3 ms·
Politics does not work that way. People all across the political spectrum demand to be bailed out when their risks go bad, and it is pointless to adopt an ideol
by mannykannot 9y ago
Politics does not work that way. People all across the political spectrum demand to be bailed out when their risks go bad, and it is pointless to adopt an ideology that ignores this reality. Then there is the issue of people whose prudent choices were nullified by rampant development upstream.
> But then the solution is to force people to buy 'crisis cover' from private insurance companies.
I see you are not opposed to government intervention, you just want it in a different form.
- MarkMc 9y ago> I see you are not opposed to government intervention, you just want it in a different form. That's right - I want it in a reduced, more efficient form. Personally I don't think the government should bail out property damage of people whose risks go bad and who don't have insurance. But I can accept that maybe this is the minority opinion - but even in this case it's still more efficient for people to be forced to buy private insurance rather than have the government say 'you must pay us $X flood risk premium' or 'you cannot build here'. Private insurance companies (with money on the line) will more accurately assess flood risks than a government official (who has no financial interest in the accuracy of his assessment).
- mannykannot 9y agoWe have been down this route with flood insurance, so we know what happens - the electorate pressures the legislature to make insurance available at below-market rates, which it does by interfering in the market. As the notably conservative states along the Gulf coast have not done anything to make the situation truly market-driven, it is unrealistic to think of this as a solution. Maybe if the legislature did not have to respond to the populace... is that the more efficient form of government you prefer?
- MarkMc 9y agoThere are plenty of examples in history where the majority opinion changes, even with regard to deep, long-held ideas. In any case it's reasonable to support a policy on principle, even if it's unlikely to be implemented.