6 ms·
This isn't really the whole story. They are assuming that their member companies will make more money as a result of less piracy. And that additional money shou
by ars 16y ago
This isn't really the whole story. They are assuming that their member companies will make more money as a result of less piracy. And that additional money should/would be added to the total.
(Note: I did not say if it will actually reduce piracy, just that that is their assumption, and is why they are willing to pay this.)
- baddox 16y agoThree things: This will not result in less piracy, pirates spend more money on music than non-pirates, and frequently-pirated music makes more money than less-pirated music. Since January, there has already been one album that I have literally only bought because of piracy (I never would have heard of the band were it not for piracy). Last year I bought 2 or 3 albums which I never would have bought were it not for piracy. How many albums do "normal" non-pirating consumer buy a year?
- michaelfairley 16y ago> This will not result in less piracy, pirates spend more money on music than non-pirates, and frequently-pirated music makes more money than less-pirated music. B and C do not follow from A. Even though pirates spend more money than non-pirates, who's to say they wouldn't spend even more if they couldn't pirate. And, frequently pirated music makes money than less-pirated music because music that is popular is more likely to be pirated.
- baddox 16y agoFirstly, I didn't mean that A logically implies B and C. I meant them as three separate statements. How is it possible that they couldn't pirate? Unless the world governments plan on actually filtering the entire internet clean of piracy, then all they'll be doing is criminalizing piracy, which is already the case most places.
- TomOfTTB 16y ago"Pirates spend more money on music than non-pirates" Without taking a position on the accuracy of the claim I will say the study that determined that was deeply flawed. Let me quote the first article that comes up on Google... The Norwegian study looked at almost 2,000 online music users, all over the age of 15. Researchers found that those who downloaded "free" music – whether from lawful or seedy sources – were also 10 times more likely to pay for music. This would make music pirates the industry's largest audience for digital sales. This is flawed because people who are actively seeking music can reasonably be called "music enthusiasts" who would normally buy more music than their counterparts who don't actively seek out new music. Note the study says the ones who were categorized as "not pirates" didn't even use free sources to listen to new music. So in order to get an accurate answer as to how piracy impacts sales you'd have to compare enthusiasts who pirate to those who don't.
- barrkel 16y agoEven that wouldn't be fully free of confounding variables, because you don't know if enthusiasts who pirate vs those who don't have the same quality of enthusiasm.
- chopsueyar 16y agoMy personal enthusiasm suffers from a lack of quality.
- amalcon 16y agoThis would still support the specific claim that "Pirates spend more money on music than non-pirates." It would not, however, support the claim that pirates spend more money on music than they would if piracy were not available as an option. As they say, correlation does not equal causation.
- baddox 16y agoGranted, there's no scientific evidence that they wouldn't spend more if piracy weren't an option, but from personal (anecdotal) evidence as well as common sense, I think it's likely the case. Being exposed to more music seems like it would lead to more music sales.
- jsz0 16y agopirates spend more money on music than non-pirates Without going into too much incriminating detail I just find that really hard to accept.
- krig 16y agoThere seems to be some studies that indicate that this is the case, even though it is a counter-intuitive finding: 1. http://arstechnica.com/web/news/2009/01/dutch-government-study-net-effect-of-p2p-use-is-positive.ars http://arstechnica.com/web/news/2009/01/dutch-government-stu... 2. http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2009/apr/21/study-finds-pirates-buy-more-music http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2009/apr/21/study-finds-pira...
- shasta 16y agoIt's only counterintuitive until you think about it. Like "people who receive chemotherapy are more likely to die of cancer than people who don't."
- philwelch 16y ago"frequently-pirated music makes more money than less-pirated music" Which can be rephrased far less interestingly as "popular music is frequently purchased as well as frequently pirated".
- baddox 16y agoAnd yet, the way RIAA portrays it is as if every album has a set number of potential sales, and each instance of piracy takes away from those potential sales. The truth is, the piracy rate will usually be pretty constant across all albums, e.g. one album sale for every 20 free downloads.
- philwelch 16y agoThere's no contradiction there--it's entirely possible there will be one album sale for every 20 pirate downloads, but that doesn't rule out the possibility that each album is capable of selling 20 times more than it does. It's implausible, but not logically ruled out. More to the point, maybe for those 20 free downloads, 5-6 would have actually bought the album but didn't, and 5-6 (possibly overlapping set) will be convinced to see a show or buy a t-shirt, so the actual financial situation for the band isn't so much different as they think it is.
- blueben 16y agoThis isn't just about demand for an album; demand is tempered by the price attached to the product. This is about demand for an album at $15/copy. There is demand for the album; the downloads demonstrate that. There is almost no demand for that same album at $15/copy. That is the limit of what you can assume about this scenario.
- ErrantX 16y agoHow many albums do "normal" non-pirating consumer buy a year? Myself; about 30-40. This is probably a high number; most of my friends will buy anything from 3-5 (in a quick straw poll of about 30 of them).
- rsheridan6 16y agoAnd it's totally a coincidence that the bottom has fallen out of the record industry since Napster.
- rgoddard 16y agoThis is more due to the shift from buying albums to buying singles. This shift is made possible by digital distributions. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/05/the-death-of-the-album-in-handy-graph-form.ars http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/05/the-death-of...
- mmorris 16y agoWhile I don't doubt that the increased ease and frequency of piracy has had an impact on the bottom line of the recording industry, I believe the decline of the industry as a whole has much more to do with the increased capabilities of home computers and the spread of broadband Internet access. The big recording companies provide a few main services to artists: production, distribution, and promotion. For years they kept CD prices artificially high because there weren't alternatives for most people (for artists to create albums or for consumers to obtain music). Once everyone could record and burn CDs expensive production studios became much less valuable, and broadband Internet makes distribution nearly free (relatively, at least). Simultaneously, radio has become a much less important means of promotion, so the connections that the recording companies had in that arena become much less valuable. In other words, the big record companies just don't offer the value they used to - either to artists or to consumers. And once the value your company offers disappears, so should your company (unfortunately this usually happens very slowly, with the company(/ies) trying everything to avoid extinction). So was it a coincidence that this all happened at around the time that Napster took off? I don't think so, I think there were just common causes that led to both results.
- philwelch 16y agoRight, because since the internet took off, huge, mass-media publicized "artists" have fallen to the wayside and been replaced with a wider variety of niche acts, many of whom weren't signed to labels at all? No. The labels aren't suffering because they have to compete with independent artists, they're suffering because they have to compete with the Pirate Bay and friends.
- hugh3 16y agoThis will not result in less piracy How so? Data point: I don't pirate music, partly because I'm paranoid about getting sued by the RIAA. I'm sure I'm not the only one. frequently-pirated music makes more money than less-pirated music. Yes, popular music makes more money than unpopular music. Duh. pirates spend more money on music than non-pirates Which, even if true, is not a demonstration of "pirates spend more money on music than they would if they weren't pirates". I am extremely skeptical of the idea that piracy helps the music industry. It smells strongly of the kind of thing that people believe in order to justify their own actions, rather than the kind of thing that people believe because it's likely to be true. If you're still pirating music in 2010, and the track you're pirating is available on the Apple Store for 99 cents, then you're just being a cheap bastard.
- pyre 16y ago> If you're still pirating music in 2010, and the track you're pirating is available on the Apple Store for 99 cents, then you're just being a cheap bastard. Where can I get my iTunes for Linux?
- psadauskas 16y agoAmazon's digital music is pretty awesome. The only annoying limitation is that you're only allowed to download the file once, but I just immediately upload it to S3.
- CountHackulus 16y agoAnother annoying limitation is that Amazon MP3 is limited to US customers only. This greatly annoys me as there's an album I want that's not on iTunes, but is on Amazon MP3. None of the local music stores stock it. My only choices are to either pirate the album or pay exorbitant fees and wait several weeks to import the disc. Guess which one's easier.
- GrandMasterBirt 16y agoOn the dual-boot to your hackintosh. Ah crap that does not seem to resolve the pirating problem. :) The response to the itunes lover.... Seriously when we mention pirated music sells more, its because studies show that while pirating is up so are sales. In fact sales are higher now than when pirating was non-existent. There is very little corelation shown that pirating hurts music sales, and vice versa, so both arguments are kind-of equally valid. The music industry just wants every damn penny. See the post about the Humble Bundle's pirating issue. The entire bundle of games could be purchased at 1 penny, yet people pirated, and often there are good reasons why someone will pirate vs buy.
- jeza 16y agoOne of the biggest mistakes that music/film/software industries make is assuming that each pirated copy is a direct revenue loss. I don't know if that's what they actually believe, though it's often reported this way in the media and I'm pretty sure organisations like RIAA support that style of reporting. Though the problem is, not everyone who pirates something would pay for it if that were the only way of obtaining it. Certainly the higher the price, the less likely that is to occur.
- roc 16y agoHere's the funny thing about "piracy=lost sales": there's no good reason to believe that anyone believes it. The RIAA is a group of lawyers whose best interest is directly behind saying it, particularly if they don't believe it. If you can sell an eternal war, you can guarantee a whole lot of budget for an awful long time. The studios themselves are largely obsolete. The top 10% are on borrowed time; their job won't exist after the transition to digital is complete. The analysts will remain, the accountants will remain, the producers will remain. But there'll be no advantage to having Sony records in its entirety, let alone the overpaid execs. All you need is some good producers/engineers, a marketing agency and an accountant. So, if suing delays the transition, it enriches the decision makers by extending the time over which they draw a check. If it doesn't, oh well, it's only shareholder money being burned. Either way, the lawsuits give them a perpetual excuse for missed revenue targets. And the longer the shareholders are unable to muster any defense, the further "lawsuits as business model" gets pushed. Sue digital radio. Sue terrestrial radio. Sue incidental recordings in online videos. Sue everyone, because the heads are out of ideas.
- vermontdevil 16y agoI think it's more of squelching distribution channels that are outside of their control. So they can build an illusion that they are the ONLY ones distributing music and continue to control the creation of content.
- GrandMasterBirt 16y agoAnd people wonder why the settlements/lawsuits demand so much money. Its not to recover costs but to deter. HOWEVER just like the death penalty, a deterrent that is not immediate, seen as unfair, and is extremely unlikely to happen to you, is not a deterrent at all.
- eli 16y agoNot to mention the deterrent effect. You can debate about what effect piracy actually has on their bottom line, but I'd wager that if there were never any prosecutions even more people would pirate music than do currently.
- bediger 16y agoArrrr, I'd have to say I doubt it. Plenty of methods of (partially) counter-acting "piracy" exist, mate. Shiver me sides! The "Madonna" wench put sound files full of swearing that would embarassa deckhand on file sharrrring networks. These files probably only appealed to perrrverrts, but piracy is filled with such perrrverrrts. And what about bands/label pre-emptively releasing sub-optimal (mono, low sample rate) singles to the file sharing networks, but sellling pristine, high-fidelity versions? This whole mass-lawsuit thing smacks of incredible dumbness, or of a general tendency towards larceny rather than honest labor. Which a pirate, can respect, mind you!