7 ms·
The Accidental Elitist: Academia is too important to be left to academics
- nafey 9y agoA part of me believes that academics fulfill the role of priests in ancient cultures. They have highly developed sophisticated incantations which are not intended to be meaningful but to build a facade of control and portray an illusion of almost prophetic insight to the general public.
- keithwhor 9y agoSounds like you went to grad school. :) Edit: This is not facetious. YMMV, but many share this sentiment.
- xapata 9y agoNearly every elitist subculture does this. Executives and management consultants have their own esoteric jargon. To amuse myself during conference calls, I used to invent silly dance moves to correspond to their various phrases as if the boss was at a square dance calling out the next step. "Circle back," "Align," "Come to Jesus," and of course, "Synergize!"
- vecter 9y agoWhat are academics controlling?
- blusterXY 9y agotenure
- fennecfoxen 9y agoIndoctrination of the people who use the education system, of course. (Specifics and the ultimate impact are left as an exercise to the reader.)
- collyw 9y agoActually listening to Jordan Peterson talking about some humanities subjects (gender studies for example), there may be some truth in this.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- osullivj 9y agoThere are shared cultural roots in monasticism in medieval Europe. The monasteries were keepers of books, learning and scholarship in the long interregnum after the fall of Rome and up to the Renaissance. Oxford, Cambridge, Bologna and the other ancient universities of Europe were founded early in the second millenium, and it was natural for them to take the monasteries as a template.
- afpx 9y agoIn Human culture, accepted ideas are tightly associated with social status. Unfortunately, in my experience, social status isn't highly correlated with awesome ideas. That's why low-status people (like myself) who thrive on seeing novel ideas be realized must quickly learn the art of 'managing upwards' (i.e. Making one's boss think it was their idea).
- dredmorbius 9y agoA pretty well-recognised truth. J.S. Mill on 19th century Britain, via Hans E. Jensen: First, the universities were given the task of providing an unceasing supply of ideologically correct candidates for vital positions in government, church and business. The state was able to make the faculties of the "'venerable institutions'" of higher education, or rather indoctrination, assume this duty because it controlled appointments and held the purse from which "emoluments" flowed into the coffers of academics. Hence the members of the university "hierarchy" made it their "business, the business for which they . .. [were] paid," to "uphold certain political as well as religious opinions," namely those of the "ruling powers of the state" (Mill 1981: 429: and 1988b: 350). Thus the universities pursued with vigor their assignment to inculcate in their students those political and ideological views that were cherished by the power elite. The graduates of the ancient universities were, therefore, well prepared for employment in, and by, those institutions that were instrumental in perpetuating the existing maldistribution of income. All of this might come to naught, however, if the masses of the underclass should achieve anything approaching success in potential attempts at throwing off their fetters. The state devised a second educational strategy in order to prevent such a calamity from occurring. According to Mill, the "elementary schools for children of the working classes" were given the task of ensuring that the poor would continue to accept docilely their dismal station in life. It was very easy for the state to force the public schools to assume this role. It did so simply by failing malignantly to allocate sufficient funds for the operations of what Mill identified contemptuously as "places called schools" (Mill 1982: 200; emphasis in original). These places were therefore understaffed. Moreover, the few teachers who were actually employed were completely "unfit for their work." Hans E. Jensen, "John Stuart Mill's Theories of Wealth and Income Distribution". Review of Social Economy. Pages 491-507. Published online: 05 Nov 2010. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00346760110081599 http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00346760110081599
- rini17 9y agoThe elephant in the room is that humanities have zero predictive power. And reaction to unexpected results is markedly different, too. If the eclipse did not happen exactly as predicted, hard sciences would (mostly) excitedly scramble to understand how and why. If Trump gets elected...you get stuff like this article "oh my what kind of person we are in this Trump era".
- matttproud 9y agoI suspect you strongly misunderstand what humanities provide: a rounding out of one's expertise and an appreciation of the qualitative world. You seem to presume predictive power is the preeminent criterion — the only thing worth optimizing for.
- rini17 9y agoAuthor seems to disagree with you - he basically says humanities should provide better input to political discourse. Also, it's the author that started using comparisons with hard sciences. In this context I have used the "elephant in the room", something to be aware of, not necessarily to optimize for.
- dredmorbius 9y agoAuthor may also be wrong.
- xapata 9y agoDescriptive science is equally important as predictive science, but either way, science is not our only tool for knowledge. Statistical predictive models do happen to be in vogue, though.
- demonshalo 9y ago> Descriptive science The whole point of science is for it to be predictive though. Calling "descriptive science" (whatever that is) a science is sort of... wrong!
- Ultimatt 9y agoI'm going to be snobby. There is a vast VAST difference between the humanities and social sciences and natural sciences with jargon use. There are a shitload of things no one ever talks about that need a name. Jargon in natural science is used to speak precisely, but in social science it's invariably used to speak in general terms. In human geography the words "place" and "space" for example are quite maddening to a scientist. In natural science words aren't made up to replace simpler common words about phenomena most people are aware of. Instead the names for the most part are very specifically systematic and precise especially in Chemistry. So from a composite name like "hydrogen dioxide" and "carbon dioxide" you get an idea of similarity. If everyone spoke about "water" and other dioxides, it's actually less obvious you're only talking about dioxides. The worst offenders in natural science are for sure people who work in taxonomy and phylogenetics. They still demand that everyone understand Latin and use really ridiculous names for most species. It took me two years to realise all the things with "carteri" in the name wasn't something meaningful. It just meant "Carter's", who was the victorian mutton-chop-rocking guy who discovered them. But the naming of species isn't very systematic in general, and is frequently whimsical. A fun example is "Selenochlamys ysbryd" one of the only species to be designated with a Welsh-Latin fusion name https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_slug#Etymology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_slug#Etymology I like that they got away with it, but I doubt anyone got from "ysbryda" the slug would look "ghostly". I can't even argue with the use of latin, there is too much stuff to name in just english without it becoming incredibly confusing. There's only so many ways you can say "brown beetle".
- mdpopescu 9y ago> So from a composite name like "hydrogen dioxide" and "carbon dioxide" you get an idea of similarity. If everyone spoke about "water" and other dioxides... Er... I generally agree with what you're saying, but water is not hydrogen dioxide, it's dihydrogen monoxide. It's most definitely not similar to carbon dioxide :)
- Ultimatt 9y agoHah! See this is why it should be just "water" OMG. Ok so dinitrogen monoxide :P which also has a common name related to how I feel right now. I just woke up gimme a break :'( It's almost certainly not obvious using "water" and "laughing gas" the two have something in common.
- Glyptodon 9y agoNothing like seeing college classmates get PHDs and then apparently spend substantial amounts of time telling "conservatives" and Trump supporters to STFU and f-off on Facebook comment threads.
- scythe 9y ago>There’s a huge difference, for instance, between defending academic jargon as such and defending academic jargon as the typical academic so often uses it. There’s likewise a huge difference between justifying jargon when it is absolutely necessary (when all other available terms simply do not account for the depth or specificity of the thing you’re addressing) and pretending that jargon is always justified when academics use it. And there’s a huge difference between jargon as a necessarily difficult tool required for the academic work of tackling difficult concepts, and jargon as something used by tools simply to prove they’re academics. What I find so amusing about this paragraph is that the word "jargon" is, in this context, jargon. It is not explained when jargon is necessary, or when it isn't, or what kinds of discussions would make it necessary. In fact, it is probably ideal to be familiar with the use of some sort of jargon, and with contexts in which it is necessary and unnecessary, in order to really make sense of what the author means here. And something important got left out, which is: jargon is often easy. Easy like reaching into the bag of chocolate-peanut clusters rather than making some actual food. Jargon has two primary functions: it increases the number of things you can talk about specifically and it removes the emotional impact of talking about those things. The cognitive-somatic empathy impact of "blunt trauma to the genital region" is less wince-inducing than "kick in the nuts". Using jargon puts a Latinate wall between you and any difficult emotions that you might have about the subject that you're discussing. But there is another purpose of jargon, too, in which it comes closer to that other famous tool of the academic, the formalism. Language is fluid and the meaning of words changes, but in order for the academic canon to remain useful for centuries, it has to stay somewhat the same. Jargon is supposed to fulfill the need for language that doesn't change. That's why, when academic jargon like "microaggression" -- a term which has appeared in papers since 1989 ( https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/3424662/Microaggression.pdf?AWSAccessKeyId=AKIAIWOWYYGZ2Y53UL3A&Expires=1504168265&Signature=cCqcSv%2BM9KHuuTxw274CCUdMMYQ%3D&response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%3DLaw_as_microaggression.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/3424662/Micr... ) -- becomes common in social parlance, it also stops being jargon, because it is no longer tied to its original meaning. To be brief (and somewhat wrong) jargon tries to be prescriptive, whereas real language is descriptive. And because language which is no longer jargon cannot be correctly used as though it were, having fluency in an academic field does not imply being able to communicate with ordinary people about it. In order to have conversations in colloquial language you have to learn to use colloquial language, which is a separate skill-set from what the academic is expected by their job title to accomplish. So if you try to fix this communication problem by turning the jargon switch on and off: >It goes without saying we are implicitly celebrating a kind of technocratic anti-politics, though, when we contribute to making the discussion of politics intelligible only to a select few. If Trump’s election didn’t teach us that this kind of thing is a death wish, nothing will. well, maybe you should be beaten over the head with a copy of On Certainty. Is the discussion intelligible only to a select few? No, if it were, it would be physics, and there are very few popular conspiracy theories about physics. Except for that one funded by billionaires, but that's a different problem. There are lots of popular conspiracy theories about sociology, and that's because it isn't that they hear you talking and don't get any ideas out of it, it's that they hear you talking and they think you're some kind of monster because of it. That doesn't happen when we're discussing wavefunctions. And that's because this: >The perpetual conceit of academics in the humanities is that translating their work into a more accessible vernacular will “dumb down” what are necessarily complex subjects. Important stuff will be lost. Behind this conceit, though, is an implicit presumption from just about every academic that they could perform this kind of translation if pressed to. It has been one of the great sources of my disillusionment with academia to realize that a staggering majority of jargonauts, when pressed, actually can’t. doesn't happen because academics don't really understand the subject they're talking about, it happens because they don't understand the language they're trying to translate it into. So I would certainly agree that >It requires that one goes and does the painstaking work of learning languages that express and condition the worldviews of their speakers, that are encoded with specific logical systems and empowered by cultural conventions, which must also be learned and practiced. It requires daily efforts to understand how this cultural material works for smaller and larger publics as well as repeated attempts to construct workable critical stances out of that very material. but ordinary language is not by its naturally fluid nature an appropriate foundation for critical theory. Rather the task of communicating in ordinary language must be approached in and of itself. I think there's another question of whether the researchers themselves should be tasked with this, or a separate group of people, who may not exist. Yet it is probably not at all comforting to academics, a generally self-assured culture, to suggest that they can't fix politics alone. In a more harmonious culture, perhaps journalists would bridge this chasm, but today, they seem more interested in dredging it. PS: >[the right was] shifting people’s sentiments in such a way that they’ll even support things that are fundamentally bad for them. The words "fundamentally bad" link to a book about tax cuts in Kansas. Problem: while the whole rest of the essay focused on sociology, this book is about economics. Problem 2: Kansas's tax-reform experiment did not actually pass because of wide popular support. In fact, libertarian economics doesn't actually poll very well on its own (look at all the love for free trade agreements in 2016), it just happens to be attached to the banner of the Republican Party. If you want to be convincing, it helps not to be wrong in the ways that even laypeople can recognize. Does my postscripted objection make sense? The context is a sentence about the right convincing people to vote for things that are bad for them in an essay about sociology; the example is something people didn't vote for which was implemented by the right and which was bad economics. I don't think that's a big deal in isolation, but consider the choice the author made, by using this example over any other example, in the context of my first paragraph. There are many things the right really convinced people to vote for that could be bad for them, such as building a goddamn wall on the Mexican border or repealing a law that everyone was suddenly in favor of when you call it by its original name, and yet the author -- while decrying jargon -- chose an example which is unfamiliar and uncontroversial. Easy. Chocolate-peanut clusters. >What makes a subject difficult to understand — if it is significant, important — is not that some special instruction about abstruse things is necessary to understand it. Rather it is the contrast between the understanding of the subject and what most people want to see. Because of this the very things that are most obvious can become the most difficult to understand. What has to be overcome is not difficulty of the intellect but of the will.
- roceasta 9y agoI find it almost incredible that while the motivated autodidact can learn almost any theoretical topic for almost no money via the internet we simultaneously have millions of students getting into heavy debt at university. (Also into heavy drinking, exam pressure, mental illness, radical indoctrination, etc.)
- rleigh 9y agoThere's a difference between learning a topic yourself and learning it at a university: the university gives you a certificate at the end to say you did it, which other people recognise as having value. There are also things that you gain by studying and working with others: discussion, exposure to different perspectives and points of view. Inspiration by experts in the field. These all have value. Whether they are worth the cost is a separate question. Heavy drinking and radical indoctrination are optional; you can skip all that. Exam and other pressure from deadlines can be bad, but it can also be a powerful motivator to pull your finger out and get stuff done.
- roceasta 9y agoSure. But bear in mind that all these benefits existed in the 60s, 70s and 80s, before the higher education bubble. When there was no web and little or no student debt. Yet there are more people in higher education now. Heavy drinking and radical indoctrination are optional They're notionally optional but don't underestimate the effects of social pressure. In fact, conformity prevails strongly on the academic as well as the social side of university life. People talk about discussion and perspectives but in practice they want and expect accredited professionals to conform and to believe the same things. We don't generally want our doctors, for instance, to be original and creative. (Whereas, by contrast, we can have real discussion here.) Students want to know whether a given topic will be in the exam or not, and what the right answer is. In the arts/humanities, where fashions tend to prevail, they try hard to give approved answers in original or disguised form. I suppose this isn't surprising, historically speaking. The first universities were religious institutions founded to train priests, to inculcate doctrinal uniformity, stamp out heresies, and so on. If we judge the rationality of institutions by whether they meet the problems they purport to address then by that standard universities are pretty irrational. In fact I think one of the main functions they serve isn't mentioned very much: getting the kids to leave home.
- clarkevans 9y agoWhat do we expect of humanities academics? Keeping in mind that even if you make to tenure, you might have a $70-90K job in urban places where you cannot afford to own a house. Indeed, the failure rate of getting tenure or to full professor is very high: academia is much like a startup in this regard, you can work for a decade and if you don't get traction... you're no longer a market participant. ... This article reads like someone starting a career who is musing about the stereotypes and flaws he presumes exist in his chosen profession and how his career relates to the broader world. Is Maximillian asking that that academics, especially those in the humanities, participate more in the political world? Surely, this is a double-edged sword: as soon as they present their ideas and knowledge forcefully in a political setting based upon their study of history, they are labeled as political. Can you be an effective advocate for change if you are labeled political? So, what do we ask humanities professors do? Outreach. Acedemics give talks at museums or libraries; they and help curators with fixing incorrect labels. They do their very best to wrap their hard-won knowledge in accessible terms. They write beautiful, amazing books that inspire people and spread ideas. But frankly, not everyone has an idea or insight that's generally applicable and worthy enough to have general public visibility. Service. Acedemics often have part time jobs doing all sorts of service roles such as assisting undergraduates with their careers, participating in a broader administrative organization called a University, incrementally advancing their field, doing peer review, and the like. This takes time, because working with people and ideas takes time. Research. We ask academics to be fountains of knowledge in their tiny itty-bitty field, to know each other in their field, and to maintain and advance the state of understanding. This means constant reading of what almost everyone in their field writes. They might even coalesce thought in the field, condense knowledge, and express this clearly to specialists and non-specialists alike. Education. We expect academics to teach, and teach well. For the most part, in humanities, we expect them to use their field as an example play ground for students to learn to think deeply, reason about problems, express themselves logically and coherently, etc. This is challenging work, especially when so many students come to college ill-prepared with basic problems in thought formulation and expression. Yet, they do it. What warms an academics heart is when they get a letter, some 2-3 years or 10 years later where someone says: "you helped me learn to me think, and that has made all the difference in my life". Do all academics do all of these perfectly? Probably not. However, for a high (or even medium) double-digit salary for a life's dedication to a field and education, what do we expect them to be? superheros?
- wisty 9y agoI feel a lot of the purpose of jargon in academia is simply to avoid disagreements. It's easy to agree with a metaphor, because you can interpret it however you like.
- leflappyface 9y agoBehold the quintessential modern literary / humanities intellectual in all its glory. A pretentiously long and drawn out article about mistrust of academia. And at no point does he talk about the possibilities that some or all humanities academics' work could be based on false or unrealistic premises; or contain deductions based on faulty reasoning; or the work makes no unfalsifiable conjectures yet the academic still claims to have expertise. It seems the last thing this guy will ever attempt is making a falsifiable prediction by using his mountains and mountains of theory. Nope, just add more theory and hope you fool people with the BS!
- sctb 9y agoCould you please comment more substantively so that an informative discussion is likelier to follow? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- DataWorker 9y agoThe problem is an inability to synthesize knowledge from outside disciplines. The piece itself is proof. No consideration of the economic factors or sociological factors at play. Just inward focus and self examination unaided by the very applicable knowledge provided by other domains of study. I strongly suspect this will all prove to be a self correcting problem. The solution may be closer than many realize.
- stinkytaco 9y agoWhat do you mean by "self correcting"? What do you speculate the solution might be?
- mcguire 9y ago"Then, halfway through the panel, it hits me: this is awful. The redeeming insights are just so few and far between, stranded between deserts of lame, forced conference humor and straightforward, even banal points dressed up in comically unnecessary jargon." Welcome to the land of adulthood, where everything is like this. There's an old joke about the American hiker in Japan going to the inn in a small village in the evening and asking for a room. The innkeeper says in Japanese, "you wouldn't like it here, we have Japanese bathrooms." The hiker replies in Japanese that he has been in Japan for months and would be fine. They go back and forth a couple of times until the hiker in frustration says, in English, "Why can't I just get a place to sleep?" The innkeeper replies, "Because you don't speak Japanese," and slams the door. Anyway, this kind of behavior is everywhere, especially in any field that does not look difficult. Yes, I have a PhD in computer science. No, I don't fix PCs all day. The bottom line is that the author is part of the problem. The article is excessively erudite and verbose. He's clearly not talking to anyone outside of his field. He misrepresents the state of the "other side" to make points. (Quick, call up the ghost of William F. Buckley and ask him about the state of the American right.) And he is not saying anything new.
- cerealbad 9y agothe things i know are not as certain as i am. universities teach myth and research profit. "Here they lie."