2 ms·
Attempting to argue about the value of dynamic typing right now is like trying to win the vim/emacs (or is that now just Sublime Text/Atom) editor wars. It's mo
by falcolas 9y ago
Attempting to argue about the value of dynamic typing right now is like trying to win the vim/emacs (or is that now just Sublime Text/Atom) editor wars. It's more a recitation of dogma than useful conversations; you can't discuss any type system's pitfalls without "oh, that's just algebraic typing, not static typing".
Fear not, my fellow Ruby/Python/Lisp/Perlers - the pendulum will swing back, and all that will be discussed is how much of a pain the current static typing systems are and how type hinting is the real future.
- abetusk 9y agoI get the feeling that you didn't watch the talk. He specifically talks about the field making large decisions based mostly on dogma and that evidence should be used to make those decisions instead. He's trying to advocate the use of the scientific method as applied to language design choices. He admits that the papers he cites are too few to make large decisions and that the analysis he does by looking at how many issues on GitHub are actually caused by type system errors (1-5%) but he's trying to steer away from dogmatism in favor of empirical evidence.