3 ms·
Maybe nationalization is a bad way to go about it, but these companies are too large, they have too much power over society and society needs to exert power bac
by visarga 9y ago
Maybe nationalization is a bad way to go about it, but these companies are too large, they have too much power over society and society needs to exert power back onto them. So there should be some kind of external oversight when decisions that affect millions of people are being made.
I think governments are inefficient and corrupt, but companies are absolutely free to do as they please when deciding how to change products that affect society. Also, there is much more spying freedom in the private sector. This is why there should be a mechanism to oversee what happens with our data.
- simonh 9y agoYou mean like a set of regulations these companies had to comply with? Maybe with panels of ordinary citizens to adjudicate their application, overseen by a professional expert. Maybe we could call these regulations 'laws'.
- igravious 9y agoLargest companies by annual revenue[0]: WalMart Stores (US) - $485.8bn State Grid (China) - $315.1bn Sinopec (China) - $267.5bn China Natural Petroleum (China) - $262.6bn Toyota Motor (Japan) - $254.7bn Volkswagen (Germany) - $240.2bn Royal Dutch Shell (Netherlands) - $240bn Berkshire Hathaway (US) - $223.6bn Apple (US) - $215.6bn Exxon Mobil (US) - $205bn None are the big three. Should we nationalize Toyota and Volkswagen also? [0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2017/07/20/revealed-worlds-10-largest-companies-revenue/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2017/07/20/revealed-worl...
- TrickyRick 9y agoAre you more or less forced to buy a Toyota simply because all your friends drive a Toyota? Is the majority of roads exclusive to Toyotas? If you question a business decision of Toyota, or a design of their car, can you then sell said car and purchase one from another brand with minimal impact on your daily life (Other than the fact that you have to sell and buy a car)? Clearly it's not just about revenue numbers here.
- kiliantics 9y agoI think nationalising Walmart is a perfectly reasonable idea. Considering issues like the level of access to quality food in poor neighbourhoods in the US and the fact that US government subsidises much of Walmart's labour cost already, it would be a much better deal for the American people on average.
- zild3d 9y agoNot really relevant, it's not the revenue that is a problem. It's their massive network effects that are, as the author puts it, platform monopolies. Walmart, Toyota, Apple, do not have entrenching networks that lead to a monopoly. You can just as easily go to Target, buy a Honda, or get an Android phone