11 ms·
Terry Pratchett's unfinished novels destroyed by steamroller
- phreack 9y agoBefore anyone else gets enraged, this was Terry's will being honored. However, there's a debate to be had regarding whether it would have been worthy to release his final works even if incomplete and against his wishes.
- senectus1 9y agomeh, I dont care what "debate" there is about it. It was his dying wish. Not for filling that is disrespectful in the extreme. He wants his legacy to be as static as possible and not pimped out and whore'd to the highest bidder. Fair enough I say.
- adrianN 9y agoKafka also wanted everything burned. Imagine what a loss that would have been.
- concerto 9y agoTerry Pratchett had over 70 books published in his lifetime, and so his legacy is in his published works, while Kafka's masterpieces were largely unpublished at the time of his death and he was not widely known, so they are not really analogous situations.
- aaron695 9y agoRich powerful people have more rights? Or are you arguing these was more potential of some destruction of a legacy?
- Santosh83 9y agoInteresting that we consider products of billions of years of biological evolution in a cosmos that shows no evidence of life anywhere else in its vast coldness as perfectly alright to be destroyed willy-nilly in the pursuit of short-sighted expansion and greed, but we are nevertheless full of hubris that OUR OWN excretions of imagination and little buildings and artefacts of our infant civilisation, right down to every single bit, needs to be preserved at all costs!
- Houshalter 9y agoPlease, show me the person who wants the world to be destroyed but not these specific books.
- anvandare 9y agoThe world would have been fine. We've probably lost uncountable number of beautiful works to destruction and geniuses to crib death that would have otherwise completely changed the (cultural) state of the world, but we don't miss them because we never knew about them. The path history took is as valid as all other paths it could have taken.
- Houshalter 9y agoSure the world is fine. But that's a really low bar of argument. If someone was going to go back in time and destroy great works, would you not strongly prefer them be stopped? (All else equal and no secondary consequences from time travel or whatever.) Do they have literally no utility to the world in your mind?
- anvandare 9y agoNo, because that's a paradoxical requirement. I can't care for things which I never knew (could have) existed, and interfering with reality so that they would exist would require me to care enough for them to exist so as to interfere in the first place. Every action we make chooses one from (infinite) branches of reality. Favoring one over the other is meaningless. The result of things existing will always be other things not existing. The atoms that I'm using to exist could have been used to compose other entities instead. You're assuming a sort of situation where everything that could exist would exist. A Borgesian library where not only every possible work of Kafka is written, but in every possible variation. The act of writing by itself destroys every alternative work. Are we certain that the Kafka we have is the best Kafka we could have? One morning, when Gregor Samsa woke from troubled dreams, he found himself transformed in his bed into a horrible vermin. One morning, when Georg Samsa woke from troubled dreams, he found himself transformed in his bed into a disgusting bug. One day, when Georg Valta woke from troubled dreams, he found himself awake in his bed transformed into a horrible vermin. In the morning, when Georg Sanka woke from dreadful dreams, he found himself awake in bed in the body of a nightmarish vermin. ...
- Houshalter 9y ago
- pgeorgi 9y agoGiven Kafka's work (and the sadistic pleasure teachers have in tormenting high school students with it), I'm quite angry that it wasn't followed through.
- khazhoux 9y agoPutting aside his dying wishes, why would it matter if there's a "highest bidder" at play? All commercial literature involves highest bidders and people make money who've never read a word of it, and what do we readers care as long as we get to enjoy the work itself?
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoDisrespectful to who or what? I'm sorry, but Terry's gone. There's no entity left to suffer if his legacy does not match what his desires were while he was alive - nor even to be the subject of the possessive "his". In my opinion, the only valid positive outcome of respect for the dead can be in benefits to the living - who may benefit from either disrespecting the dying wish, or alternatively from the expectation that their own dying wishes may some day be fulfilled. That's definitely a debate. I do think they made the right call here, though.
- philh 9y agoIf Terry had expected us to ignore his wishes, how would we have acted differently in life? Would he have destroyed them himself just in case? Would he have done that before completing The Shepherd's Crown, or even an earlier book? I honestly don't know, but it's worth asking the question. That's how we can expect the next Terry Pratchett to act, if we ignore this Terry Pratchett's wishes. (I should note that even if the answer is that he would have shrugged and let us release his unfinished works, I still think we should obey his wishes. Terry belongs to Terry, no one else has a right to him.)
- lwhalen 9y agopRest pIn Peace, pTerry.
- ferd_erik 9y agoGNU Terry Pratchett
- steanne 9y ago!!!!!
- steanne 9y agosigh... http://wiki.lspace.org/mediawiki/index.php/Multiple_exclamation_marks http://wiki.lspace.org/mediawiki/index.php/Multiple_exclamat...
- jmcgough 9y agoI respect this a lot - if he hadn't, relatives or others would eventually publish his unfinished works (either in an unfinished state or completed by another author). The money is too alluring.
- Apocryphon 9y agoWould this qualify as an addition to this list? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_work
- jrimbault 9y agoI was amazed to not see the handle my scrollbar reduced to a tiny pixel. This list could be orders of magnitude larger.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoIt's on Wikipedia, so get editing! :)
- WalterBright 9y agoMy Will specifies that my warp drive design be destroyed. Earthlings are not ready for it yet.
- khazhoux 9y agoLest you suffer the posthumous indignity of the world discovering the designs are coded in C# ;-)
- WalterBright 9y agoThat does it. I'm not sharing my Hodge Conjecture solution, either!
- jamiethompson 9y agoThat's a very old looking HDD. It seems odd that his most recent work would be on that.
- rullelito 9y agoYes, strange indeed, I expected Terry to only roll with the latest in tech.
- laumars 9y agoSarcasm? There has been interviews with him where he discusses his "writing equipment" and like many authors he preferred a basic system that kept mostly out of his way. I mean it's just as easy to write a novel in Word for DOS* as it is in the latest software and hardware tech, so why would authors want to waste their time always running the latest tech when it's a distraction from their day job? * I'm not advocating people write novels in DOS. Just making an exaggerated point that since the medium is text only you don't need to be upgrading frequently.
- jrimbault 9y agoIsn't GRR Martin famously writing on a DOS computer ?
- laumars 9y agoIndeed: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-27407502 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-27407502
- digi_owl 9y agoUsing Wordstar no less, must drive his editor and publisher bonkers. Not that i can't relate. If i could find a CLI browser that kept up with latest CSS and JS stuff, i would be doing everything in a framebuffer CLI.
- dspillett 9y agoCould easily have been a drive that had been in his main work machine for quite some time. He no doubt had the good sense to have backups on other local drives and remote services[1], but this could still be his primary store. It isn't like holding the text of books in progress is a task that needs the speediest of SSDs so if that drive just kept working why would he replace it? [1] presumably these have also been purged if his wishes were so written or interpreted, probably by more conventional means[2] [2] the bulldozer being used for this one drive for ceremonial purposes
- paulajohnson 9y agoI have mixed feelings about this. On the one hand this was his wish, but on the other hand I am sure that future generations of pratchettologists will mourn the loss.
- laumars 9y agoAs a Pratchett fan I welcome his wish as it means his legacy is left as he had intended it to be written.
- loopbit 9y agoNot only that, there's one of his (many) quotes that fits nicely with this way of thinking: "I save about twenty drafts — that's ten meg of disc space — and the last one contains all the final alterations. Once it has been printed out and received by the publishers, there's a cry here of 'Tough shit, literary researchers of the future, try getting a proper job!' and the rest are wiped." On one hand, as a long time Pratchett fan, it would be interesting to see what ideas he was working on (I'll miss many of his characters), on the other hand and looking at other examples (cough, cough, Tolkien, cough), I prefer his legacy to be what it is today.
- mcv 9y agoI just read an article about George R.R. Martin's writing process, and apparently he's done some extreme rewrites to some of his books, and submitted all his intermediary manuscripts to some archive. As for Tolkien, I'm quite happy that the Silmarillion got published.
- paulajohnson 9y agoIts not just about the release of an unfinished novel with lots of rough edges, its our understanding of how the Diskworld evolved in Pterry's mind over the years. TCOM was a simple spoof of swords-and-sorcery epics, but by Going Postal it had become a complex world that fused magic with steampunk. The rough drafts, abandoned dead-ends and private notes that presumably inhabited those disk drives would have provided insights into how this happened. Update: just read loopbit's response to the same post. Good point.
- orf 9y agoThat's one way to clear your internet history after you die.
- inDigiNeous 9y agoWell to be honest his more recent books started to be more dull in a way, although I respect deeply his work, especially with the earlier books, but maybe the alzheimer started to have an effect also on his writing. I've read most of his works until Snuff or so, but those 3 - 5 books before that just really didn't had the same magic anymore, so maybe it's for the best.
- cm2012 9y agoI thought Unseen Academicals was his best book.
- c17r 9y agoI found Discworld by starting with Unseen Academicals that I picked up at Düsseldorf waiting for my flight home from a business trip. I had it finished by the time the car service dropped me off at home.
- potus_putin 9y agoI understand from the Guardian article that the last two books ( and possibly more ) were ghostwritten.
- c17r 9y agoTerry had Ocular Alzheimer's disease. He "wrote" by either dictating to Rob or using speech recognition software.
- SamBam 9y agoAbsolutely the writing quality had started to diminish -- it was at the point that I just felt sadness, and that I was doing Pratchett a disservice to even read his later books, as I think the Pratchett of 10 years ago wouldn't have wanted them to be written, if he knew.
- jff 9y agoAgreed; 'Raising Steam' made me so sad I couldn't finish it (I thought it was a much better story when titled 'Making Money', and even better when it was called 'Going Postal').
- ainiriand 9y agoIf anyone believes that the REAL HD was destroyed then he/she doesn't know how business work. PS: I would have destroyed the shit out of that HD.
- mcv 9y agoWhat makes one HD more real than any other? Terry was fairly tech savvy. Would he not have kept backups?
- clarkevans 9y agoI've found Ursla Vernon (http://www.redwombatstudio.com/ http://www.redwombatstudio.com/) to be a witty and lucid writer much in the spirit of Sir. Pratchett.
- aqsalose 9y agoI throughly enjoyed the webcomic Digger [1]. I didn't realize the author had so many other works published on the internet and in print. Thank you for this pointer! [1] http://diggercomic.com/ http://diggercomic.com/
- robg 9y agoTo save you the click - That's what he wanted.
- joosters 9y agoGood to see his wishes fulfilled. In the end, it was his choice and no-one else's. In comparison, Douglas Adams' remaining incomplete notes were turned into a book after he died (The Salmon Of Doubt). As a fan, it was frustrating to read - you could see his moments of genius, but the gaps in the story and the unrefined parts of the text were a let down. I gladly bought the book, but after finishing it, I'm not sure it was a good choice to publish the unfinished writings. If an author had a very-nearly complete book, I reckon it might be worthwhile to let someone else do the final tidying up and publish, but if Terry Pratchett's remaining works were lots of partially complete writings, I think it would be a poor reflection on the author to let someone else work on them.
- exit 9y agoi don't follow how it reflects poorly on the author. maybe it reflects poorly on our grasp of the creative processes.
- michaelt 9y agoBrands tend to get a bad reputation if they have some good quality products and some bad quality ones and only small print to tell them apart.
- vidarh 9y agoFor something like Salmon of Doubt there was far more than small print to tell them apart, though. It was not a half finished book as much as a half finished fragment of one preceded by a substantial section that acted as an eulogy to Adams. As such I think it was worthwhile. I agree with you that if a work is published and presented as just another one of their novels it is different.
- lproven 9y agoA fair point. I would have liked to see what his existing writing partners -- Neil Gaiman or Stephen Baxter, for instance -- could have done. But it's not what he wanted.
- rusk 9y agoFranz Kafka had similar wishes, that his friend was to destroy all his work. I can't say I'm "glad" per se that he didn't since such emotions are antithetical to Kafka, but I suppose it is for the best, culturally that his friend went ahead and published them ... I suppose it's a little different given Pratchett's stuff here was "unfinished" tho Kafka could have argued all his stuff was unfinished too ...
- pasquinelli 9y agomost of kafka's writing was clearly unfinished.
- probably_wrong 9y agoI like to compare Kafka to James Joyce. With Kafka, we got great novels out of the postumous publication. The publication of Joyce's letters to Nora Barnacle, however, paint him as someone who "[fastens] intently on peculiarities of sexual behaviour, some of which might be technically called perverse"[1]. No one has really benefited from their publication, except perhaps gossip columns. I think I would stick to the author's desires. As great as Kafka's work is, I don't think we are "entitled" to them. But I can understand the opposing point too. [1] Richard Ellmann, Selected Letters of James Joyce, Introduction, Faber & Faber, London, 1975
- imchillyb 9y agoDamn those Hyperspace bypasses!
- infinite8s 9y agoYou've got the wrong author. You are thinking of Douglas Adams.
- b4ux1t3 9y agoEh, same vein of humor. I'll allow it.
- paulpauper 9y agoi'm sure it could still be recovered through forensic means from the pieces if one really wanted to
- SamBam 9y agoI'd like to imagine that the steamroller was driven by Nomes.
- excalibur 9y agoThis is dramatic and certainly renders the drive itself useless, but this is not how you securely destroy data. The bits on those platters are still largely recoverable. Do Terry a favor and run that drive over a degausser (or at least a really big magnet) before putting it in a museum. And let everyone know you did it. Remove the temptation for someone to steal it, attempt a forensic recovery, and try to sell unfinished Terry Pratchett novels that the author never intended to see the light of day.
- Johnny555 9y agoThat sounds like a lot of money to spend to get fragments of notes for an unfinished book that you can't even sell as "Terry Pratchett's Unfinished Book" because his estate would sue you. Not to mention the legal risk of stealing the hard drive fragments then publicly admitting that you did it when you publish your book.
- excalibur 9y agoWell when step one is "steal hard drive from museum", you can assume that the sale and (initial) distribution are unlikely to be conducted above-board. Depending on one's access to sophisticated forensic tools, this may still be a difficult undertaking to extract any profit from. But money isn't the only possible motive.
- rootw0rm 9y agoAnyone else here ever play the Discworld MUD? Highly recommended.
- forkLding 9y agoTerry Pratchett was one of my most favourite authors, it's rare to see someone keep building up a universe that both my elderly teachers and me as a student could appreciate during high school. Moreover, I wish there were more movie adaptations than what they have now. Also seems so long ago, I used to play Discworld MUD and relive the stories on there as well. And now Terry has passed away (RIP, hope you're having fun with Death) and Discworld is off on its own, floating on a turtle somewhere. I have to be honest, I would read some Discworld fan fiction just to see those familiar characters again.
- rootw0rm 9y agohell yeah, it's a pretty kickass MUD.