I believe the way you presented your two arguments shows them as non mutually exclusive. Couldn't healthcare or economic security be something that society is

I believe the way you presented your two arguments shows them as non mutually exclusive. Couldn't healthcare or economic security be something that society is obligated to not take _away_ from you, while also not being something that a society should provide? For the record, I'm not advocating for calling any of those things rights. Simply posing a question regarding the above statements.