3 ms·
Off topic, but I've noticed in the gym, sometimes the music playing from the instructor's iPhone through one of those cheap Ion Block Rocker bluetooth speakers
by rconti 9y ago
Off topic, but I've noticed in the gym, sometimes the music playing from the instructor's iPhone through one of those cheap Ion Block Rocker bluetooth speakers (big boxy one, looks like a guitar amp) has very very noticeable pitch sag in various parts of various songs.
It's via bluetooth, and the source is Pandora. I even googled Pandora and pitch change, and found some forums with folks discussing bluetooth causing this to happen, which has never been my experience.
It occurred to me that slowing the playback (eg, causing the pitch to sag) could be a fantastic way of dealing with a connection that's too slow. It would be far better than stuttering, even though many of us would find the pitch change really annoying. The instructor and my wife simply can't hear it, or say "I thought that was just part of the song".
Anyway, has anyone ever heard of this happening? Do certain products do it? Were the Pandora forums wrong and this is actually a Pandora problem? Of all of the bluetooth problems I've had in my life, I've never experienced this before, so I tend to lean towards it being a data rate issue on the cell connection and Pandora slowing the music down.
- jaquers 9y agoAt my greatest aspiration, I'm no more than a casual music listener - however I am very conscious of pitch. On more than one occasion, I've noticed that a song I'm familiar with seems off pitch, as in lower or higher key than I think of it in my head - and I seem to notice that particularly around shitty speakers or bluetooth or some combination of the two. Glad to know I'm not crazy :) To your point, I would lean towards bluetooth as I've never associated the phenomena with Pandora. My friends and I mostly use Spotify.
- rconti 9y agoI use spotify as well. And what I describe is a sag for 5 or 10 or 15 seconds, not just a song that's playing too slowly. it's really weird.
- colejohnson66 9y agoOr people who pirate their music by ripping YouTube videos that are just the songs pitch shifted to avoid automated copyright strikes
- 72deluxe 9y agoWould it perhaps be because the bluetooth speakers typically cannot reproduce bass below a certain range and so play the harmonics of the bass note or use the resonance of the item they are placed on to "produce" the bass note? In truth you are not hearing the bass note - you are hearing the harmonics and your brain is making up the missing low note.
- com2kid 9y ago> Off topic, but I've noticed in the gym, sometimes the music playing from the instructor's iPhone through one of those cheap Ion Block Rocker bluetooth speakers (big boxy one, looks like a guitar amp) has very very noticeable pitch sag in various parts of various songs. Many Bluetooth speakers are not loseless. Cheaper ones are likely going to support MP3 and that's it (or even worse, just the minimum required SBC). Pandora is already compressed, if your instructor doesn't know to flip the "HQ sound" toggle (which is turned off by default on Mobile, even with a paid subscription!), then 128kbit MP3 recompressed to MP3 yet again, is going to sound pretty atrocious. Not sure if one of the other codecs used for A2DP can cause pitch changes though.