8 ms·
It is kinda surreal that a company obeying the law is headline news. Note that they appear to have responded on the final day allowed. Throughout this process,
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
It is kinda surreal that a company obeying the law is headline news.
Note that they appear to have responded on the final day allowed. Throughout this process, Google has repeatedly asked for extensions to review the claims or come up with a response for all of these cases. It seems like, knowing the result, Google has attempted to draw out this process as long as legally possible. The PR damage from keeping this case ongoing presumably pales in comparison to the profit from their unlawful conduct.
- tareqak 9y agoI find it interesting how the fiduciary duty towards shareholders given priority over obeying the law. My initial instinct is to basically assume that the former requires the latter in some way.
- charlesdm 9y agoThe fine makes it worth complying. It's 5% of global daily revenue per day, which is significant. It's also not tax deductible. If the fine would be $10,000 a day, Google wouldn't care.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoThere's no fiduciary duty to maximize profits for shareholders. Google was under no legal obligation to break the law here.
- dmitrygr 9y agoIs your name Wesley Mouch by chance?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI don't read Rand so I couldn't tell you. But corporate fiduciary duty is extremely misunderstood. Google would not have violated any fiduciary duty by refusing to engage in the actions which have attracted this attention and it would not have violated any fiduciary duty by fessing up and paying the fine. EDIT: after reading the conservapedia entry on Wesley I found this comment a lot funnier. Unfortunately I couldn't be Mouch, it was said of him that "What I like most about you, Mouch, is that you do not talk too much" and I don't think anyone has ever accused me of that. (:
- tareqak 9y agoSorry then, my understanding was incorrect. I'm not sure where to look for the precise definition of "fiduciary". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiduciary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiduciary fiduciary: A fiduciary is a person who holds a legal or ethical relationship of trust with one or more other parties (person or group of persons). http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=744 http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=744 fiduciary: 1) n. from the Latin fiducia, meaning "trust," a person (or a business like a bank or stock brokerage) who has the power and obligation to act for another (often called the beneficiary) under circumstances which require total trust, good faith and honesty. 2) adj. defining a situation or relationship in which a person is acting as a fiduciary for another. http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=745 http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=745 fiduciary relationship: n. where one person places complete confidence in another in regard to a particular transaction or one's general affairs or business. http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=599 http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=599 duty of care: n. a requirement that a person act toward others and the public with the watchfulness, attention, caution and prudence that a reasonable person in the circumstances would use.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_judgment_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_judgment_rule So the business judgment rule isn't where any normal person would want to start on this topic, but I think it's wikipedia article probably is the best in terms of defining a few things and then linking you to more resources.
- tareqak 9y agoThanks frgtpsswrdlame! It is definitely hard to have any meaningful discussion without agreeing on the vocabulary to use.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 9y ago> It is kinda surreal that a company obeying the law is headline news. It is like a construction company advertising they have built the house "up to code". Maybe it sounds good to them, to me that sounds like "we've done the absolute minimum required and would have majorly cut corners had it not be for those pesky rules about fire safety and such getting in the way".
- icebraining 9y agoHow is Google "advertising" anything? Have they bought Bloomberg recently?
- summer_steven 9y ago> It is kinda surreal that a company obeying the law is headline news. That is an unreal level of politicking. You can't see any reason why companies might prefer to pay a fine than obey a law? If you lived in an HOA, and that HOA mandated that all your lawn ornaments must be bright pink by next week, how eager would you be to comply by next week? If the fine for non-compliance was only $1 per year, would you prefer to pay the fine? I'm trying to illustrate that companies are made up of human beings, not monsters.
- kuschku 9y agoThe right to start, and own, a company, exists only so that they can provide a benefit for all of society (as specified in the German constitution and the EU treaties). According to the same documents, if a company decides to intentionally violate democratically created laws, or decided to hurt society, their right to exist as company can be eliminated, and their property can be seized. If you disagree with a community’s decision, you can lobby to have them changed, or you can move elsewhere – but you can’t, just because you disagree, disobey them. Or you’ll have to expect that if you try to disobey their decisions, they’ll respond accordingly. I’m not suggesting anything a society should do as response to a foreign company arriving there, violating laws, and refusing to obey, but generally this simply ends up bad for the company. I disagree with IP laws, but I can’t just pirate content and sell remixes either, by hiding behind a shell corporation. Not even if I’m willing to pay the fine (Kim Dotcom, for example, made enough profit that he was able, and willing to pay the license fees, and still would have turned a profit, but this was denied).
- tannhaeuser 9y ago> The right to start, and own, a company, exists only so that they can provide a benefit for all of society (as specified in the German constitution and the EU treaties). Citation needed
- tannhaeuser 9y agoHey downvoters, show me the place where these documents say something to the effect that the right to start and own a company exists only so that they can provide a benefit for all of society or even that an EU member state, not to speak of an EU institution, can grant or revoke such rights. [1]: https://www.bundestag.de/grundgesetz https://www.bundestag.de/grundgesetz The text of the German consitution law [2]: https://europa.eu/european-union/law/treaties_en https://europa.eu/european-union/law/treaties_en The text of the EU treaties
- ars 9y agoIt's headline news when the law is not only ridiculous, but protectionist, and inconsistently followed. It's pretty obvious that the EU is only doing this because Google is a US company. I am quite sure that google considered simply pulling entirely out of Europe. It wouldn't affect them as much as you think - it's the internet, you can run a website from anywhere. And it's not like the EU would prevent their citizens from buying ads from Google, so their revenues would not be affected all that much. Their EU sales force could be through a third party (so that Google would not have any assets in the EU). All that Google would lose is EU employees. The bare fact this this plan I am outlining is even worth considering rather than bow to the EU demands tells you a lot.
- Oletros 9y ago> It's pretty obvious that the EU is only doing this because Google is a US company. If it is obvious, it will be easy to explain the reasons for it > I am quite sure that google considered simply pulling entirely out of Europe. It wouldn't affect them as much as you think - it's the internet, you can run a website from anywhere. I'm quite sure that Google is glad to not have people like you as CEO. > And it's not like the EU would prevent their citizens from buying ads from Google Tell me how a company like Google, or Apple or Microsoft can do business with the EU without being there. And please, no't give nonsensical reasons like internet is everywhere, that just shows that you don't know much about economy.
- thejynxed 9y agoThey did it quite easily prior to when certain EU nations decided to give them massive tax breaks (up to and including zero tax) if they located offices and production facilities in their nations, so your last point is moot. Until then, they didn't have offices in the EU because there was no point in sinking that kind of money into countries that would just tax you to death for little in return.
- Oletros 9y agoPlease, can you give any information of any of those companies working for EU customers without having any presence in the EU?
- pitaj 9y agoTo people who agree with Google that this was the wrong ruling, or disagree with the law in general, this kind of announcement might be real news to them. For instance, if a marijuana company sliced that it would be shutting it's doors to comply with US federal law, I'd very much want to know about it.
- DocTomoe 9y ago> It is kinda surreal that a company obeying the law is headline news. "That's a nice company improving lives everywhere on the world you have there. It would be so regrettable if something ... happened to it."
- oblio 9y agoWhile Google is definitely nice and useful, I think that they, just like any company, are trying to "improve" their bottom line. And they seem to be doing just fine without also trying to do shady stuff: https://www.forbes.com/pictures/mlf45kijd/google/#10b28b8029a8 https://www.forbes.com/pictures/mlf45kijd/google/#10b28b8029...
- DocTomoe 9y agoThat is an image of two painters in protective clothing painting a Streetview car at the CeBit as an art project a few years ago (2010?). What do you want to tell me with that? Also, what is wrong with a company which improves lives to also improve it's bottom line? I prefer that to an openly hostile company who destroys life that improves it's bottom line.
- ionised 9y ago>Also, what is wrong with a company which improves lives to also improve it's bottom line? Nothing as long as it obeys the laws of the countries in which it operates.
- DocTomoe 9y agoAre you familiar with legal theorist Gustav Radebruch, who defined a rule ("Radebruch Formula") that essentially came down to the idea that an unbearably unjust law may never be followed?
- ionised 9y agoYes, which is why I will happily consume LSD and MDMA ins pite of whatever the laws of my country may be. You're suggesting however that the EU laws are unjust because Google and perhaps others opted to not follow them. Can't say I agree at all. By that same logic the laws and regulations governing the financial services industry were unjust because banks the world over opted not to follow them, resulting in the financial crash of 2007/2008. Even just laws aren't followed by individuals or organisations that realise they can make a lot money by not following it, so I'm not sure the point you are trying to make holds any weight. Sometimes breaking a law and paying the pathetic fine afterwards is just the cost of doing business, which is why I usually argue for genuinely punitive damages and prison time (like in the case of the banks for example).