3 ms·
The argument in favor of the tests: https://www.siumed.edu/pr/highlights/game-changer-herpes-vaccine-shows-promise.html https://www.siumed.edu/pr/highlights/gam
by tim333 9y ago
The argument in favor of the tests: https://www.siumed.edu/pr/highlights/game-changer-herpes-vaccine-shows-promise.html https://www.siumed.edu/pr/highlights/game-changer-herpes-vac...
Excerpts:
>“Many of the virus vaccines we currently put in our kids — chickenpox, mumps, measles and rubella — were developed using live-attenuated viruses in the ’50s, ’60s and ’70s when the regulatory landscape was more relaxed,” he says, “and they have worked remarkably well.”
In the United States, a noticeable shift in research focus occurred around the time of the Belmont Report, published in 1978, which summarized ethical principles and guidelines for research involving human subjects. The FDA began erring on the side of caution, and expediency became a casualty of the government’s procedures.
>Dr. Halford feels the relative risk is fairly clear-cut.
“Relative risk is not a new concept,” says Halford. “Our technology is much better today, yet within first-world countries the mindset for developing vaccines has moved away from relative risk and toward the legal approach that asks ‘Is there any risk whatsoever?’” Dr. Halford smiles. “There’s risk when you walk out the door each day.”
He believes the more humane, common-sense approach weighs the risk of testing a vaccine candidate versus the risk of doing nothing.
“For example, in 2016 we know that about 60 million people will get newly infected by HSV-1 and 2—about a million people per week—and 2 to 3 percent are going to progress to a lifetime of chronic disease,” he says. “Many of those people will face a lifetime of never-ending isolation and pain caused by a chronic herpes infection. These can also have devastating effects on the psyche of patients.”
“So, do we run a small trial using something that’s been proven safe on animals for the past 20 years or do we sit on the sidelines?” he asks. “If we sit on the sidelines, people suffer.”