2 ms·
Calling it "contempt" is unsupported. Patronizing, condescending, sermonizing - sure. If we weren't told by first principles in 2000 that all Internet traffic
by mindslight 9y ago
Calling it "contempt" is unsupported. Patronizing, condescending, sermonizing - sure.
If we weren't told by first principles in 2000 that all Internet traffic was being surveilled, then Mark Klein certainly did in 2006. And yet the masses continued blissfully adopting webcrapps and other negligently-designed communications systems... until 2013 when Snowden came along with banal "revelations", that were doled out slowly enough to survive the media's short attention span.
I'd love it if there were enough whistleblowers that we did get a new leak from the surveillance-industrial complex every week. And this news item, in the technical context, is utterly boring. But it's a bit disingenuous to condemn a news organization for behavior that every other news org does, likely because you disagree with their politics.
- tptacek 9y agoWe've shared enough threads that I think you can predict my response to this. I find it aggravating when people suggest that our understanding of dragnet Internet surveillance is new, and that it came from leaks. The NSA's access to online communication was understood as a ground truth in the 1990s. You can read the first edition of Applied Cryptography to see it. If anything, the last 10 years have diminished my respect for SIGINT capabilities. A thing I think people lose sight of when trying to put this stuff in historical perspective is that in the 1990s it was not only possible but actually sort of routine for entire ISPs to be owned up. There were instances of solsniff.c getting access to backbone traffic. None of it was encrypted. Internet surveillance in the 1990s wasn't hypothetical. Clueful people's homedirs would get traded in the "underground" and they'd be tarballs full of .pgp files, because everyone knew they were going to get owned up somehow.
- mindslight 9y agoIt depends what you mean by "our" understanding. If the "our" refers to us paranoid computer professionals, then I completely agree with your characterization. If the "our" refers to society at large, then I do think there was a sea change with Snowden. Furthermore, there is a distinction between understanding how vulnerable everything is, and believing that the modus operandi of government institutions is actually that of an attacker (and furthermore, the societal effects when that belief becomes widespread. But I digress). The only point I was picking on is your characterization of Wikileaks's approach to audience-impedance-mismatch as "contempt". Contempt of the lagging-understanders isn't outright wrong - I can try it on myself, but dwelling on having contempt for say everyone using gmail wouldn't be healthy or productive. But it's certainly not charitable to ascribe to others, which is why I said it comes down to pure political disagreement.