4 ms·
What about for non-humans? Consider a dog that lives with a musician who plays, for example, trumpet. The musician plays the trumpet at home to practice, and a
by tzs 9y ago
What about for non-humans?
Consider a dog that lives with a musician who plays, for example, trumpet. The musician plays the trumpet at home to practice, and also records his practices to review.
A trumpet produces significant acoustic energy out to about 100 KHz [1]. When the musician plays live the dog hears a rich musical instrument. When the musician plays back his recordings, half the frequency range that the dog could hear in the live trumpet will be gone. I'd imagine that this makes the recorded trumpet a lot less aesthetically pleasing to the poor dog.
[1] https://www.cco.caltech.edu/~boyk/spectra/spectra.htm https://www.cco.caltech.edu/~boyk/spectra/spectra.htm
- QAPereo 9y agoIn my experience as a long time trumpet playing dog owner, the dog is generally thrilled when there is less richness in the noise, and generally less trumpet playing period. I say this with experience owning many dogs and having played the trumpet in a range from really badly and inexpertly, to pretty good... they don't care. Trumpets in person are just way too loud and a bit too much in general for most dogs.
- 72deluxe 9y agoAnd perhaps too loud for humans? I only say this because most people are happy listening to music on CDs but when in the presence of a live band (eg an orchestra) it is suddenly obvious how incredibly loud it is. My brother is a drummer and I find it incredibly loud; I am a bass player and I don't play loud although he sometimes complains that there's "too much bass". Perhaps we just go deaf in our relative audio spectrum.
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoHow do we know that the trumpet still sounds harmonically pleasing above 20 kHz? It may sound nice to the human ear, and a horrible mess to anyone with ultrasonic hearing capabilities. Have we asked the dogs?
- kazinator 9y agoIf we boost the frequencies even in just the range 10-20 kHz, things sound harsh and fizzy to the human ear. The frequencies there are no longer musical in the sense of being recognized as musical notes. That is to say, although in a pure arithmetic sense, frequency 148080 is an A, since it is a power of two multiple of 440; five octaves above it, we don't hear it as an A tone. The frequencies in that ballpark just have to be present to add a sense of "definition" or "crispness" or "air" to the sound. In fact, this can be faked! In the OPUS codec, there is something called SBC: spectral band compression. What this refers to is basically a hack whereby the upper harmonics of the signal are completely stripped away, and then re-synthesized on the other end based on a duplicate of the lower harmonics or something like that. The listener just hears the increased definition.
- peatmoss 9y agoWhat about transhumans? I'm looking forward to my HiFi Cochleatron 9000(tm) when my hearing starts to go. Then I'll be mighty glad we made all these high-res recordings.
- exikyut 9y agoThat makes for some genuinely interesting thought experiments. What if, this actually becomes possible, but we discover that because we previously couldn't hear these frequencies, our instruments and equipment are HORRIBLY mis-tuned and sound terrible? We may end up having to re-record tons of stuff. Something something premature optimization. And part of me is glad that the art of hand-making instruments is not yet lost; we might need the originals in the future. Disclaimer: I say this as a completely naive person when it comes to instruments. The answer to this may be "if it wasn't built to resonate at frequency X, it won't by itself," which would be a good thing.
- photojosh 9y agoHigher frequencies aren't even in most recordings, so we wouldn't have to re-record them for that reason. And if they were (such as in 96 kHz hi-res audio), you could just run it through a low-pass filter to strip off the higher frequencies.
- exikyut 9y agoAh, good point. And... heh, using a filter to strip out the audio we used all that extra filesize to deliberately store. Haha. :)
- photojosh 9y agoMy webapp manages photos for photography competitions. People upload 30MB JPEGs that would be visually lossless at a tenth of that file size. And I keep the originals, but actually resize down to 300KB for every function within the software. Haven't had a single complaint about image quality... :)
- BurningFrog 9y agoThe human has trained hard for years to master an instrument that has been perfected over centuries. Both those huge efforts has gone into controlling the humanly audible part of the sound. Whatever sound is accidentally produced in other frequencies is probably at best aesthetically neutral, but more likely distracting. Though my guess trumpeting is just noise to dogs either way.
- kazinator 9y ago> What about for non-humans? The thing is, the higher sample rate data doesn't actually have a lot of the higher components after 20 kHz. What the faster sample rate allows is to use a less aggressive filter. Instead of a "brick wall" filter that rapidly cuts off after around 20 kHz, one with fewer poles can be used which rolls off more gently. The higher sample rate ensures that there isn't any aliasing. 192 kHz audio does not reproduce flat up to 90 kHz. (I'm going to gloss over the microphone used on the trumpet, or the loudspeakers which ultimately reproduce it.)