2 ms·
Meh. He missed the point. It's not that you can't know anything, and so you can put anything you want in there. It's that 1) some things are beyond knowing, an
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
Meh. He missed the point.
It's not that you can't know anything, and so you can put anything you want in there. It's that 1) some things are beyond knowing, and 2) all science is provisional. These two things mean that creatively explaining the unknown has a rich and critical part in our existence.
He's presenting a false dichotomy. Yes, some folks will use religion to tell you why the sun comes up, but that doesn't mean all religious belief systems are invalid.
Religious beliefs are simply shared creative responses to the unknown. In this sense, they are about as close to the theory-formation part of science as anything can be. The difference is that theory-formation in science occurs inside a highly structured system of other theories and rules and observations, while religious explanations can just be made up by anybody.
I get tired of this "post-modernists think there is nothing solid" nonsense. Yes, some of them got the title but missed the subtext. But the point of understanding the provisional nature of science isn't to somehow discredit it, it's to keep in mind how much more there is to discover. You can be highly-critical of the political nature of how science is conducted, as I am, and still be a huge supporter of the practice and continuation of theory and research. Knowing the difference between the philosophy of science, the politics of the practice of science, the epistemological nature of science, and the pattern of scientific revolution? In my opinion, this is when you first start having a clue about what all these debates about science mean.
We've come a long way since Descartes and his brain in a jar. The conversation isn't at that point any more.