4 ms·
If you don't test both kinds of diagnostics on the same patients, that doesn't sound the same at all? As another example, if you have a ten-question survey, as
by skybrian 9y ago
If you don't test both kinds of diagnostics on the same patients, that doesn't sound the same at all?
As another example, if you have a ten-question survey, asking 1000 people one question is not the same as asking 100 people all ten questions. You don't learn nearly as much about the correlation between answers to different questions.
- euyyn 9y agoAssume the patients are assigned to the doctors in a way that's not affected by whether they have the condition or not (e.g. at random). If the screening question doesn't lead to over-diagnosis, then you'd expect the same ratio of positives/negatives from both sets. You need more subjects to attain the same statistical power, but the data is much easier to obtain. 100 subjects already sounded like overkill anyway.
- YawningAngel 9y agoIt doesn't strictly pertain to his hypothesis, but presumably you would like data on false positives and negatives as well as overall outcome percentages.
- euyyn 9y agoGranted. But to get that you need to jump many more hurdles (which are there for good reasons).