4 ms·
You wouldn't see a quadcopter on a human-scale craft. The efficiency is too low. The reason they are used in drones is that you can get 3 axis control with only
by TylerE 9y ago
You wouldn't see a quadcopter on a human-scale craft. The efficiency is too low. The reason they are used in drones is that you can get 3 axis control with only varying motor torque, instead of varying blade pitch/tilt.
Less efficient, but much simpler mechanically.
- tda 9y agoI beg to differ: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OazFiIhwAEs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OazFiIhwAEs
- TFortunato 9y agoWell played! (Though I would argue that the parent is still technically correct about multirotors / quadcopters being very inefficient compared to other flight methods) That said, I am really curious at actual lifetime costs of a system like this, and if it makes up for lack of efficiency by being simpler mechanically (leading to lighter weight, less maintenance costs, etc.) I think thats going to be the big thing that determines if this is a viable commuting option vs. rich person's toy.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoExcept that there are many examples now of human scale 4, 6, and 8 rotor craft. So perhaps the litmus test is 'efficient enough'. And the article did point out the need for improved batteries. As energy density in batteries gets closer to kerosene the 'mechanically simpler' aspect of these crafts flips the value equation in their favor.
- Alupis 9y agoRelevant: "Why haven't quadcopters been scaled up yet?"[1] The gist is, scaling up multi-rotor systems isn't as simple as making things bigger - the size adds many issues that the small models don't face (models having nearly impossible performance characteristics compared to full scale versions). Also, there's safety issues regarding controlling such as system when one or more rotors/motors fail. It's not to say it cannot be done, because obviously it can. It's a question of "why?", when there's clearly better, more simple and efficient ways to get around. Also, battery power density (and weight) has a long way to go before it will match Kerosene, or even regular AvGas - "Could an electric engine provide the same performance as jet engines on current aircraft?"[2]. [1] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/3300/why-havent-quadcopters-been-scaled-up-yet https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/3300/why-havent... [2] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/26910/could-an-electric-engine-provide-the-same-performance-as-jet-engines-on-current https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/26910/could-an-...
- ChuckMcM 9y ago> It's not to say it cannot be done, because obviously it can. It's a question of "why?", when there's clearly better, more simple and efficient ways to get around. I observe that in spite of the 'simple and efficent' ways to get around there is a tremendous amount of capital being invested to find new transportation modalities. Perhaps one or more of those investments will surprise you.
- Alupis 9y agoThere are two things that a full-sized electric multi-rotor vehicle must contend with to be practical: 1) Battery power density must have a tremendous breakthrough, in both terms of weight and stored capacity. 2) Electric motors capable of producing the energies required to produce the thrust necessary to propel a full-sized vehicle must also have a tremendous breakthrough in size, weight, and heat dissipation (especially if we're discussing vehicles capable of typical cruise altitudes over long distances). It would be far more simple and efficient to make a full-sized Kerosene, AvGas, or any other petroleum-based fuel multi-rotor vehicle... but then you must also overcome the unnecessary challenges multi-rotor systems introduce at this scale. Which... leads back to today's average helicopter and airplane designs. Like I said, it's not impossible... it's just not practical for these reasons. If someone wants to do it, they can... obviously... but it's not the most effective way. > Perhaps one or more of those investments will surprise you Indeed, people often invest in some very surprising ideas... sometimes even without really understanding what they are getting into...[1] [1] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/33541/are-fixed-wing-aircraft-with-gimbal-thrust-feasible/33542#33542 https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/33541/are-fixed...
- dreamcompiler 9y agoIt's hard to see how to overcome the rotor inertia issue in larger craft. So I'd expect human-sized quads would just use collective pitch control. Here's a hobby quad that has taken this approach: https://hobbyking.com/en_us/assault-reaper-500-collective-pitch-3d-quadcopter-mode-2-ready-to-fly-lite.html?___store=en_us https://hobbyking.com/en_us/assault-reaper-500-collective-pi...