5 ms·
Why would an alien civilization do this? And I don't just mean, come up with something that maybe some really powerful but really stupid alien civilization mig
by jerf 9y ago
Why would an alien civilization do this?
And I don't just mean, come up with something that maybe some really powerful but really stupid alien civilization might conceivably do in a silly science fiction book. Explain how this is the best use of their still-limited power.
Even the old standby "well maybe they're just incomprehensible and we can't understand them" doesn't really work here because when we're talking about "incomprehensible" aliens we don't usually mean that they're incomprehensible on account of being cosmically stupid and wasteful.
(I am speaking about what we actually have evidence for. If there's multiple exabytes of incredible data packed into this signal somehow we have no evidence for it. I like to distinguish very clearly between "things based on the evidence that we have" and "airy flights of fancy based on what might be hiding in the gaps", on the grounds that the latter is unbounded, so while they are fun in stories, in a way the very unlimited nature of the possible sets of speculations makes them uninteresting as an analysis of the real universe, all equally lost in the noise of all the other fantastic possibilities.)
- rhcom2 9y agoI just thought "ruled out" makes it sound like they have some criteria for a "alien" signal vs natural.
- coldtea 9y agoWell, randomness (entropy of the singal etc) is a good criterion which doesn't require deciphering.
- dmurray 9y agoThese "signals" have less entropy than normal, which is what is interesting about them, so we have to come up with additional criteria here.
- coldtea 9y agoWell, simple periodic/repeating signals occur all the time in nature -- so it has to be more advanced than that to consider it an actual message or "intelligence made". Even if it was the Macarena beat it would hardly qualify as such.
- PoachedSausage 9y agoA variation on Clarke's 3rd law is: Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from nature. So the origin could be such an advanced intelligence that it looks natural.
- sliken 9y agoMaybe because we already understand most of the physics required for space flight and the boring conclusion is that huge arrays of lasers are the most feasible way to accelerate an object to a fraction of light speed. Sure we can dream about FTL, but the physics support for that is minimal at best.
- adrianN 9y agoI'm reasonably sure that hydrogen bombs are the most feasible way to accelerate an object to ~0.03c. We know how to build bombs, and concepts for big-shock-absorber-with-bomb-shute spaceships looked feasible with the tech from 1960.
- sliken 9y agoSure, but how about 0.2c? Carrying your fuel with you has some pretty serious limitations for anything short of a fair chunk of your mass being anti-matter. However with the lasers you leave the fuel at home.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt appears to be few bytes. And probably not information. Still, I think being confident about what a civilization capable of sending an intergalactic signal is doing is a bit much. Maybe some kid was bored (and was throwing neutron stars into a black hole).
- kowdermeister 9y agoThere's also the possibility that FRB-s are artificial in its origin, but it's the byproduct of some technology we don't really grasp yet.
- magnat 9y ago> Explain how this is the best use of their still-limited power Weapon. I suppose you could ask the same question looking at our nuclear tests - why someone would waste so much energy in a single event? Maybe it's just remnants from their firing range?
- arethuza 9y agoOr an actual use of weapons.
- PoachedSausage 9y agoPerhaps they're celebrating the failed attempt by anarchist revolutionaries to cause the emperors home star to go nova.
- coldtea 9y ago>Explain how this is the best use of their still-limited power. Even the old standby "well maybe they're just incomprehensible and we can't understand them" doesn't really work here because when we're talking about "incomprehensible" aliens we don't usually mean that they're incomprehensible on account of being cosmically stupid and wasteful. Sorry, where did the idea of "still-limited power" came from? Or the idea that they're power constrained enough for this to be "wasteful"?
- jamesrcole 9y ago"Things we have evidence for" also includes our lack of a definitive understanding of physics and our lack of understanding of what life does or doesn't exist out there. That needs to be taken into account. You can't just assume the positive knowledge you currently have is representative of how things actually are.