3 ms·
Kaspersky Lab turns the tables, forces “patent troll” to pay cash to end case
- gameshot911 9y agoThey gave up too soon, let the troll get away to target others. Should have seen the fight through to the end and tried to invalidate the patent.
- codedokode 9y agoAs I understand invalidating a patent is not free so it makes no sense to spend money on that.
- nkurz 9y agoWhile this is a better outcome than quietly paying the troll like the previous victims, I can't really applaud Kaspersky for this. While it probably discourages future suits against Kaspersky, it does nothing to help the other businesses who will continue to fall victim. In contrast, Newegg is making the world better by helping to invalidate these nonsense patents: https://blog.newegg.com/newegg-helps-invalidate-phony-patent-assertion-claim-holds-perfect-nine-year-track-record-appeal-patent-troll-cases/ https://blog.newegg.com/newegg-helps-invalidate-phony-patent.... I think Kaspersky's approach here is "corporate stotting". "Stotting" is a fine word that describes the apparently maladaptive "show off" behavior of some animals, where they prance and dance around in front of predators: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stotting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stotting. In "signaling theory", this is presumed to be an "honest signal" that the stotting animal is so fast and fit that the predator should chase someone else instead. This is good for that particularly fit individual, but not so much for the others in the herd. As a not particularly fit or fast individual, I'm a bigger fan of Newegg's approach.
- codedokode 9y ago> it does nothing to help the other businesses who will continue to fall victim Why should Kaspersky pay for invalidating the patent and for helping other businesses? They didn't issue this patent and they didn't pass the law allowing to issue such nonsense patents.
- colanderman 9y agoThe same reason I report to the FCC scam callers, whom I am experienced enough to avoid, but whom others may not be. Because selfless philanthropic actions by those with the means to do so promote a healthy society.
- PhantomGremlin 9y agoSigh. Eugene Kaspersky is ex-KGB. If he really wanted to turn the tables on a patent troll, he'd get some help from his old comrades who have moved on to places such as the SVR and GRU. I can guarantee that a few short illnesses followed by mysterious deaths (Polonium has been proven effective in the past) within the ranks of patent trolls would have a much more salutary effect on that activity than the $5,000 that this troll eventually paid to Kaspersky Labs. I'm sure there would be downsides and repercussions and all sorts of political fallout. But we can dream, can't we? The preceding was sarcasm. But "the usual stuff isn't working". Perhaps the recent TC Heartland LLC v. Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC decision by the US Supreme Court will help. But that decision was about venue, not about garbage patents.