should be social consequences for your speech, just not legal ones. I just explained how the standard grounding for free speech doesn't distinguish between social vs legal consequences, and how the latter are only one part of the puzzle. If you dispute that logic, I'd like to hear your thinking.
- imgabe 9y agoThe immediate problem I see with extending free speech protection to keeping your job is something like this: Suppose a company has a disgruntled employee. The employee starts badmouthing them all over the place. Assume it doesn't rise to the level of libel or slander, but they're still causing significant problems. Is the company supposed to be required to keep employing this person or face a freedom-of-speech lawsuit? That seems absurd. The fundamental problem here I think is the assumption that an employer is somehow "responsible" for the employee's livelihood. Employment is a simple business transaction. Neither party should be obligated to anything beyond what they agreed to at the start of the transaction. If you go buy an apple from a store, are you now responsible for that store-owner's livelihood from then on? Are you obligated to keep buying apples there and buying enough to provide the storeowner a living wage? If someone is living so far outside their means that a temporary job loss is going to cause them ruin, that's their fault, not the company's. There's much we could do in terms of providing a better social safety net as well, but I think we're best off keeping economic transactions as purely economic as possible.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoThat is why the problem is not corporations' ability to fire employees, but whether that corporation is a monopoly, i. e. that employee's only option for employment. For a corporation with competition, the ability to fire someone over disagreement is clearly reasonable, since that employee may prefer work with another corporation in that sector. To contrast: For a monopoly, the ability to fire someone over disagreement, and no other merit, is suddenly transformed into an abuse over free speech. The employee can't speak out against a monopoly, and expect to find work afterward, meaning that employee has poignant reason not to speak out in the first place.
- Goladus 9y agoAlso, a corollary: employment monopolies can be established with blacklists. Refusing to hire someone because they were placed on a blacklist for protected speech is wrong (and I believe, illegal). After the Damore incident there were numerous reports of people within Google openly bragging about maintaining such blacklists.
- mulmen 9y agoI think your simplification misses an important distinction which you address later in your comment. The first amendment protects from reprisals from the government. If we are in a world where the government suppresses speech we are in a different kind of dystopia than one where corporations do the same thing. The solution will be different because the way we interact with our government is different from the way we interact with corporations.
- Goladus 9y agoThis is true, but it does mean we have drag people past thinking about free speech strictly in terms of the 1st amendment. All too often people respond to a situation like the OP with "freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences" and consider the discussion over. Parent poster has clearly experienced this. See also: Marsh vs. Alabama. Relates more to platforms like Youtube and Twitter but is still relevant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_v._Alabama https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_v._Alabama Marsh v. Alabama, 326 U.S. 501 (1946), was a case decided by the United States Supreme Court, in which it ruled that a state trespassing statute could not be used to prevent the distribution of religious materials on a town's sidewalk, notwithstanding the fact that the sidewalk where the distribution was taking place was part of a privately owned company town. The Court based its ruling on the provisions of the First Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment.
- SilasX 9y agoOut of curiosity, did you read the following paragraphs? I thought I addressed that pretty thoroughly.