5 ms·
Tl;Dr - helicopters are noisy and expensive to operate, but hopefully electric 'quad copter' like vehicles won't be. The caveats being that batteries, air traf
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Tl;Dr - helicopters are noisy and expensive to operate, but hopefully electric 'quad copter' like vehicles won't be.
The caveats being that batteries, air traffic control, and regulations have to change so in short, "I've your 25 today, perhaps your grand children will see a benefit here." :-(. Somehow I think even the hyperloop is nearer term than this technology, and its still out there.
- sp332 9y agoAn electric helicopter would be cool, but a single large rotor is more efficient and quieter than four small ones. You could make make a two-rotor VTOL craft like an Osprey. An electric version would be more reliable since you don't have to move fuel and oil around in various dimensions. That would let you get lift from wings during flight, which means longer range than a helicopter with the same battery capacity.
- bdamm 9y agoExactly right. Aviators know that a propeller blade provides thrust/lift but also induces drag. Given a certain power output, the more blades you have, the more drag you have, but you don't get any more lift/thrust. Therefore, if efficiency is what you want you really want as few blades as you can get away with. Normally more blades are a consequence of other design constraints, such as how wide you can realistically build a propeller blade before the stress causes it to disintegrate. Small multi-rotors have to spin faster to compensate for their reduced efficiency, leading to the characteristic drone sound. Computer cooling guys know this too... bigger slower fans move more air and do it with less noise.
- Gravityloss 9y agoWith electric motors it optimizes differently. Torque is expensive while individual motors are cheap. Distributed propulsion makes a lot more sense. Let's say you have one 2 MW rotor disk. Rotors are tip speed limited. Let's make it have an angular velocity a. Torque would need to be 2 MW / a. Having four 0.5 MW disks would have same tip speed but half the span so double the angular velocity and thus each would need torque of only 0.5 MW / (2 x a). Torque dropped to one eighth, and the motor became lighter! Now, at the one end you have a traditional helicopter with one to a few main rotors, high torque, cyclic and collective pitch in each (because torque is slow to change). At the other end you have a huge amount of small thrusters that are directly connected to their own motor and thrust is varied by electric means. In between you have things like intermediate number of thrusters / rotors having maybe a simple gear and/or collective pitch control.
- sp332 9y agoWhy is torque expensive in an electric motor? They tend to produce high amounts of torque at lower RPMs than ICEs. Even a Nissan Leaf gets 187 ft-lbs, and a Tesla motor has a flat torque curve to to 10,000 RPM.
- Gravityloss 9y agoI thought that was a generally known thing. A higher speed motor is smaller than a high torque motor for the same power. I don't think electric motors are almost ever connected to speed increase gear. It's almost always reduction or direct drive. You can check any hobby shop or Alibaba to verify the above. Probably related to some physics of magnetic field vs current. Would need to dig deeper into that dome day...
- sp332 9y agoWell I don't really know how much torque a helicopter would need. The only number I was able to find was that a 35-foot rotor could spin about 550 RPM. Even with a smaller rotor that would spin somewhat faster, I was guessing that a reasonable gear ratio would give an electric motor plenty of torque at those speeds.
- Gravityloss 9y agoAnd we are back at square one where the whole point was to go multirotor to avoid the gearbox and cyclic pitch complexity. In a car, it's a bit similar thing. With a combustion engine it optimizes to a single engine with fixed + variable ratio and shafts to the wheels and things like differentials. Lots of places to have oil, to maintain, to break, being heavy too. Tesla has 1-2 electric motors with a fixed gear ratio of about 10. Some concept vehicles have a direct drive motor near each wheel or even inside the wheel. The electric motor has different characteristics than a turbine or a piston engine. Hence it can affect the whole machine design.
- TylerE 9y agoYou wouldn't see a quadcopter on a human-scale craft. The efficiency is too low. The reason they are used in drones is that you can get 3 axis control with only varying motor torque, instead of varying blade pitch/tilt. Less efficient, but much simpler mechanically.
- tda 9y agoI beg to differ: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OazFiIhwAEs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OazFiIhwAEs
- TFortunato 9y agoWell played! (Though I would argue that the parent is still technically correct about multirotors / quadcopters being very inefficient compared to other flight methods) That said, I am really curious at actual lifetime costs of a system like this, and if it makes up for lack of efficiency by being simpler mechanically (leading to lighter weight, less maintenance costs, etc.) I think thats going to be the big thing that determines if this is a viable commuting option vs. rich person's toy.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoExcept that there are many examples now of human scale 4, 6, and 8 rotor craft. So perhaps the litmus test is 'efficient enough'. And the article did point out the need for improved batteries. As energy density in batteries gets closer to kerosene the 'mechanically simpler' aspect of these crafts flips the value equation in their favor.
- Alupis 9y agoRelevant: "Why haven't quadcopters been scaled up yet?"[1] The gist is, scaling up multi-rotor systems isn't as simple as making things bigger - the size adds many issues that the small models don't face (models having nearly impossible performance characteristics compared to full scale versions). Also, there's safety issues regarding controlling such as system when one or more rotors/motors fail. It's not to say it cannot be done, because obviously it can. It's a question of "why?", when there's clearly better, more simple and efficient ways to get around. Also, battery power density (and weight) has a long way to go before it will match Kerosene, or even regular AvGas - "Could an electric engine provide the same performance as jet engines on current aircraft?"[2]. [1] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/3300/why-havent-quadcopters-been-scaled-up-yet https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/3300/why-havent... [2] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/26910/could-an-electric-engine-provide-the-same-performance-as-jet-engines-on-current https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/26910/could-an-...
- mannykannot 9y agoA lot of the noise of helicopters comes from the rotor, and there is little more that can be done about it. Electric rotorcraft are not likely to be as quiet as their promoters like to suggest (e.g. through animations with unrealistic sound tracks), regardless of the number of rotors.
- ratsbane 9y agoA significant part of the noise comes from the antitorque (tail) rotor, which is much smaller and typically turning ~3x as fast as the main rotor. There are several solutions to minimizing this noise, including ducted tail rotors and NOTAR https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NOTAR https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NOTAR
- DenisM 9y agoCan we substitute batteries for fuel cells? They seem near-useless for cars, but very promising for aircraft.
- Pulcinella 9y agoThey are not "useless" for cars, just currently impractical. The problems are the catalyst requires rare, precious metals and, even using hydrogen, efficient fuel storage.
- tarikjn 9y agoCorrect me if I am wrong, but AFIAK the efficient fuel storage issue has been solved with using Methanol/Ethanol (liquid at room temperature) instead of Hydrogen as a fuel.